Three Oppositions, One Election: Victoria's Unusual Campaign Underway

Premier Ben Carroll distances himself from Labor's past as One Nation and the Coalition vie for power

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Victoria is in the midst of a strange election campaign, with three oppositions vying to form government in eight weeks: the traditional Liberal-National Coalition, Pauline Hanson's One Nation, and Premier Ben Carroll's own Labor government, which has spent its first two months distancing itself from its predecessors.

Victoria's election campaign has taken an unusual shape, with three distinct forces competing for government. The Liberal-National Coalition, led by Jess Wilson, is campaigning on a classic opposition platform, hoping to make the election a referendum on 12 years of Labor rule.

One Nation, meanwhile, has released its full platform with a heavy emphasis on law and order and tax relief, paired with Trumpian rhetoric about locking political opponents in prison. Polls suggest the party could attract around one in four voters in the state, despite having provided limited policy details until recently.

The third opposition is Labor itself. Premier Ben Carroll, in office for two months, has been at pains to distance himself from the governments of Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan, despite having served as a minister in their teams. On Sunday, Carroll promised to wind back land tax increases implemented by Labor in 2023 — another policy that undoes the work of his predecessors.

Carroll has sought to focus on local benefits, notably in his own once-safe but now marginal electorate of Niddrie, where he promised a new station as part of the long-awaited rail line to the airport. "Hi, I'm Ben Carroll, the airport rail premier," he said this week. The project, however, has faced delays. Carroll now says trains will run to East Keilor station in 2031, but no one will say when trains will reach the airport itself. The Upfield line upgrades have been pushed back to 2033, despite chronic under-service.

The strategy highlights a risky balancing act: the airport rail project was championed by Labor for years before being put on ice in favour of the Suburban Rail Loop. As a minister, Jacinta Allan said in 2022 trains would be running to the airport in 2029.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The unusual three-opposition dynamic could fragment the vote, making the outcome unpredictable and potentially leading to a minority government.
  • Voters face a choice between a Labor government trying to reinvent itself, a traditional Coalition alternative, and a populist One Nation offering sharp law-and-order policies and tax cuts.
  • The delay of major transport projects like airport rail and Upfield line upgrades affects Melbourne's growth and commuter frustration, becoming a key election issue.

Background

Victoria has been governed by Labor since 2014, under premiers Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan. The government has pursued ambitious infrastructure projects, including the Suburban Rail Loop, but has faced criticism over debt and project delays. The emergence of One Nation as a significant force adds a new dimension to state politics, while Premier Ben Carroll is attempting to reset Labor's image after a long period in power.

Key Perspectives

Labor (Premier Ben Carroll): Seeking to distance himself from past Labor governments and focus on local benefits, such as the airport rail promise in his own electorate, while rolling back land tax increases to appeal to voters. Liberal-National Coalition (Jess Wilson): Campaigning as a traditional opposition, aiming to make the election a referendum on Labor's record after 12 years. One Nation (Pauline Hanson): Offering a platform with strong law-and-order rhetoric and tax relief, appealing to voters dissatisfied with major parties, though policy details were limited until recently. Critics and Voters: Skeptical of Carroll's ability to separate himself from the previous administration, and wary of One Nation's Trumpian language and vague policies. Transport project delays may undermine trust in all parties.

What to Watch

  • Polling trends for One Nation and how its support holds as the campaign progresses.
  • Whether Carroll's strategy to play up local projects in marginal seats succeeds.
  • Any further policy announcements or gaffes that could shift the three-way dynamic.
  • The final timeline for airport rail: will a firm commitment be given before election day?

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.