A 76-square-metre parcel of council-owned land in Ramsgate, south of Sydney, has become the flashpoint in a dispute between Georges River Council and the NSW planning department over a proposed Woolworths supermarket and 141-apartment development, with critics saying the standoff reflects deeper anti-development attitudes in the area.
The plot at 197R Rocky Point Road is a laneway that is publicly inaccessible and has been mostly unused for years. Georges River Labor councillor Thomas Gao described it as “just a dump”, saying it has overgrown grass and does not even face the street.
The site sits within a larger area that Woolworths Group, through its property arm Fabcot, has earmarked for 141 apartments and a 4000-square-metre full-line supermarket. For the development to proceed, Woolworths is seeking to reclassify the 76-square-metre plot from “community” land, which cannot be sold, to “operational” land.
Georges River Council argues it is unlawful for the state to allow the reclassification without its consent. Mayor Elise Borg, an independent, warned it could set a citywide precedent for public land being used for private interests and not the community’s benefit.
“This is about more than one small parcel of land in Ramsgate. It raises a much broader question about whether councils and their communities can have confidence in the protections afforded to community land across NSW,” Borg said. “The beneficiary of the state government’s process is the private developer.”
Not everyone sees it that way. Gao said the council was standing in the way of much-needed development and housing that would revitalise the area, and has heard from residents and business owners who have thrown their support behind the proposal.
“Common sense should prevail here. We’re not talking about a car park. We’re not talking about a beach or a park. If the mayor thinks that’s going to set a precedent … I think no one’s going to buy that,” Gao said.
Gao said the dispute was another example of many Georges River councillors opposing development in south Sydney, pointing to a separate clash with the state over a plan to build 800 homes along a major corridor in a nearby suburb. “They are against any form of development. They will say they are for development, but they’re not,” he said.
Borg said the council was opposed to the Woolworths and housing development over traffic and infrastructure concerns, and was prepared to reconsider a more scaled-back proposal. “If they do a much more scaled-down supermarket, then there probably wouldn’t be the same level of objections,” she said. “It’s already a hugely congested area, and it’s too much of an intense use of the site.”
A spokesperson for the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure said the relevant planning proposal authority would consider all perspectives and any legal considerations before recommending whether the development should proceed, with or without amendments.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The dispute tests the legal protections for 'community land' in NSW, which is meant to be preserved for public use and cannot be sold without council consent.
- The outcome could set a precedent for other developments across the state where private developers seek to reclassify small public parcels as part of larger projects.
- The standoff highlights the tension between local council control over land use and state-level planning goals, particularly around housing supply in Sydney's south.
Background
Georges River Council and the NSW planning department have clashed before over development in the area. Gao noted a separate dispute over a plan for 800 homes along a major corridor in a nearby suburb. The current dispute revolves around a 76-square-metre plot that has been mostly unused for years, sitting within a larger site Woolworths wants to develop. Under NSW law, 'community' land cannot be sold; the developer needs it reclassified to 'operational' land for the project to proceed.
Key Perspectives
Georges River Council (Mayor Elise Borg): Warns that allowing the reclassification without council consent could set a citywide precedent and undermine community confidence in protections for public land. The council opposes the current proposal over traffic and infrastructure concerns but is open to a more scaled-back supermarket.
Labor Councillor Thomas Gao: Describes the plot as a dump and says the council is standing in the way of much-needed housing and development. He argues that the reclassification would not set a precedent and says many councillors are opposed to any form of development in south Sydney.
Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure: Says the relevant authority will consider all perspectives and legal considerations before recommending whether the development should proceed, with or without amendments.
What to Watch
- Whether the state planning department comes down on the side of the developer or the council, and what conditions it attaches.
- Whether Woolworths submits a scaled-back proposal as suggested by Borg.
- Any legal challenge from the council if the reclassification is approved without its consent.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedA 76-square-metre Ramsgate land dispute pits Georges River Council against the state planning department.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “A tiny parcel of underutilised land is emerging as the unlikely centrepiece of a long-running dispute between a local council and the state’s planning department”
- SupportedWoolworths is seeking to reclassify the 76-square-metre community-land plot for a supermarket and apartment development.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “for the development to go ahead, Woolworths is seeking to reclassify the 76-square-metre plot from “community” land – which cannot be sold – to “operational” land.”
- SupportedCritics say the dispute reflects deeper anti-development attitudes in the area.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “which critics say is emblematic of deep-rooted anti-development attitudes in south Sydney.”
- SupportedThe proposed development includes 141 apartments and a 4,000-square-metre full-line supermarket.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Woolworths Group, through its in-house property arm Fabcot, has earmarked for 141 apartments and a 4000-square-metre full-line supermarket.”
- SupportedThomas Gao described the plot as “just a dump”.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Georges River Labor councillor Thomas Gao described it as “just a dump”.”
- SupportedElise Borg warned that the land issue could set a citywide precedent for public land being used for private interests rather than the community’s benefit.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Mayor Elise Borg, an independent, warned it could set a citywide precedent for public land being used for private interests and not the community’s benefit.”
- SupportedBorg said: “This is about more than one small parcel of land in Ramsgate. It raises a much broader question about whether councils and their communities can have confidence in the protections afforded to community land across NSW,”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““This is about more than one small parcel of land in Ramsgate. It raises a much broader question about whether councils and their communities can have confidence in the protections afforded to community land across NSW,” Borg said.”
- SupportedBorg said: “The beneficiary of the state government’s process is the private developer.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““The beneficiary of the state government’s process is the private developer.””
- SupportedGao said: “Common sense should prevail here. We’re not talking about a car park. We’re not talking about a beach or a park. If the mayor thinks that’s going to set a precedent … I think no one’s going to buy that,”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““Common sense should prevail here. We’re not talking about a car park. We’re not talking about a beach or a park. If the mayor thinks that’s going to set a precedent … I think no one’s going to buy that,” Gao said.”
- SupportedGao said many Georges River councillors oppose development in south Sydney and cited a separate plan for 800 homes along a major corridor in a nearby suburb.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Gao said the dispute was yet another example of many Georges River councillors opposing development in south Sydney. He pointed to the council’s clash with the state over a plan to build 800 homes along a major corridor in a nearby suburb .”
- SupportedGao said: “They are against any form of development. They will say they are for development, but they’re not,”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““They are against any form of development. They will say they are for development, but they’re not,” he said.”
- SupportedBorg said the council was prepared to reconsider a more scaled-back proposal and said a smaller supermarket might draw fewer objections.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Borg said the council was opposed to the Woolworths and housing development at Ramsgate over traffic and infrastructure concerns, and said it was prepared to reconsider a more scaled-back proposal. “If they do a much more scaled-down supermarket, then there probably wouldn’t be the same level of objections,” she said.”