Kikai supervolcano is refilling with fresh magma, study finds

Kobe University team says the reservoir behind Earth's largest Holocene eruption is being recharged from deep below

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
Scientists have found evidence that fresh magma is slowly accumulating beneath Japan's Kikai caldera, a supervolcano that produced the largest known eruption of the past 11,700 years, giving researchers a rare look at how giant volcanic systems rebuild their underground magma supplies.

Researchers from Kobe University, working with the Japan Agency for Marine-Earth Science and Technology (JAMSTEC), used airgun arrays to send seismic pulses through the crust beneath the seafloor around the mostly underwater Kikai caldera, recording the waves with ocean-bottom seismometers. Because seismic waves travel differently through solid rock and molten material, the measurements allowed the team to map structures that cannot be observed directly.

The survey revealed a substantial region containing a high proportion of magma directly beneath the site of Kikai's giant eruption roughly 7,300 years ago. 'Due to its extent and location it is clear that this is in fact the same magma reservoir as in the previous eruption,' said Nobukazu Seama, a Kobe University geophysicist.

The magma now stored there does not appear to be leftover material from that ancient blast. A new lava dome has been developing near the centre of the caldera over approximately the past 3,900 years, and chemical analyses show that material from the dome and other recent activity differs in composition from the giant eruption's output. 'This means that the magma that is now present in the magma reservoir under the lava dome is likely newly injected magma,' Seama said.

The findings, published in Communications Earth & Environment, suggest the reservoir is being recharged by new injections of molten rock from deeper within the crust or mantle. Kikai's underwater location aided the work. 'The underwater location allows us to implement systematic, large-scale surveys,' Seama said.

The recharge process does not mean another catastrophic eruption is imminent, the researchers stress. Rather, it shows how a giant volcanic system can gradually rebuild its magma supply over thousands of years, a step toward understanding how such eruptions become possible. 'We must understand how such large quantities of magma can accumulate to understand how giant caldera eruptions occur,' Seama said.

The team says the re-injection model is consistent with the existence of large shallow magma reservoirs beneath other giant calderas, including Yellowstone in the United States and Toba in Indonesia, and hopes to refine its seismic techniques to track magma movement in greater detail. 'Our ultimate goal is to become better able to monitor the crucial indicators of future giant eruptions.'

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Kikai produced the largest known volcanic eruption of the Holocene about 7,300 years ago; understanding how supervolcanoes recharge is central to assessing future hazards.
  • The study confirms that the same magma storage system involved in that ancient eruption is now being replenished, something scientists had not been able to establish before.
  • The re-injection model may also apply to other giant calderas such as Yellowstone and Toba, potentially improving how their long-term behaviour is interpreted.

Background

Giant caldera volcanoes can erupt far more violently than ordinary volcanoes, releasing so much magma that the ground above the emptied reservoir collapses into a broad depression. Kikai, most of which lies beneath the ocean off southern Japan, last produced such an eruption roughly 7,300 years ago, the largest of the Holocene. Yellowstone and Toba are among the best-known caldera systems, and all are associated with some of the most powerful eruptions in Earth's history. Until now, scientists have had an incomplete picture of how the enormous magma volumes required for these events accumulate underground, which has made it extremely difficult to anticipate when another major eruption might occur.

Key Perspectives

[Researchers (Kobe University and JAMSTEC)]: The seismic and chemical evidence points to newly injected magma occupying the same reservoir that fed Kikai's giant eruption, supporting a model of gradual re-injection from deeper in the crust or mantle. [Hazard assessment]: The team stresses that a refilling reservoir does not mean an eruption is near. The value of the finding lies in learning how recharge unfolds over thousands of years so that the indicators of a future giant eruption can eventually be recognised. [Critics/Skeptics]: The researchers themselves caution that the process does not signal imminent danger, and giant eruptions remain extremely difficult to forecast. The main concern is that a demonstrably recharging supervolcano is still a system to watch, and reliable prediction of when, or whether, it will erupt again remains out of reach.

What to Watch

  • Refinements to the seismic survey method, which the team plans to develop to study how magma is re-injected and stored in greater detail.
  • The lava dome near the centre of the caldera, which has been growing for about 3,900 years and may show further changes in activity.
  • Whether similar re-injection signatures are detected beneath other giant calderas such as Yellowstone and Toba.

Sources

Checked

11 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedKikai is refilling with fresh magma, according to a study.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “One of Earth's most powerful supervolcanoes is slowly refilling its enormous underground magma reservoir”
  2. Partly supportedThe reservoir is being recharged from deep below.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “It suggests that the magma now stored beneath the volcano was supplied by new injections of molten rock from deeper within Earth's crust or mantle”
  3. SupportedKikai produced the largest known volcanic eruption of the Holocene.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Kikai last experienced a giant eruption approximately 7,300 years ago, producing the largest known volcanic eruption of the Holocene”
  4. SupportedSeama said the reservoir is the same one involved in Kikai’s previous eruption.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: ““Due to its extent and location it is clear that this is in fact the same magma reservoir as in the previous eruption,” Seama says.”
  5. SupportedSeama said the magma beneath the lava dome is likely newly injected.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: ““This means that the magma that is now present in the magma reservoir under the lava dome is likely newly injected magma,” summarizes Seama.”
  6. SupportedA new lava dome has been developing near the caldera’s centre for approximately 3,900 years.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Previous investigations revealed that a new lava dome has been developing near the center of the caldera over approximately the past 3,900 years.”
  7. SupportedMaterial from the dome and other recent activity differs in composition from material from the giant eruption.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Chemical analyses also showed that volcanic material from this dome and other more recent activity differs in composition from the material released during Kikai's giant eruption.”
  8. SupportedThe underwater location allows systematic, large-scale surveys.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: ““The underwater location allows us to implement systematic, large-scale surveys,” Seama explains.”
  9. SupportedThe recharge process does not mean another catastrophic eruption is imminent.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “This replenishment process does not mean that another catastrophic eruption is imminent.”
  10. SupportedThe re-injection model is consistent with large shallow reservoirs beneath Yellowstone and Toba.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: ““This magma re-injection model is consistent with the existence of large shallow magma reservoirs beneath other giant calderas like Yellowstone and Toba,” says Seama.”
  11. SupportedSeama’s ultimate goal is to better monitor indicators of future giant eruptions.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: ““Our ultimate goal is to become better able to monitor the crucial indicators of future giant eruptions.””

Zotpaper

Written by June Katz on the Science desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub. Plate by Ollie Flash, picture desk.

1 source10 of 11 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe