AFP bribery investigation into SMEC ends with $9 million settlement, no prosecution

Company cooperated and made no admissions of wrongdoing

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
The Australian Federal Police have accepted a $9 million settlement from engineering company SMEC, formerly the Snowy Mountains Engineering Corporation, to end a 13-year-long bribery investigation into the company's conduct in Sri Lanka and Vietnam. Police will not pursue a prosecution and SMEC made no admissions of wrongdoing.

The Australian Federal Police have accepted a $9 million settlement from engineering company SMEC, formerly the Snowy Mountains Engineering Corporation, to end a 13-year-long investigation into alleged foreign bribery. The settlement, paid under proceeds of crime legislation, involves no prosecution and no admission of wrongdoing by the company.

The AFP began investigating SMEC's conduct in countries including Sri Lanka and Vietnam in 2013 and twice conducted searches under warrant in subsequent years. Despite the length of the investigation, police did not refer the matter to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. The AFP cited factors including the company's cooperation and the time elapsed since the alleged events.

AFP anti-corruption commander Andrea Quinn said the $9 million payment demonstrated that companies could still face significant financial consequences following foreign bribery investigations even without prosecution. "Noting the cooperation of SMEC throughout the investigation, companies identifying potential misconduct and engaging early, transparently and constructively with the AFP place themselves in a materially different position to those who do not," Quinn said. She added that the AFP is committed to detecting, disrupting and deterring foreign bribery.

SMEC cooperated throughout the investigation. A spokeswoman said the company conducted internal investigations, hired external consultants, and self-reported to the AFP in 2016 and 2018. "SMEC cooperated with the AFP throughout the investigation and provided an extensive range of additional material and information as requested over an extended period," she said. "SMEC has zero tolerance for bribery and corruption throughout its global operations and has enhanced its anti-bribery and compliance procedures since the alleged conduct."

As part of the settlement, SMEC also agreed to contribute to the AFP's external legal costs and to donate money to an anti-corruption NGO. The amounts of these payments were not disclosed. The company confirmed that staff alleged to have been involved in the overseas issues are no longer with the company.

SMEC continues to hold major government contracts, including work on the Snowy Hydro 2.0 project.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The outcome establishes a potential model for resolving foreign bribery cases in Australia through financial settlement without prosecution, raising questions about deterrence.
  • It highlights the importance companies can place on early cooperation and self-reporting when facing investigations.
  • SMEC continues to hold government contracts, meaning accountability mechanisms for such companies remain under scrutiny.

Background

SMEC, originally the Snowy Mountains Engineering Corporation, is a major Australian engineering firm involved in infrastructure projects at home and abroad. The AFP investigation, which lasted more than a decade, focused on alleged bribery in Sri Lanka and Vietnam. The case concluded with a proceeds of crime settlement rather than a criminal referral.

Key Perspectives

  • AFP: A $9 million payment imposes significant financial consequences and shows that cooperation affects outcomes.
  • SMEC: The company maintains it has zero tolerance for bribery, has enhanced compliance, and cooperated fully while making no admissions.
  • Critics: Some may argue that the absence of prosecution and the confidentiality around the additional payments reduce transparency and accountability, especially given the length of the investigation.

What to Watch

  • Whether the AFP's approach influences future foreign bribery cases and how prosecutors weigh cooperation.
  • The level of public and parliamentary scrutiny of the settlement and any subsequent changes to corporate bribery enforcement.
  • SMEC's continued eligibility for government contracts and any effects on its reputation.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.