Authorities unable to decipher gestures exchanged on court video links, report says

The Age reports that people facing charges exchanged gestures during court video links that authorities could not decipher

By LineZotpaper
Published
Updated
Read Time3 min
Sources3 outlets
The Age reports that people facing charges exchanged gestures during court video links. Unidentified police and prison sources told the publication that authorities could not determine what the gestures meant.

The Age reported that gestures had been exchanged on court video links while proceedings were adjourned, but their meaning was unknown.

"The sign language becomes part of the crew, so they're all on the same page. They generally do that sort of shit if they think they've been bugged or, you know, watched or listened to," a former organised crime figure told The Age. "It just looks sophisticated because you haven't seen it before. Everyone's got their signs on what this sign means and what that sign means among each crew."

The language is not Auslan, the official Australian sign language. Corrections Victoria does not offer Auslan courses in prison. Instead, it is a bespoke, one-off language with gestures that vary between crews. "One might put three fingers up instead of two fingers and a thumb for the same thing. And people think, 'What the f---'s that?' But no one knows but me and you, basically," the informant said.

The Age said some gestures appeared recognisable, but reported that authorities could not determine their meaning.

Similar secret communication has been documented in prison visits and on the street. In 2017, authorities recorded visits involving jailed gangland figure Kazem "Kaz" Hamad and his brother, but could never decode the conversations. An associate who later became a prosecution witness testified: "In every single visit when they talk, it's not like plain normal English, it's more like, you know, gestures, you know, they use code. ... I didn't know what they were talking about half the time and I just kind of played along."

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The practice undermines courtroom security, potentially allowing defendants to coordinate false testimony or intimidate witnesses in real time.
  • It exposes a gap in surveillance methods: even with CCTV and oversight, criminals can operate a hidden channel of communication.
  • The phenomenon suggests organised crime in Melbourne has become more sophisticated and adaptive, staying ahead of law enforcement tactics.

Background

Melbourne has been gripped by violent turf wars over the illicit tobacco trade, known as the "tobacco war," and the nightclub security industry, or "bar wars." The article reports that members of crews implicated in these conflicts are using a custom sign language during joint court video links, typically after being arrested and held in different prisons. The practice is not new — gangland figures have used hand signals and code words for years to avoid detection by bugs and listening devices.

Key Perspectives

[Law enforcement and prison authorities]: They acknowledge they are unable to translate the bespoke signs, making it nearly impossible to monitor what is being said during court proceedings. [Criminal crews]: For them, the sign language is a necessary adaptation to communicate securely under constant surveillance. It reinforces group cohesion and operational security. [Critics/Skeptics]: Some may question how pervasive the practice is, or note that similar coded communication has been used in prisons for decades. The lack of a common dictionary makes it difficult to assess the threat.

What to Watch

  • Whether courts will revise video link procedures to restrict visual contact between accused persons.
  • If investigators invest in linguistic analysis or recruit informants to decode the signals.
  • The potential for this tactic to spread to other jurisdictions as awareness grows.

Sources

Checked

10 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 5 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedAuthorities could not decipher the gestures exchanged on court video links (headline).Brisbane Times - Latest News: “What is being said is a complete mystery to justice authorities.”
  2. SupportedPeople facing charges exchanged gestures during court video links that authorities could not decipher (summary and opening).Brisbane Times - Latest News: “The duo is part of a four-man crew accused of staging the kidnapping of a tobacco shop owner”
  3. SupportedUnidentified police and prison sources said authorities could not determine what the gestures meant.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Police and prison sources, who cannot be identified publicly, say they simply can't translate this bespoke sign language.”
  4. SupportedFormer organised crime figure: 'The sign language becomes part of the crew... They generally do that sort of shit if they think they've been bugged or, you know, watched or listened to.'Brisbane Times - Latest News: “The sign language becomes part of the crew, so they're all on the same page. They generally do that sort of shit if they think they've been bugged or, you know, watched or listened to,”
  5. Partly supportedThe language is not Auslan, 'the official Australian sign language'.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “This is not Auslan , the Australian Sign Language used by the deaf community, according to an expert who reviewed some of the signs documented by The Age .”
  6. Partly supportedCorrections Victoria does not offer Auslan courses in prison, and 'instead' the crews use a bespoke language.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Corrections Victoria also does not offer Auslan courses in prison.”
  7. Partly supportedThe informant said: 'One might put three fingers up instead of two fingers and a thumb for the same thing...'Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““One might put three fingers up instead of two fingers and a thumb for the same thing. And people think, ‘What the f---’s that?’ But no one knows but me and you, basically.””
  8. Partly supportedIn 2017, authorities recorded visits involving Kazem 'Kaz' Hamad and his brother, but could never decode the conversations.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “In 2017, prison authorities recorded a visit between then-jailed gangland figure Kazem “Kaz” Hamad and his brother Maytham Hamad after a murder that implicated several members of their crew.”
  9. SupportedAn associate who later became a prosecution witness testified: 'In every single visit when they talk, it's not like plain normal English...'Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““In every single visit when they talk, it’s not like plain normal English, it’s more like, you know, gestures, you know, they use code.”
  10. Partly supportedSimilar secret communication has been documented in prison visits and on the street.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “The underworld and prison system are rife with these bespoke sign language systems, a way for criminals to communicate in code under the noses of authorities and blanket CCTV coverage, underworld and police sources say.”

Zotpaper

Written by Harper Lane on the Australia & local desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source5 of 10 claims matched to a sourcefirst published 19 Oct, 6:49 amupdated once
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe