Small NSW farmer says Coles decision to drop local bananas signals end for family farms

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
A New South Wales banana farmer with 30 years of supply to Coles says the supermarket's decision to stop buying his produce is a sign that small, family-run farms may not survive, as industry experts warn major retailers are centralising supply chains.

Amrit Singh, who grows bananas on the Coffs Coast, sold his crop to Coles indirectly through a wholesaler, an agreement he said was worth hundreds of thousands of dollars a year. In August, Coles confirmed it would stop selling Coffs Coast bananas, pumpkins and cucumbers, citing an effort to simplify its supply chain. The produce is now expected to come from north Queensland.

"Freight costs [involved in] getting access to those [new] markets are going to be extremely high," Mr Singh said. He described Coles' decision as "anti-competitive" and said farmers who do not sell directly to supermarkets have "no power" to negotiate trade agreements, forcing them to reduce prices to support promotions. "That doesn't come out of [Coles'] pocket, that comes out of returns, so we actually [foot] the bill for those specials," he said.

Industry experts have claimed major Australian supermarkets were centralising supply chains to cut costs, warning some producers could now be at greater risk of having their products removed from shelves. Woolworths said its supply chain network had expanded. Coles rejected the experts' claims.

An inquiry by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) last year found Coles and Woolworths had overwhelming power in their trade relationships with suppliers. Mr Singh said small-scale growers are "price takers", not price makers.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The decisions by Coles and Woolworths to drop local products affect the viability of small family farms across Australia.
  • Consumers may face reduced choice and potentially higher prices as supply chains are consolidated.
  • The ACCC inquiry already found the two supermarket giants have overwhelming supplier power; these moves could intensify that imbalance.

Background

The ACCC's inquiry into Australian supermarkets last year concluded that Coles and Woolworths held significant market power over their suppliers. In the past two months, both chains have confirmed they would stop selling certain local products, including Coffs Coast bananas and Tasmanian beef, telling suppliers the changes were due to supply chain adjustments. Industry observers say the trend is towards centralisation to save costs.

Key Perspectives

Small farmers (e.g. Amrit Singh): They argue they have no negotiating power and are forced to absorb the cost of supermarket promotions, making it harder to compete against larger producers. Supermarkets (Coles and Woolworths): Coles rejects claims of centralisation; Woolworths says its supply chain network has expanded. Both frame the changes as routine supply chain management. ACCC: The regulator has documented the power imbalance and recommended greater transparency and stronger protections for suppliers.

What to Watch

  • Further announcements from Coles and Woolworths about dropping other local product lines.
  • Any government or regulatory response to the growing concerns about supermarket supplier practices.
  • Whether affected farmers like Mr Singh are able to find new buyers or are forced to exit the industry.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.