Adam Gee to referee NRL grand final, Chris Butler in bunker

Grant Atkins overlooked, Ashley Klein demoted after missed penalty call

By LineZotpaper
Published
Updated
Read Time2 min
Sources3 outlets
Adam Gee has been appointed to referee his second NRL grand final, with Chris Butler working as the bunker official for Sunday's Roosters-Knights decider. Incumbent 2025 grand final referee Grant Atkins was overlooked after not officiating in either preliminary final.

Gee, who previously refereed the 2023 grand final between Penrith and Brisbane, was in charge of the Roosters' 36-20 preliminary final victory over the Dolphins on Friday. In that match, he referred contentious tries to Jamayne Isaako and Rob Toia to the bunker. Video official Ashley Klein subsequently awarded both tries, deeming there was not sufficient evidence to overturn the on-field decisions. Butler was the bunker official for that preliminary final.

Grant Atkins, who refereed the 2025 grand final, was not selected this year after missing out on officiating in either preliminary final. Veteran referee Gerard Sutton oversaw Newcastle's 22-14 defeat of the Panthers on Sunday, the other preliminary final.

Ashley Klein, who had overseen all three State of Origin matches this year, was demoted to bunker duties for the preliminary finals after failing to award an escort penalty to the Warriors in the final minute of their semi-final loss to Newcastle a week earlier at Eden Park. Klein will be in the bunker for the first game on grand final day, the annual curtain-raiser.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The appointment decisions reflect the NRL's response to recent officiating controversies, particularly the missed escort penalty call.
  • The grand final is the season's most-watched match, and referee and bunker performance will face intense scrutiny.
  • Consistency in officiating across finals series is a key concern for clubs, players, and fans.

Background

Grand final referee appointments are made after the preliminary finals, with form and performance during the finals series being the primary criteria. The NRL's officiating structure includes an on-field referee and a bunker video official who reviews try decisions and other contentious calls. This year's decider between the Roosters and Knights has attracted significant attention following several tight calls in earlier finals matches.

Key Perspectives

Players and coaches: They want consistent and accurate decision-making, especially on try reviews and penalty calls that can decide a match. NRL match officials: The appointments aim to put the most experienced and best-performing officials in the biggest game, while also managing fallout from errors in earlier rounds. Fans and pundits: The omission of Grant Atkins and the demotion of Ashley Klein are likely to be debated, with some questioning the selection process and the impact of recent controversies.

What to Watch

  • Performance of referee Adam Gee, particularly his management of the ruck and penalty counts.
  • Bunker decisions involving Chris Butler, especially on marginal try calls.
  • Any flashpoints or controversial calls that could reignite debate about officiating standards.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.