WA regulator investigates big batteries over 'unusual' pricing behaviour

ERA confirms inquiry into coordinated charging that pushed spot prices higher, raising concerns about market manipulation

edit
By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
Western Australia's economic regulator has launched an investigation into the pricing activities of the state's fleet of large-scale batteries, following episodes where coordinated charging appeared to drive up wholesale electricity prices. Economic Regulation Authority (ERA) chair Steve Edwell confirmed the agency was probing 'unusual behaviours' in the market, with a particular incident seeing spot prices spike from $120 to more than $350 per megawatt hour after midnight charging by batteries owned by state-controlled utility Synergy.

The inquiries target the owners of WA's growing battery fleet — Synergy and French firm Neoen — and come amid mounting scrutiny from the Australian Energy Market Operator as well. Large-scale battery capacity in WA's main grid has surged from negligible levels to about 1400MW in recent years, with batteries now meeting more than 20 per cent of peak demand and sometimes supplying over a third of power. More notably, batteries set the price in the grid more than 90 per cent of the time.

Mr Edwell said batteries had become an instrumental part of the power system, capable of storing renewable energy when surplus and supplying it when scarce, delivering benefits to consumers. But he signalled those benefits were not guaranteed. 'We have been actively undertaking enquiries on these matters, as we always do when we see unusual behaviours or unexpected outcomes in the wholesale electricity market,' he said. 'Where we suspect non-compliance with the Electricity System and Market Rules, we will investigate and take compliance action. These batteries are an important part of the energy transition, but only if we maintain a well-functioning market.'

In one reported episode, coordinated charging by all of Synergy's batteries shortly after midnight propelled spot prices from $120 to more than $350 per megawatt hour. One market player, not authorised to speak publicly, said the incident was one of many in which Synergy's batteries seemed to be driving prices materially higher. While prices in WA's short-term market account for only about 10 per cent of electricity traded — most is done via direct contracts — experts say they are a vital indicator of underlying supply-demand tightness. Observers also note that prices are highest in winter, when wind and solar output are at seasonal lows.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Higher wholesale electricity costs can eventually flow through to consumer bills, even though most power is sold via direct contracts.
  • The investigation tests whether the rapid growth of battery storage, essential for integrating renewables, is compatible with competitive market rules.
  • The outcome could set a precedent for how battery operators are regulated across Australia's energy markets.

Background

Large-scale battery capacity in Western Australia's main grid has grown rapidly, from virtually nothing a few years ago to about 1400MW. These batteries are now critical for meeting peak demand and stabilising the grid as more renewable generation comes online. However, their ability to strategically charge and discharge — often at the same time — has raised questions about whether they are exploiting market design to maximise profits rather than simply providing grid services.

Key Perspectives

Battery operators (Synergy and Neoen): Likely argue that their charging behaviour is commercially rational and within market rules, responding to price signals to store energy when cheap and sell when expensive, which is the intended function of batteries. Regulator (ERA): Concerned about unusual pricing patterns that may indicate coordinated behaviour or non-compliance with market rules, and is investigating to ensure a well-functioning market. Critics / Market participants: Some players see the coordinated midnight charging as artificially inflating prices, driving up costs unnecessarily and potentially undermining trust in the market.

What to Watch

  • Any formal compliance action or enforcement by the ERA against Synergy or Neoen.
  • Whether the Australian Energy Market Operator introduces new rules or guidelines for battery charging behaviour.
  • Continued monitoring of winter spot prices, when supply-demand tightness is greatest and battery influence is most pronounced.

Sources

newspaper

Zotpaper

Articles published under the Zotpaper byline are synthesized from multiple source publications by our AI editor and reviewed by our editorial process. Each story combines reporting from credible outlets to give readers a balanced, comprehensive view.