Cynthia Ellen Rigney has been found guilty of manslaughter but not guilty of murder for the 2018 stabbing death of 61-year-old Maria Luis at her Kilburn home, with a South Australian Supreme Court judge saying she could not find the then-19-year-old had the specific intent to kill or cause really serious bodily harm, after considering her treatment-resistant schizophrenia and likely psychosis.
Justice Anne Bampton delivered the verdict of manslaughter by an unlawful and dangerous act, finding that while Rigney stabbed Ms Luis 34 times, she could not be satisfied that the reasonable possibility the stabbing resulted from a psychotic motive in the context of a delusion had been excluded.
Rigney, who lived on the same street as Ms Luis, was arrested shortly after the December 2018 stabbing. Police forced entry into her home and found her sleeping with a plastic bag containing cannabis attached to her leg.
Justice Bampton noted that Ms Luis was known in the local community as a cannabis dealer and that her husband had told police she did not sell cannabis to Aboriginal or young people. A neighbour had reported days before the incident that Rigney was screaming on Ms Luis’s porch, and had told Rigney to “snap out of it” and “have some respect”. According to the ruling, Rigney then asked the neighbour if she could “get me a bag then”.
Medical experts at trial identified a non-psychotic alternative explanation for Rigney's conduct, meaning she was not considered unfit to stand trial. Justice Bampton wrote that Rigney had a history of buying cannabis from Ms Luis and had conflict with her in the days leading up to the stabbing. "It is likely that if such a disagreement had occurred, in her psychotic state, Ms Rigney would have been predisposed to react in a paranoid, impulsive, and aggressive manner," the judge said.
While acknowledging that “the number and location of the stab wounds inflicted is undoubtedly suggestive of specific intent”, Justice Bampton said that, given Rigney’s treatment-resistant schizophrenia and likely psychosis at the time, she could not be satisfied that the reasonable possibility the stabbing resulted from a psychotic motive in the context of a delusion had been excluded. “Ms Rigney must be found not guilty of murder,” she said.
Rigney appeared via video link from the forensic mental health facility James Nash House and smiled as the verdict was handed down. The defence has been given time to seek an updated psychiatric report ahead of sentencing, and the matter will return to court in December.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The verdict highlights the complex role of severe mental illness in criminal responsibility, particularly the distinction between murder and manslaughter when psychosis may have driven the act.
- The case underscores gaps in mental health support and community safety, as Rigney had known conflicts with the victim in the days before the killing.
- The outcome may influence how courts handle similar cases where defendants with treatment-resistant schizophrenia are charged with serious violent offences.
Background
The stabbing occurred in December 2018 at Maria Luis's home on Goodman Avenue in Kilburn, an inner-northern Adelaide suburb. Cynthia Ellen Rigney was 19 at the time and lived on the same street. She was charged with murder but raised a defence based on mental impairment. The trial proceeded before a judge alone, with Justice Anne Bampton delivering the verdict in the Supreme Court of South Australia. Rigney had a history of buying cannabis from Ms Luis, and CCTV showed her arriving at the victim's address and leaving three minutes later.
What to Watch
- The updated psychiatric report ordered by Justice Bampton, which will inform Rigney's sentence.
- The sentencing hearing in December, which will determine how long Rigney spends in custody or under supervision.
- Potential appeals by either party, though none have been indicated.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedAdelaide woman Cynthia Ellen Rigney was found guilty of manslaughter and not guilty of murder in her neighbour’s stabbing death.Adelaide articles feed: “An Adelaide woman who stood trial for stabbing another woman 34 times because the victim refused to sell cannabis to her has been found not guilty of murder, but guilty of manslaughter.”
- SupportedThe judge said she could not find Rigney had the specific intent to kill or cause really serious bodily harm, while considering her schizophrenia and likely psychosis.Adelaide articles feed: “Justice Anne Bampton said she could not find Rigney stabbed Ms Luis with the specific intent to kill or cause really serious bodily harm.”
- SupportedThe stabbing death was in 2018, and Maria Luis was 61.Adelaide articles feed: “Cynthia Ellen Rigney has been found guilty of manslaughter after fatally stabbing a 61-year-old Adelaide woman in 2018.”
- SupportedRigney stabbed Luis 34 times.Adelaide articles feed: “An Adelaide woman who stood trial for stabbing another woman 34 times”
- Partly supportedThe judge’s quoted finding was that “the reasonable possibility the stabbing resulted from a psychotic motive in the context of a delusion had been excluded.”Adelaide articles feed: “she could not be satisfied that "the reasonable possibility the stabbing was the result of a psychotic motive in the context of a delusion held has been excluded"”
- SupportedThe manslaughter verdict was for an unlawful and dangerous act.Adelaide articles feed: “Rigney appeared in court via video link from forensic mental health facility James Nash House and smiled as the verdict of "manslaughter by an unlawful and dangerous act" was handed down.”
- SupportedDays before the stabbing, a neighbour said Rigney was screaming on Luis’s porch and told her to “snap out of it” and “have some respect”.Adelaide articles feed: “A neighbour had also reported days before the incident Rigney was screaming on Ms Luis's porch, and had told Rigney to "snap out of it" and "have some respect".”
- SupportedPolice forced entry into Rigney’s home and found her sleeping with a plastic bag of cannabis attached to her leg.Adelaide articles feed: “Specialised police officers had forced entry into her home where she was found sleeping with a plastic bag containing cannabis attached to her leg.”
- SupportedMedical experts identified a non-psychotic alternative explanation for Rigney’s conduct, so she was not considered unfit to stand trial.Adelaide articles feed: “Justice Bampton said medical experts in the trial had identified a non-psychotic, alternative explanation for Rigney's conduct, which is why she was not considered unfit to stand trial.”
- SupportedJustice Bampton said Rigney would likely have reacted in a paranoid, impulsive and aggressive manner if a disagreement had occurred while she was psychotic.Adelaide articles feed: “"It is likely that if such a disagreement had occurred, in her psychotic state, Ms Rigney would have been predisposed to react in a paranoid, impulsive, and aggressive manner."”
- SupportedRigney appeared by video link from James Nash House and smiled when the verdict was handed down.Adelaide articles feed: “Rigney appeared in court via video link from forensic mental health facility James Nash House and smiled as the verdict of "manslaughter by an unlawful and dangerous act" was handed down.”
- SupportedThe defence was given time to seek an updated psychiatric report before sentencing, and the matter will return to court in December.Adelaide articles feed: “Justice Bampton granted the defence time to seek an updated psychiatric report ahead of Rigney's sentencing. The matter will return to court in December.”