An AI detection service found that many opinion pieces published in several US newspapers as part of a campaign opposing Waymo were written with significant AI input.
The op-eds, which appeared in outlets including the New York Daily News, Dallas Morning News, San Francisco Chronicle, San Diego Union-Tribune and Times of San Diego, argued that Waymo's robotaxis could cost jobs, endanger riders and block fire trucks. Pangram's analysis found that many of the pieces were written with significant AI input, with some registering 95% as AI-written or likely AI-generated.
Ira Goldstein, former head of New York's Black Car Fund and author of a New York Daily News op-ed, told Semafor that a first draft was prepared by his PR firm. 'I stand by every word in this OpEd and believe that AI being used without my knowledge, to write a first draft of a 700-word opinion piece pales in comparison to the economic and public safety damage that thousands of AI powered robotaxis will inflict on New York City,' he said.
Michael Redmond, author of a San Francisco Chronicle piece, said he uses AI tools for research and to organise his thinking. Chronicle editor Matt Fleischer said the news organization's policies were to ask opinion writers to disclose whether they had used AI.
Dallas Morning News commentary editor Ryan Sanders said the paper does not accept pieces generated entirely by AI. New York Daily News executive editor Andrew Julien said the organisation aims to create stricter guardrails against AI on the site. The paper, he said, feels 'strongly that our readers deserve original opinions, certainly not machine-generated content created by companies we are suing over billions of dollars they owe us for stealing our content.'
The Washington Post reported that the Coalition for Accountability and Road Safety, a group opposing Waymo, spent more than $2.6 million on ads in the Washington DC area in 2026. Waymo, which operates commercially in 15 US cities, has faced opposition from labour unions, ride-hailing companies such as Uber and Lyft, and other groups.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The use of AI in op-eds challenges media authenticity and trust, especially as readers seek verified human perspectives.
- It reflects the broader conflict between AI advocates and skeptics, with both sides leveraging AI tools in public campaigns.
- The revelations may push news organisations to strengthen policies on AI disclosure and use.
Background
Waymo, an autonomous vehicle company under Alphabet, has expanded commercial operations to 15 cities despite opposition from various groups concerned about safety, jobs and public accountability. The Coalition for Accountability and Road Safety has been a prominent opponent.
Key Perspectives
- Ira Goldstein: Believes AI drafting is minor compared to the dangers of autonomous vehicles.
- Michael Redmond: Considers AI tools a normal part of modern writing.
- David Margulies (for Amy Witherite): Maintains that AI is used for initial drafts but all content is reviewed and approved by the author.
- Ryan Sanders (Dallas Morning News): Accepts limited AI use for research but not fully generated pieces.
- Andrew Julien (New York Daily News): Advocates for stricter AI guardrails due to the paper's legal actions against AI companies.
What to Watch
- Updates to newspaper policies on AI-generated submissions.
- The outcome of the New York Daily News' litigation against Microsoft and OpenAI.
- Regulatory decisions affecting Waymo's operations in various cities.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedAI-assisted op-eds were used in a campaign against Waymo, according to Pangram’s detection.Semafor: “Pangram found that many of the pieces were written with a significant amount of AI input”
- SupportedPangram identified multiple pieces as largely AI-written.Semafor: “Pangram found that many of the pieces were written with a significant amount of AI input”
- SupportedAuthors and newspapers responded to the findings.Semafor: “Michael Redmond, the San Francisco Chronicle author. Chronicle editor Matt Fleischer told Semafor that the news organization’s policies were to ask opinion writers to disclose whether they had used AI.”
- SupportedMany opinion pieces in a campaign opposing Waymo were written with significant AI input.Semafor: “They’ve been waging a kitchen sink campaign, placing op-eds in local news outlets ... Pangram found that many of the pieces were written with a significant amount of AI input”
- SupportedThe campaign’s op-eds appeared in the New York Daily News, Dallas Morning News, San Francisco Chronicle, San Diego Union-Tribune and Times of San Diego.Semafor: “The campaign also included series of op-eds for the Dallas Morning News ... a San Francisco Chronicle article ... another Daily News piece ... a San Diego Union-Tribune piece ... and a Times of San Diego piece”
- SupportedThe op-eds argued that Waymo’s robotaxis could cost jobs, endanger riders and block fire trucks.Semafor: “local news outlets arguing the autonomous taxi company Waymo could cost jobs, endanger riders, deprive the government of information, and block fire trucks”
- SupportedSome pieces registered 95% as AI-written or likely AI-generated.Semafor: “which registered as 95% AI-written ... on Pangram”
- SupportedIra Goldstein said a first draft of his New York Daily News op-ed was prepared by his PR firm.Semafor: ““A first draft of this OpEd was prepared by our PR firm at the time, which is standard procedure when working with a PR firm.””
- SupportedGoldstein said he stood by every word and that AI being used without his knowledge to write the first draft paled in comparison to the damage he expected from robotaxis.Semafor: ““With all that said, I stand by every word in this OpEd and believe that AI being used without my knowledge, to write a first draft of a 700-word opinion piece pales in comparison to the economic and public safety damage””
- SupportedMichael Redmond said he uses AI tools for research and to organise his thinking.Semafor: ““Like many, many writers, I use AI tools for research, to sometimes test my arguments, help organize my thinking, and make my writing as clear as possible,” said Michael Redmond”
- SupportedThe Chronicle’s policies were to ask opinion writers to disclose whether they had used AI.Semafor: “Chronicle editor Matt Fleischer told Semafor that the news organization’s policies were to ask opinion writers to disclose whether they had used AI.”
- SupportedThe Washington Post reported that the Coalition for Accountability and Road Safety spent more than $2.6 million on ads in the Washington DC area in 2026.Semafor: “The Washington Post reported this month that the Coalition for Accountability and Road Safety, a group of Waymo opponents, spent more than $2.6 million on ads in the DC area in 2026”