OECD chief Cormann warns Australian parties against adopting populist migration caps

Former finance minister urges productivity over populism as One Nation surges to 25% in polls

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources3 outlets
Mathias Cormann, the former Australian finance minister and now secretary general of the OECD, will deliver a sharp warning to Australia's mainstream political parties on Saturday night: do not mimic populist policies such as arbitrary migration caps to address cost-of-living grievances. In an address to the Centre for Independent Studies, he will argue that the only reliable long-term solution is boosting productivity to deliver housing, real wage growth and lower energy costs.

Cormann will caution Labor and the Coalition against following the lead of populist parties like One Nation, which has surged to a primary vote of 25% according to the latest Guardian Essential poll, overtaking the Coalition on 22%. While acknowledging that populists have gained traction by speaking to real grievances over rising energy bills, home ownership and falling real incomes, he will argue that copying their economics is a losing strategy.

"Mainstream parties that respond to a populist surge by adopting its economics do not recover their voters. They lose twice: once to the original, which the electorate will always prefer to the copy, and once to the centre, which has nowhere else to go," the speech will say.

Cormann will specifically warn against "arbitrary migration caps" imposed without regard for their effects on business, hospitals, aged care or universities. He will acknowledge that more Australians than at any time in the past 20 years believe the migration intake is too high, with many citing housing concerns. However, he will argue the answer lies in addressing housing supply, infrastructure, services and the composition of the migration intake, not blanket caps.

Citing OECD research across Australian regions, Cormann will note that in places where more migrants arrived, employment among Australian-born workers grew faster, not slower, with no measurable effect on their wages.

"The lesson is consistent: deliver homes, lower energy costs, real wage growth and a credible budget, and the populist tide recedes. Mimic the populists, and you simply confirm that they were right all along," he will say. "The way to defeat populism is to solve the problems it feeds on."

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The warning comes as One Nation's primary vote hits 25%, signalling a significant populist shift in Australian politics that is pressuring both major parties.
  • Cost-of-living pressures remain the dominant issue for voters, and how parties respond could determine the outcome of the next federal election.
  • Cormann's call for a productivity-focused agenda challenges both Labor and the Coalition to offer substantive policy solutions rather than quick political fixes.

Background

Mathias Cormann served as Australia's longest-serving finance minister before becoming secretary general of the OECD in 2021. The Centre for Independent Studies, a conservative think tank, is hosting his address. The speech takes place against a backdrop of rising populism globally and specifically in Australia, where One Nation has capitalised on voter frustration over housing affordability, energy prices and stagnant wages. The Coalition's primary vote has fallen to 22%, its lowest ever in Guardian Essential polling.

Key Perspectives

Mainstream political parties (Labor and Coalition): Facing electoral pressure from a surging One Nation, they must decide whether to adopt tougher migration policies to win back voters or follow Cormann's productivity prescription. One Nation: Represents voters angry about housing and cost-of-living pressures, and has built support on an anti-immigration platform. The party benefits from the perception that major parties are not addressing these concerns. Economists and business groups: Many support Cormann's view that productivity growth is the key to sustainable living standards and that migration caps would harm the economy, but they acknowledge the political difficulty of selling long-term solutions to impatient voters.

What to Watch

  • Any change in migration policy announcements from either Labor or the Coalition ahead of the next election.
  • Whether housing supply measures, such as planning reforms or construction incentives, gain traction in federal and state policy debates.
  • The trajectory of One Nation's primary vote in future polls, which will test whether mainstream parties can stem the populist tide without adopting populist economics.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe