U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan, R-Alaska, accused his Democratic opponent Mary Peltola and her campaign on Tuesday of running what he called the biggest election cheating scandal in Alaska's history, two days after a federal judge dismissed a Justice Department lawsuit seeking to stop the state from declaring a winner if Peltola tops the ticket.
After casting his ballot at the Alaska Zoo in Anchorage, a designated polling site for two South Anchorage precincts, Sullivan told reporters the scandal was the effort to put a different candidate who shares his name on the ballot: Dan J. Sullivan of Petersburg, a retired teacher and longtime resident of that Southeast Alaska island community. "Unfortunately, the scheme is working," the senator said. "The decoy is on the ballot. Thousands, likely, of Alaskans are going to mistakenly throw away their vote. There's no one voting for this guy on purpose."
The race between Sullivan and Peltola could determine which party controls the U.S. Senate. The Alaska Supreme Court has ruled that Dan Sullivan of Petersburg has a legal right to be on the ballot, and there is no law against convincing anyone to run for office for any reason unless bribery is involved. The tactic, known as "ballot stacking," is generally legal, and both parties have used it in Alaska elections.
The controversy drew national attention after the New York Times reported efforts by Democratic operatives connected to Peltola's former staffers to persuade the Petersburg Sullivan to run. President Donald Trump, who called the Petersburg Sullivan a "fake," has called for Peltola to be stripped from the ballot and the Alaska election to be overturned if she won. U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman said Friday that federal and state law enforcement officials are investigating the election for potential civil and criminal violations, and that the Justice Department is aware of allegations that the Peltola campaign and national Democrats "orchestrated a sprawling conspiracy to recruit, prop up Dan. J Sullivan as a sham candidate, and we are taking that extremely seriously." A federal judge on Sunday dismissed the Justice Department's lawsuit, and the Trump administration plans to appeal.
Sullivan pointed to the attention the race has drawn. "The whole country's watching this," he said. He also said, "I think we're just touching the tip of the iceberg here," and referred to a circulating idea that, if true, hush money was paid to make a campaign manager drop her lawsuit.
Several Alaska voters dismissed the idea of confusion, noting that the ballot identifies the senator as the incumbent and that the state's ranked-choice voting system allows both Sullivans to be chosen. Ella Wheeles, 18, a first-time General Election voter from Anchorage, said, "If you know what the word incumbent means, it should not be a problem. I think it's pretty self-explanatory." TJ Smith, an Anchorage resident of more than 30 years, said the judge "did a really good job making it very clear who the incumbent is, who the incumbent isn't." Brandon Harker, another Anchorage voter, called the issue "blown out of proportion," adding that he thought ranked-choice voting kind of negates any potential for that to really affect the outcome.
Petersburg resident Barry Bracken, a friend of Dan J. Sullivan whom he described as "a very, very, very nice man," said FBI agents visited him Friday to ask about a donation he made to the Petersburg Sullivan's campaign. "Well, as far as I'm concerned, I contributed to the right Dan Sullivan, because I wouldn't give a nickel to the other guy," Bracken said at a news conference held outside the FBI's Anchorage office.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The race may decide which party controls the U.S. Senate, giving the dispute national stakes.
- It marks an unusual federal intervention in a state election: a Justice Department lawsuit, a presidential call to overturn the result if Peltola wins, and at least one FBI visit to a donor.
- The fight tests the legality and limits of "ballot stacking," a tactic both major parties have used in Alaska.
Background
Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, in which voters rank candidates in order of preference, a system that can allow an incumbent and a same-name challenger to both receive votes in the same race. The Alaska Supreme Court has already ruled that Dan J. Sullivan has a legal right to appear on the ballot, and there is no law against persuading someone to run for office unless bribery is involved. The incumbent's claims of deception follow a New York Times report that Democratic operatives connected to Peltola's former staffers encouraged the Petersburg Sullivan to run.
Key Perspectives
Sen. Dan Sullivan: calls the campaign to put Dan J. Sullivan on the ballot the biggest election cheating scandal in Alaska history and says thousands of voters will mistakenly waste their votes on the "decoy."
