Hezbollah's decision to join Gaza war has permanently weakened its political standing, analysts say

The group's influence in Lebanon has diminished after its leadership was decimated and a new president and government took office with a stronger line against it

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
Hezbollah's decision to join the war on Israel on October 8, 2023, in support of Palestinians has fundamentally reshaped Lebanese politics and left the group politically weakened, according to analysts. The move set off a chain of events that culminated in the September 2024 pager attack, the assassination of much of its leadership, and the election of a president and government that have taken a much stronger line against the once-dominant group.

A day after the October 7, 2023, attack on Israel and the beginning of Israel's war on Gaza, Hezbollah decided to join the conflict, saying it was in support of the Palestinian people. Analysts now say that decision has forever shaped Lebanese politics and dealt a major blow to Hezbollah's standing.

"Hezbollah got sucked into a vortex which culminated in the decapitation of their leadership and the invasion of south Lebanon," Nicholas Blanford, a non-resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and author of a book about Hezbollah, told Al Jazeera. "That dealt Hezbollah a major blow to their popular standing and galvanised the election of Joseph Aoun as president and the formation of a new government that took a much stronger line against [the group]."

Before October 7, Hezbollah was the strongest political and military actor in Lebanon. The Iranian-backed group's influence extended across the region; it was a key ally of the al-Assad regime in Syria and had links with allies in places such as Iraq and Yemen. In Lebanon, Hezbollah had key electoral influence and was not against deploying its supporters against movements opposed to it, as in 2019 when they beat back protesters calling for political reform.

In the months leading up to October 2023, Hezbollah's confidence was on display, with analysts pointing to a military parade in south Lebanon and the group erecting tents in the Shebaa Farms, territory Lebanon considers occupied by Israel. At the time, Israel was roiled by protests, and Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah was delivering speeches predicting Israel's imminent doom. The decision to join the fight against Israel, however, drew the group into a war that it could not control.

Analysts say the group underestimated the depth of Israel's intelligence penetration, which later manifested in the bloody September 2024 pager attack and the assassination of much of Hezbollah's leadership, including Nasrallah. While Hezbollah has not been defeated, despite claims from some critics, it is no longer the political or military hegemon it once was.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The weakening of Hezbollah reshapes the balance of power in Lebanon and the broader Middle East, potentially reducing Iran's influence.
  • The new government under President Joseph Aoun may be able to assert state authority over areas previously controlled by the group, affecting governance and stability.
  • Hezbollah's diminished standing could alter the dynamics of any future conflict with Israel and affect the security of southern Lebanon.

Background

Hezbollah emerged as a major force in Lebanon after the 15-year civil war ended in 1990. It built a powerful military wing and political apparatus, becoming the dominant Shiite faction. For years, it held significant sway over Lebanese governments and used its military to support allies in Syria and elsewhere. Its decision to open a front against Israel in October 2023, however, exposed it to a devastating intelligence war and a ground invasion that eroded its public support and paved the way for a political shift in Beirut.

Key Perspectives

Hezbollah: The group says it joined the war in solidarity with the Palestinian people. It maintains that its resistance is legitimate and that it remains operational despite losses.

Critics and analysts: They argue that Hezbollah overestimated its own strength and underestimated Israeli intelligence, leading to a catastrophic miscalculation. Nicholas Blanford and other experts note that the group's political and military standing has been permanently reduced, allowing a new government to take a tougher line against it.

The new Lebanese government: Under President Joseph Aoun, the government has asserted greater authority, viewing Hezbollah's weakened position as an opportunity to reassert state control over sovereignty and security matters.

What to Watch

  • Whether the new government can maintain its stronger line against Hezbollah without causing internal political crises.
  • The potential for Hezbollah to attempt to rebuild its political influence ahead of scheduled parliamentary elections.
  • Any further Israeli military operations that could exploit Hezbollah's damaged state or provoke a new cycle of escalation.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe