Egypt's press union chief defiant in defence of six detained journalists

Syndicate files torture complaint while pro-government critics accuse it of backing a 'terrorist'-linked outlet

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
The head of Egypt's Journalists Syndicate, Khaled Elbalshy, has vowed to keep fighting for press freedom after the union came under fire for defending six journalists detained last month and charged with joining a "terrorist" group, while separately filing a complaint alleging the detainees were tortured.

The head of Egypt's Journalists Syndicate has insisted the organisation will continue to fight for press freedom after it came under fire for defending six journalists detained last month and charged with joining a "terrorist" group.

"What happens to one colleague affects us all, and may happen to others tomorrow," Khaled Elbalshy said in a statement on Sunday. "An infringement of one journalist's freedom is an infringement of everyone's freedom and a weakening of the safeguards protecting that freedom."

His comments came after the syndicate filed a complaint with Egypt's public prosecutor over allegations that the detained journalists, who work for the investigative website Matsadaash, had been tortured. Egyptian authorities denied the accusations, while pro-government commentators criticised the organisation for defending the journalists.

Mohamed Adel, Mohamed Ashraf Abu Emeira, Islam Barakat, Omar Helal, Mohamed Mahmoud and Abdallah Qadry were arrested on September 28 and 29 and have since appeared before the Supreme State Security Prosecution, which handles national security cases. They have been ordered held in pretrial detention for 15 days pending investigations.

Prosecutors have accused the six of working for a media organisation tied to the Muslim Brotherhood, which Egypt has officially designated a "terrorist" group, a designation the organisation strongly denies. The designation follows a 2013 coup against democratically elected President Mohamed Morsi, a Brotherhood member. Matsadaash co-founder Abdelrahman Mansour has rejected any link between the platform and the Muslim Brotherhood.

In his statement, Elbalshy said: "The fundamental principle governing all such matters, particularly when dealing with accused persons in general and vulnerable people in particular, remains that an accused person is innocent until proven guilty."

The Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights (EIPR), whose lawyers represent the six, said the journalists were initially held for five days without contact with their families or lawyers. After complaints, they appeared before prosecutors and were questioned in the presence of their lawyers and a syndicate representative. The EIPR said the journalists are held under Egypt's 2015 Counterterrorism Law, which allows custody before prosecution when "there is a risk of a terrorist crime and a necessity to confront that risk", though the rights group noted the prosecution only alleges the journalists published rumours or "false" reports.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The case tests whether Egypt's Journalists Syndicate, one of the few professional bodies that challenges security prosecutions, can shield journalists from national security charges.
  • The six journalists face renewable 15-day pretrial detention orders under a counterterrorism law that rights groups say is used against critics.
  • Torture allegations, denied by the authorities, raise questions about the treatment of detainees in national security cases.

Background

Egypt has tightly restricted press and political freedoms since the army removed President Mohamed Morsi from power in 2013. The Muslim Brotherhood, Morsi's movement, was designated a terrorist organisation and has been the target of a sustained crackdown. The 2015 Counterterrorism Law gives prosecutors broad powers to hold suspects before trial, and independent outlets have frequently come under pressure. The Journalists Syndicate has historically been one of the few institutions able to contest these cases.

Key Perspectives

Journalists Syndicate: Argues the presumption of innocence applies and that an infringement on one journalist is an infringement on all; filed a torture complaint with the public prosecutor. Egyptian authorities: Deny the torture allegations and accuse the six of publishing false reports for a platform linked to the Muslim Brotherhood. Pro-government commentators: Criticise the syndicate for defending journalists facing national security charges. Rights groups and Matsadaash: The EIPR, which represents the journalists, points to the five-day incommunicado detention as a due process breach; co-founder Abdelrahman Mansour rejects any Brotherhood links.

What to Watch

  • Whether the Supreme State Security Prosecution extends pretrial detention when the current 15-day orders lapse.
  • The public prosecutor's response to the syndicate's torture complaint.
  • Whether criticism of the syndicate escalates into legal or administrative pressure on the union itself.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe