Liam Slann, who is standing trial alongside his father for the murder of 21-year-old William Holdback, has told a South Australian Supreme Court jury he chased Mr Holdback after the alleged victim swung a knife at him during an attempted drug deal, and said he wanted to 'get back' at him.
Liam Slann gave evidence on Tuesday in his own murder trial, saying he asked his father, Brian Slann, to drive him to a drug deal in Welland in Adelaide's inner north-west in April 2024. Both men have pleaded not guilty to murder, but Liam Slann has pleaded guilty to manslaughter, a plea the prosecution did not accept.
He told the court the alleged victim approached the car wearing a COVID mask, asked to see the drugs, grabbed a bag of cocaine and swung a knife at him before the knife dropped into the car. 'His hand came straight through the window, came straight for my face … I reckon I screamed,' Liam Slann said.
He said the alleged victim smashed his father's back window and taunted him: 'He kept laughing, jumped side to side.' The court heard Liam Slann jumped out of the car and told Mr Holdback, 'You're f****** c**** … I'm going to stab you.'
When his lawyer, Elizabeth Mansfield, asked what he wanted to do when he caught up, Liam Slann said he wanted to 'hurt him'. '[In] reality, obviously hurt him … only to the extent of what happened … very unlucky where he got stabbed,' he told the jury.
The accused said he remembered stabbing the alleged victim's shoulder but that his memory became hazy after that. 'I honestly can't remember … after the first lunge,' he said. The court previously heard Mr Holdback was stabbed 10 times and was left crying out for help on the street.
Under cross-examination, prosecutor Nicola Moore asked Liam Slann about CCTV that captured his father asking where he stabbed Mr Holdback, to which the son replied 'everywhere'. 'Can't remember saying that,' Liam Slann told the court. He also denied the prosecutor's suggestion that he left the house with the knife before the alleged murder.
The trial continues.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The case highlights the legal distinction between murder and manslaughter, with Liam Slann's guilty plea to the lesser charge reflecting his account of a violent drug deal gone wrong.
- The trial is being closely watched in Adelaide as it involves a father and son accused of a fatal stabbing, raising questions about self-defence and provocation.
- The outcome will set a precedent for how the courts weigh a defendant's claim of acting in response to a perceived threat during a drug transaction.
Background
Liam Slann and his father, Brian Slann, are accused of the murder of 21-year-old William Holdback in Welland, Adelaide, in April 2024. The prosecution alleges Mr Holdback was stabbed 10 times and left crying for help after a disagreement over drugs. Both men pleaded not guilty to murder; Liam Slann also pleaded guilty to manslaughter, which the prosecution rejected, leading to the full trial.
Key Perspectives
Liam Slann (accused): told the jury he thought he was being robbed, that the alleged victim swung a knife first, and that he chased Mr Holdback 'trying to get the coke back' and wanted to 'hurt him' but said where he was stabbed was 'very unlucky'.
Prosecutor Nicola Moore: put to Liam Slann that CCTV showed him telling his father he stabbed the victim 'everywhere', and suggested he left the house with a knife before the alleged murder.
What to Watch
- Further evidence from the prosecution and the defence, including any CCTV or witness testimony that corroborates or contradicts Liam Slann's account.
- The testimony of co-accused Brian Slann, who has not yet given evidence.
- The jury's verdict on the murder charge against both men and whether they accept Liam Slann's version of events.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says Liam Slann wanted to “get back” at the alleged victim.Just In: “"I wanted to get back at him for what he did to me," he said.”
- SupportedThe summary says Slann acted after a knife was swung at him during a drug deal in Welland.Just In: “Liam Slann said the alleged victim approached the car wearing a COVID mask, asked to see the drugs, grabbed the bag of cocaine and swung a knife at him before the knife dropped into the car.”
- SupportedSlann told the jury he chased Holdback after Holdback swung a knife at him, and said he wanted to get back at him.Just In: “Liam Slann told the court he chased Mr Holdback, "trying to get the coke back". "I wanted to get back at him for what he did to me," he said.”
- SupportedLiam Slann and his father, Brian Slann, are standing trial for the murder of 21-year-old William Holdback.Just In: “Liam Slann and his father, Brian Slann, are standing trial for the murder of 21-year-old William Holdback”
- SupportedBoth men pleaded not guilty to murder, while Liam Slann pleaded guilty to manslaughter and the prosecution did not accept the plea.Just In: “Both men have pleaded not guilty to murder, but Liam Slann has entered a guilty plea to manslaughter, which the prosecution did not accept.”
- SupportedSlann said he asked his father to drive him to a drug deal in Welland in Adelaide's inner north-west in April 2024.Just In: “after a disagreement over drugs in April 2024. [...] Liam Slann told the court he asked his father to drive him to the deal in Welland in Adelaide's inner north-west.”
- SupportedSlann said Holdback grabbed a bag of cocaine and swung a knife at him before the knife dropped into the car.Just In: “Liam Slann said the alleged victim approached the car wearing a COVID mask, asked to see the drugs, grabbed the bag of cocaine and swung a knife at him before the knife dropped into the car.”
- SupportedSlann said, “His hand came straight through the window, came straight for my face … I reckon I screamed.”Just In: “"His hand came straight through the window, came straight for my face," Liam Slann said. "I reckon I screamed."”
- SupportedSlann said Holdback smashed his father's back window and taunted him, saying, “He kept laughing, jumped side to side.”Just In: “He told the court the alleged victim smashed his dad's back window and taunted him. "He kept laughing, jumped side to side," Liam Slann told the jury.”
- SupportedSlann said he told Holdback, “You're f****** c**** … I'm going to stab you.”Just In: “The court heard that Liam Slann jumped out of the car and said to the alleged victim, "You're f****** c**** … I'm going to stab you."”
- SupportedAsked what he wanted to do when he caught up with Holdback, Slann said he wanted to hurt him.Just In: “When his lawyer, Elizabeth Mansfield, asked about what he wanted to do when he eventually caught up with the alleged victim, Liam Slann said he wanted to "hurt him".”
- SupportedThe court previously heard Holdback was stabbed 10 times and left crying out for help on the street.Just In: “The court previously heard Mr Holdback was stabbed 10 times and was left crying out for help on the street.”