Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is facing calls from across the political spectrum and the Ukrainian diaspora to boycott posing for a photograph alongside Russian President Vladimir Putin at this week’s APEC leaders’ summit in China, but has not ruled out taking part in a group photo if it is the wish of the host country.
Albanese and Canadian counterpart Mark Carney have indicated they are open to posing for a “family photo” with Putin and other leaders to avoid offending their Chinese hosts. Carney was more definitive, saying: “Yes, I will participate in the photo out of respect for the host. We’re in Asia.”
The Russian president is set to appear at his first APEC summit since 2017. Putin rarely travels to global summits because the International Criminal Court has issued an arrest warrant for alleged war crimes relating to deportation of children. China is not a member of the court, meaning Putin is not liable for arrest on Chinese soil.
The Australian Federation of Ukrainian Organisations said it was alarmed that Albanese had not ruled out posing alongside Putin, who ordered the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Chair Kateryna Argyrou said: “Vladimir Putin is not just another world leader attending an international summit. He is an indicted war criminal and the architect of a brutal war against Ukraine – a war that has brought death, destruction and unimaginable suffering to millions of people.”
“How can it possibly be acceptable for Anthony Albanese, the leader of a democratic country which has stood alongside Ukraine for nearly five years, to willingly take part in a photograph with the man responsible for this war?” Argyrou said. “Standing and smiling beside Putin ignores Russia’s gross violation of international law, and normalises an indicted war criminal’s presence among world leaders as his forces continue to murder Ukrainian civilians, destroy cities and deliberately target civilian infrastructure. Prime Minister Albanese should not be in that photo.”
Albanese said on Sunday: “But we will make very clear our views about Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.”
Greens leader David Shoebridge said he found it remarkable Albanese was entertaining the idea. “Of course you shouldn’t be seen in a photograph with Vladimir Putin,” he said, adding that it was “a moment for the prime minister to show some kind of ticker and principle, and I hope he steps out when the camera’s on”.
Liberal frontbencher Andrew Bragg said he was unsettled by the prospect. “I don’t know that we want to encourage our prime minister to be having photos with people who have been running wars against humanity over the last few years,” he said. “Now, if we have to engage with people for economic and diplomatic reasons, fine, but I don’t think he should be going out of his way to hang out with Vladimir Putin.”
Fellow frontbencher Andrew Hastie disagreed, telling the ABC he was not especially troubled by the prospect of Albanese appearing in a photo with Putin.
Ukraine’s ambassador to Australia, Vasyl Myroschnychenko, said: “We hope that the PM will continue to be guided by Australia’s very prominent pro-Ukraine stance. Substance matters more to Ukraine than style.”
Albanese has also endorsed the historic trilateral meeting due to take place between Putin, US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping in China, even as critics expressed concern it would legitimise Russia as a great power and allow the leaders to carve up spheres of influence.
The prime minister was otherwise talking up the strength of middle powers as he arrived at ASEAN in Manila on Monday, which is taking place before APEC. Albanese will meet Trump at a Quad meeting with India and Japan on Tuesday evening.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The decision could signal Australia's stance on normalising relations with Putin amid the ongoing war in Ukraine.
- It tests the strength of the cross-party consensus in Australia supporting Ukraine.
- The photo opportunity may set a precedent for how Western leaders engage with Putin at international forums.
Background
Putin has largely avoided global summits since the International Criminal Court issued an arrest warrant for alleged war crimes over the deportation of children from Ukraine. China, not a member of the ICC, provides a safe venue for his attendance. Australia has been a strong supporter of Ukraine since the 2022 invasion, providing military aid and diplomatic backing. The APEC summit in Shenzhen is Putin's first since 2017.
Key Perspectives
Ukrainian diaspora (Kateryna Argyrou): says it is unacceptable for Albanese to pose with an indicted war criminal whose forces continue to kill civilians and destroy infrastructure; the prime minister should not be in that photo.
Greens leader David Shoebridge: says Albanese should show principle and step out when the camera is on.
Liberal frontbencher Andrew Bragg: says he is unsettled by the prospect and Albanese should not go out of his way to be with Putin.
Liberal frontbencher Andrew Hastie: says he is not especially troubled by the prospect of the photo.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney: says he will participate in the photo out of respect for the host.
Ukraine's ambassador to Australia Vasyl Myroschnychenko: says substance matters more than style and hopes Albanese remains guided by Australia's pro-Ukraine stance.
What to Watch
- Whether Albanese joins the family photo when it is taken at the APEC summit.
- The trilateral meeting between Putin, Trump and Xi, and whether it produces any public statements on Ukraine.
- Reaction from Ukraine's government and Western allies if Albanese does appear in the photo.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedAlbanese is under fire over a possible photo with Putin at APEC.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “‘Of course you shouldn’t’: Albanese under fire over possible Putin photo.”
- SupportedAlbanese faces cross-party calls and calls from the Ukrainian diaspora to boycott a family photo with Putin.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is facing calls from across the political spectrum and the Ukrainian diaspora to boycott posing for a photo alongside Russian President Vladimir Putin at this week’s APEC leaders’ summit in China.”
- SupportedAlbanese has not ruled out taking part in an APEC leaders’ photo with Putin if China wants it.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Albanese did not rule out appearing in an APEC leaders’ photo with Putin on Thursday if that was the wish of China as the host country.”
- SupportedCarney said, “Yes, I will participate in the photo out of respect for the host. We’re in Asia.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““Yes, I will participate in the photo out of respect for the host. We’re in Asia.””
- SupportedPutin is set to attend his first APEC leaders’ summit since 2017.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Russian President Vladimir Putin is set to appear at his first APEC leaders’ summit since 2017.”
- SupportedPutin rarely travels to global summits because of an ICC arrest warrant over alleged war crimes relating to the deportation of children; China is not a member of the court, so he is not liable for arrest there.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Putin rarely travels to global summits because the International Criminal Court has issued an arrest warrant for alleged war crimes relating to deportation of children. China is not a member of the court, meaning Putin is not liable for arrest on Chinese soil.”
- SupportedPutin ordered the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “The Russian president ordered the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 .”
- SupportedArgyrou called Putin “an indicted war criminal and the architect of a brutal war against Ukraine”.Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““Vladimir Putin is not just another world leader attending an international summit. He is an indicted war criminal and the architect of a brutal war against Ukraine – a war that has brought death, destruction and unimaginable suffering to millions of people,” federation chair Kateryna Argyrou said.”
- SupportedAlbanese said on Sunday, “But we will make very clear our views about Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““But we will make very clear our views about Russia’s invasion of Ukraine,” Albanese said on Sunday.”
- SupportedShoebridge said, “Of course you shouldn’t be seen in a photograph with Vladimir Putin.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““Of course you shouldn’t be seen in a photograph with Vladimir Putin,” he said.”
- SupportedBragg said he did not think Albanese should go out of his way to spend time with Putin.Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““Now, if we have to engage with people for economic and diplomatic reasons, fine, but I don’t think he should be going out of his way to hang out with Vladimir Putin.””
- SupportedAlbanese endorsed a planned trilateral meeting between Putin, Trump and Xi in China, amid critics’ concerns it could legitimise Russia as a great power and let the leaders carve up spheres of influence.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Albanese has also endorsed the historic trilateral meeting due to take place between Putin, US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping in China, even as critics expressed concern it would legitimise Russia as a great power and allow the leaders to carve up spheres of influence.”