President Donald Trump: has called the Petersburg Sullivan a "fake" and has called for Peltola to be stripped from the ballot and the election overturned if she wins.
U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman: says officials are investigating allegations that the Peltola campaign "orchestrated a sprawling conspiracy to recruit, prop up Dan. J Sullivan as a sham candidate" and are taking them extremely seriously.
Alaska voters interviewed by the Alaska Beacon: dismiss the confusion claims, pointing to the incumbent label on the ballot and ranked-choice voting as making the race simple to understand.
What to Watch
- The Trump administration's appeal of the federal judge's dismissal of the Justice Department lawsuit.
- Whether the federal and state investigation produces charges before the election result is certified.
- The outcome of the race, including where voters rank the two Sullivans in the ranked-choice count.
Checked
10 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedSullivan called the same-name candidate scheme the “biggest election cheating scandal” in Alaska’s history.Alaska Beacon: ““We are witnessing the biggest election cheating scandal in the history of the state of Alaska, one of the, maybe one of the biggest in the US Senate’s history,””
- SupportedSullivan accused Peltola and her campaign on Tuesday of election cheating over the effort to put another Dan Sullivan on the ballot.Alaska Beacon: “Sullivan used the impromptu news conference to make more accusations against his main opponent, Democratic candidate Mary Peltola and her campaign. ... The scandal, Sullivan said, is the campaign to put a different candidate who shares his name onto the ballot.”
- SupportedThe race could determine which party controls the U.S. Senate.Alaska Beacon: “Dan J. Sullivan of Petersburg, a retired teacher and longtime resident of that Southeast Alaska island community, is one of the candidates in a high-stakes race that could determine which party controls the U.S. Senate.”
- SupportedThe judge dismissed the Justice Department lawsuit two days before Sullivan spoke, and the suit sought to stop the state declaring a winner if Peltola finished first.Alaska Beacon: “A federal judge on Sunday dismissed the Justice Department’s lawsuit seeking to block the state from declaring a winner in the U.S. Senate race if Peltola winds up on top.”
- SupportedSullivan said, “The decoy is on the ballot. Thousands, likely, of Alaskans are going to mistakenly throw away their vote. There's no one voting for this guy on purpose.”Alaska Beacon: ““The decoy is on the ballot. Thousands, likely, of Alaskans are going to mistakenly throw away their vote. There’s no one voting for this guy on purpose.””
- SupportedSullivan said “the whole country's watching this.”Alaska Beacon: ““The whole country’s watching this,” he said.”
- SupportedSullivan said the Petersburg candidate had a legal right to be on the ballot, and that convincing someone to run is not illegal unless bribery is involved.Alaska Beacon: “The Alaska Supreme Court already ruled that Dan Sullivan of Petersburg has the legal right to be on the ballot, and there is no law against convincing anyone to run for office for any reason unless bribery is involved.”
- SupportedThe story says the hush-money idea was circulating and qualifies it with “if true.”Alaska Beacon: ““There’s now circulating, certainly in Alaska, this idea that there’s hush money paid to make the campaign manager drop her lawsuit and (recant) her story. Who knows who paid that hush money, if it’s true.””
- SupportedThe Justice Department was aware of allegations that the Peltola campaign and national Democrats recruited Dan J. Sullivan as a sham candidate, and Heyman said officials were investigating possible civil and criminal violations.Alaska Beacon: “U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman, in an Anchorage news conference on Friday, said federal and state law enforcement officials are investigating the election for potential civil and criminal violations. Heyman said the Justice Department is aware of allegations that the Peltola campaign and national Democrats “orchestrated a sprawling conspiracy to recruit, prop up Dan. J Sullivan as a sham candidate, and we are taking that extremely seriously.””
- SupportedBracken said FBI agents visited him Friday to ask about his donation to Dan J. Sullivan’s campaign.Alaska Beacon: “Bracken, speaking Monday at a news conference held by the left-leaning 907 Initiative and the Alaska AFL-CIO, the state’s largest union, said he got a visit by two Federal Bureau of Investigation agents on Friday who quizzed him about the donation he made to the Petersburg Sullivan.”