BHP faces union anger over board pay rise as Pilbara job cuts loom

ETU calls chairman's increase an 'affront to decency' days after up to 300 redundancies announced

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
BHP has defended an increase in board pay approved at its annual general meeting, after the Electrical Trades Union accused the mining giant of inflating directors' packages just days after flagging up to 300 job cuts at its Pilbara iron ore operations.

The remuneration report passed with more than 98 per cent support at the AGM this week. It recommended lifting the group chair's base payment to US$1,058,200 and board members' base payments to US$193,000.

Last week, BHP confirmed redundancies affecting up to 300 jobs at South Flank, Mining Area C, Newman and Jimblebar. The company said it regularly reviews how it can operate "safely, effectively and productively."

ETU WA secretary Adam Woodage said: "People working on the ground in the Pilbara made a sizable chunk of BHP's $15 billion dollar profit last year. The company has decided it will reward 300 of them with unemployment. Members of the board of directors moved a total of zero tonnes of iron ore last year."

He said the increase put the chair on a base of more than $1.5 million, described it as a 10 per cent rise, and accused BHP of having "one rule for board directors, and another for working people."

A BHP spokesperson said: "We are making some changes to ensure our WA iron ore business can continue to make a significant contribution to the Pilbara and WA and continue to be a major employer in the State. As we always do, we will seek to redeploy people into other roles elsewhere in the business where possible. We will be working directly with our people on what this change means for them."

Woodage also said wages and conditions at BHP's iron ore operations had gone backwards against the consumer price index and the market for more than a decade, and that electricians could earn more on construction sites in Perth and see their families each night. BHP and the Combined Ports Unions, which include the ETU, the Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union and the Western Mine Workers Alliance, are in a pay dispute that led to strike action in Port Hedland earlier this year. The unions have voted for protected industrial action.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The planned redundancies and the board pay rise land together, intensifying scrutiny of BHP's treatment of workers while the company reports large profits.
  • The dispute involves port workers who can disrupt iron ore exports, a significant part of WA's economy.
  • The outcome could set a benchmark for wages and conditions in the Pilbara mining sector.

Background

BHP is in an industrial dispute with the Combined Ports Unions, made up of the ETU, the Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union and the Western Mine Workers Alliance. The unions voted for protected industrial action over pay, leading to strikes in Port Hedland earlier this year. The dispute centres on wage discrepancies in the current workforce. BHP says it regularly reviews its operations and will seek to redeploy affected employees.

Key Perspectives

Electrical Trades Union: Secretary Adam Woodage says the pay increase is an affront to decency, that workers generated BHP's profit while board members moved no iron ore, and that wages have fallen behind inflation and the market.

BHP: The company says it regularly reviews operations, that changes are needed to keep its WA iron ore business contributing to the Pilbara and WA, and that it will try to redeploy workers.

Shareholders: More than 98 per cent of votes at the AGM supported the remuneration report, showing broad investor backing for the board's pay proposals despite union opposition.

What to Watch

  • Whether BHP and the Combined Ports Unions can settle the wages dispute or further strikes are called.
  • How many of the up to 300 flagged roles are actually cut and how many workers are redeployed.
  • Any signs of disruption to iron ore shipments from Port Hedland.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 9 supported.

Show each claim
  1. Not in the sourcesBHP defended the board-pay increase.The Age - Latest News: “A BHP spokesperson said the company regularly reviews how it works to ensure it can operate safely, effectively and productively.”
  2. Partly supportedThe AGM approved the board-pay increase.The Age - Latest News: “shareholders voted for several resolutions, including the adoption of the company’s remuneration report, which passed with a majority of more than 98 per cent. ... Included in the report was a recommendation to increase the base payments for the group chair to US$1,058,200 and for board members to US$193,000.”
  3. Partly supportedThe ETU called the chairman’s increase an “affront to decency.”The Age - Latest News: “ETU WA secretary Adam Woodage said the decision to inflate board pay packets only days after announcing a decision to eliminate 300 positions in mining operations was an affront to decency.”
  4. SupportedPilbara job cuts loom.The Age - Latest News: “It comes after the miner announced last week that as many as 300 jobs will be impacted by a round of redundancies at BHP’s Pilbara mine sites.”
  5. SupportedThe remuneration report passed with more than 98 per cent support at the AGM.The Age - Latest News: “shareholders voted for several resolutions, including the adoption of the company’s remuneration report, which passed with a majority of more than 98 per cent.”
  6. SupportedThe report recommended base payments of US$1,058,200 for the group chair and US$193,000 for board members.The Age - Latest News: “Included in the report was a recommendation to increase the base payments for the group chair to US$1,058,200 and for board members to US$193,000.”
  7. SupportedUp to 300 jobs were affected by redundancies at South Flank, Mining Area C, Newman and Jimblebar.The Age - Latest News: “Last week a BHP spokesperson confirmed the job cuts at its South Flank, Mining Area C, Newman and Jimblebar operations. It comes after the miner announced last week that as many as 300 jobs will be impacted by a round of redundancies at BHP’s Pilbara mine sites.”
  8. SupportedWoodage said the chair’s base would be more than $1.5 million and described the increase as 10 per cent.The Age - Latest News: ““The company has decided they need a 10 per cent increase – one that puts the chair of the board on more than $1.5 million as a base.””
  9. SupportedWoodage said Pilbara workers made a sizable chunk of BHP’s $15 billion profit last year and that board members moved zero tonnes of iron ore.The Age - Latest News: ““People working on the ground in the Pilbara made a sizable chunk of BHP’s $15 billion dollar profit last year,” he said. “The company has decided it will reward 300 of them with unemployment. “Members of the board of directors moved a total of zero tonnes of iron ore last year.””
  10. SupportedBHP said it would seek to redeploy workers where possible and work directly with them about the changes.The Age - Latest News: ““As we always do, we will seek to redeploy people into other roles elsewhere in the business where possible. We will be working directly with our people on what this change means for them.””
  11. SupportedWoodage said BHP iron ore wages and conditions had gone backwards against CPI and the market for more than a decade.The Age - Latest News: “Woodage said wages and conditions at BHP’s iron ore operations have gone backwards against CPI and against the market for more than a decade.”
  12. SupportedA pay dispute between BHP and the Combined Ports Unions led to strike action in Port Hedland earlier this year, and the unions voted for protected industrial action.The Age - Latest News: “The iron ore company and workers from the Combined Ports Unions, made up of members from the Electrical Trades Union, the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union and the Western Mine Workers Alliance, are currently involved in a pay dispute that led to multiple strike action in Port Hedland earlier this year. ... with the unions voting for protected industrial action.”

Zotpaper

Written by June Katz on the Business & markets desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source9 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe