Settler sieges trap Palestinian families in their homes across the West Bank

From the South Hebron Hills to Umm Safa and Madama, families describe blockades on water, food and schooling as monitors warn of a collapse of law enforcement

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time4 min
Israeli settlers have besieged Palestinian family homes in at least three parts of the occupied West Bank since early October, cutting off water, food and schooling, with one farmer in the South Hebron Hills saying he is being driven from the house he built. Human rights and settlement-monitoring groups describe the blockades as a displacement policy and evidence that law enforcement in the territory has collapsed.

Yousef Shanaran, 52, built his two-storey home in 2016 on land between the town of as-Samu and the village of Susiya in the South Hebron Hills, planting about 70 grapevines and 30 to 40 olive trees and digging a well. Since October 5, he told Al Jazeera, Israeli settlers have besieged the house around the clock. The family cannot step outside on their own, even to reach the well. It took five days for the army to coordinate access, and after the family ran out of water, the army on Tuesday allowed them to draw some.

"Food, there's none," Shanaran said by phone. "My well, full of water; I built it and lost money on it. They keep me from it because they want to get me out of my house."

More than half a year ago, settlers pitched a tent 300 metres from the residence. On October 5, the tent was moved to 30 metres from the home, and that day about 50 settlers attacked the family with sticks and pepper spray, according to the report. Nothing now moves in or out without army permission.

Nasser Nawajeh, a longtime B'Tselem field researcher who heads the Susiya village council in Masafer Yatta, has tried repeatedly to deliver supplies. Most attempts failed. "Once I tried to bring aid to the people, and right away there was an attack from the settlers. I mean they're there 24 hours to attack," he said. He called the siege a displacement policy: if children are to reach school, or food and water brought in, the army must coordinate it. Since October 15 he says he has asked daily, and been told "tomorrow and tomorrow."

Nawajeh says there are now two forces to contend with: the settlers' rapid response squads, the Kitat Konenut, and the regular army, which "comes, demolishes [the settlers' tent] and leaves," allowing settlers to pitch it again. The house is in Area B, nominally under joint Israeli-Palestinian control, where a closure order against the settlers exists. "But there's no enforcement of these laws," he said. "In practice, the Palestinians are living in a prison inside. The siege is basically a prison."

Shanaran said prison would end. "Here, you're sitting in your own house, and they've locked you up in it, and you're afraid."

The same pattern is reported elsewhere. In Qusra, settlers besieged three homes, one owned by an American citizen, before the army set up barracks beside them. In Jalud, the Tubasi family was forced from their home in July and attacked in September when they tried to return under a court order. B'Tselem's Yair Dvir said the Qusra siege drew wide coverage largely because one of those involved held US citizenship. "In reality, attacks like these occur continually across the West Bank," he said.

Settlers have built more than 400 outposts across the West Bank, isolating Palestinian communities. Dror Etkes, cofounder of the monitoring group Kerem Navot, said the doorstep sieges reflect "an advanced stage of the complete collapse of any rule of law, any attempt to enforce law in the West Bank." Violence that once kept families off grazing and farmland is now moving into built-up areas, he said, as settlers work to "expel certain families who are residing outside of the big cluster of a built-up area."

In Umm Safa, northwest of Ramallah, the home of Muhammad al-Abayat, home to 15 people since 1973, sits between the settlement of Ateret and one of six outposts around the village. Mayor Marwan Sabah said settlers pitched a tent at the family's door in late September and fixed a gate blocking the path. The children cannot reach school, and al-Abayat's wife is ill and needs an operation. The village won a court ruling and a police decision to open the gate, but "the settlers lock the gate themselves most of the time," Sabah said. He described a "suffocating siege," with the village cemetery, the olive harvest and even rubbish removal under settler control. On October 20, the Israeli Civil Administration issued a demolition notice for the Abayat home.

In Madama, south of Nablus, the army sealed all three main entrances to the village with earth mounds on October 12, forcing villagers, including teachers, women and children, to cross the mounds on foot. The same day, a weeklong siege of neighbouring Burin was lifted.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Settler violence is moving from open farmland into built-up residential areas, according to Kerem Navot, placing family homes under direct siege rather than merely pressuring grazing land.
  • The affected families say the aim is expulsion, household by household, starting with isolated houses on the edges of villages and towns.
  • As described in the report, the Israeli army's role is coordination and protecting families from beatings, not lifting blockades, leaving residents dependent on daily military escorts for water, food and school runs.

Background

The West Bank has been under Israeli occupation since 1967. Under the Oslo Accords, it is divided into Areas A, B and C: Area C is under full Israeli military and civil control, Area B is nominally under joint Israeli-Palestinian administration, and Area A is intended to be under Palestinian administration. The homes under siege in this report sit in Area B. Settlements and outposts built by Israelis in the occupied West Bank are considered illegal under international law, though successive Israeli governments have supported settlement building. That administrative division is now decades old and heavily contested on the ground.

Key Perspectives

Affected families and village councils: They describe being locked inside their own homes, unable to reach wells, schools, medical care or the olive harvest, and they read the sieges as a deliberate attempt to force them off land their families have held for decades. Umm Safa's mayor says court and police orders to open blocked gates are ignored by settlers.

Human rights and settlement-monitoring groups: B'Tselem's field researcher Nasser Nawajeh calls the sieges a displacement policy and says Palestinians are living in a prison inside their own homes. Kerem Navot's Dror Etkes says the doorstep blockades represent an advanced stage of the collapse of any rule of law in the West Bank, as settlers target families on the edges of built-up areas.

Concerns over enforcement: The report describes a cycle in which the army demolishes settler tents only for them to be re-pitched, and a closure order against settlers that is not enforced. The looming risk flagged by villagers is that the demolition notice against the Abayat family home in Umm Safa, issued October 20, is carried through, and that the tactic spreads from single houses to whole communities during the olive harvest.

What to Watch

  • Whether the Israeli Civil Administration acts on the demolition notice issued for the Abayat family home in Umm Safa on October 20.
  • Whether court rulings and police decisions to open blocked gates are enforced, as the Umm Safa mayor says settlers keep relocking them.
  • Whether the army's pattern of demolishing settler tents and then leaving continues, and whether sieges on isolated houses expand toward larger villages and towns.

Sources

Checked

10 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 9 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedSettler sieges have trapped Palestinian families in their homes across the West Bank.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Since October 5, Israeli settlers have besieged his family home in Wadi Rakhim around the clock”
  2. SupportedFamilies describe blockades affecting water, food and schooling, while monitors warn of a collapse of law enforcement.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “these doorstep sieges reflect “an advanced stage of the complete collapse of any rule of law, any attempt to enforce law in the West Bank””
  3. SupportedSettlers besieged Palestinian family homes in at least three parts of the West Bank, with incidents continuing since early October.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “On October 5, the tent was moved just 30 metres from their home. That day, about 50 settlers attacked the family with sticks and pepper spray.”
  4. SupportedShanaran said, “Food, there's none,” and that settlers kept him from his well because they wanted him out of his house.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““Food, there’s none,” Shanaran, who built the sturdy two-storey house in 2016 on land between the Palestinian town of as-Samu and the village of Susiya, told Al Jazeera by phone. “My well, full of water; I built it and lost money on it,” he said. “They keep me from it because they want to get me out of my house.””
  5. SupportedAbout 50 settlers attacked Shanaran’s family with sticks and pepper spray on October 5.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “On October 5, the tent was moved just 30 metres from their home. That day, about 50 settlers attacked the family with sticks and pepper spray.”
  6. SupportedNawajeh called the siege a displacement policy.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““This is a displacement policy,” he said.”
  7. SupportedIn Qusra, settlers besieged three homes, including one owned by an American citizen, before the army set up barracks beside them.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “in Qusra, where settlers besieged three homes , one owned by an American citizen, before the army set up barracks beside the besieged homes.”
  8. SupportedSettlers have built more than 400 outposts across the West Bank.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Settlers have now built more than 400 outposts across the West Bank, isolating Palestinian homes and communities through their control of nearby hilltops and pathways.”
  9. Partly supportedThe Umm Safa home has been home to 15 people since 1973.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “The family has lived there since 1973, before the nearby illegal settlement of Ateret was established, according to the village mayor, Marwan Sabah. ... where 15 people live.”
  10. SupportedThe army sealed Madama’s three main entrances on October 12, the same day a weeklong siege of neighbouring Burin was lifted.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “On October 12, the army sealed all three main entrances to the village with earth mounds. On the same day, a weeklong siege of neighbouring Burin was lifted.”

Zotpaper

Written by Harper Lane on the World desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source9 of 10 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe