WA Premier says new Ombudsman information could open door for coronial inquest into Hawke children deaths

New details released by WA Ombudsman prompt renewed calls from family for inquiry into 2022 murders in South Hedland

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Western Australian Premier Roger Cook says new information released by the state Ombudsman on the deaths of three children in the Pilbara could provide grounds for a coronial inquest, though he stopped short of ordering one. The children – aged ten, seven and four months – were murdered by their mother Margaret Hawke in South Hedland in 2022.

The WA Ombudsman, Bevan Warner, has released new details of the case, citing media coverage as a reason to make the information public. He said that although individual death investigations are not usually published, the level of public interest justified the report.

Extensive evidence was examined during the review, including police body-worn camera video and more than 1,700 pages of records from key agencies. The review covered 17 emergency calls and six family violence incidents.

Premier Roger Cook said the new material might offer an opportunity for further consideration, noting that if it was not part of the evidence previously considered by the coroner, the Attorney-General could speak with the coroner about it.

The children's grandmother, Dorothy Papertalk, has been calling for an inquest since the deaths, but former Coroner Phil Urquhart denied that request in 2025.

Attorney-General Tony Buti has repeatedly stated he cannot order an inquest, and has published private legal advice to support his position. However, he was challenged in an open letter by former Governor Malcolm McCusker KC and former president of the Children's Court Denis Reynolds. Mr Reynolds argued the Coroners Act 1996 clearly gives the Attorney-General the power to direct the state coroner to conduct an inquest, describing the relevant provision as "very clear and unambiguous, and not qualified at all."

Mr Buti responded that he accepted the advice from the solicitor-general on the matter.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The case has raised serious questions about how domestic violence, child protection and police responses are handled in remote Western Australian communities.
  • The grandmother's long-running campaign for an inquest reflects community demands for accountability and answers about systemic failures.
  • The legal dispute over the Attorney-General's powers could set a precedent for when and how coronial inquests can be ordered in Western Australia.

Background

The three children were murdered by their mother in South Hedland in 2022. Their grandmother, Dorothy Papertalk, has since pushed for a coronial inquest, arguing that the system failed her grandchildren. In 2025, the then Coroner Phil Urquhart denied the request. The case has received sustained media coverage, prompting the Ombudsman to release new details that had not previously been made public.

Key Perspectives

Grandmother (Dorothy Papertalk) and legal advocates: They argue the Attorney-General has the power to order an inquest and that the law is clear. They want a full public inquiry into what happened. Attorney-General Tony Buti: Maintains he lacks the legal authority to order an inquest without fresh evidence, and says he is acting on solicitor-general advice. Premier Roger Cook: Stopped short of ordering an inquest but indicated that the Ombudsman's new information might be sufficient fresh evidence to warrant further consideration by the Attorney-General.

What to Watch

  • Whether the Attorney-General reconsiders his position on an inquest in light of the Ombudsman's new details.
  • Any further legal action by the grandmother or her supporters to compel an inquest.
  • Coroner Phil Urquhart's response to the new information being made public.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe