Why This Matters
- The perceived imbalance could shape public and political perceptions of the AUKUS deal, potentially undermining trust in the United States while deflecting scrutiny from China.
- The inquiry's approach may influence how Australia's parliament and public weigh the security benefits and risks of the submarine program.
- The finding comes as debate continues over whether AUKUS strengthens or weakens Australia's security.
Background
AUKUS, announced in 2021, is intended to provide Australia with nuclear-powered submarines through cooperation with the US and UK. The public inquiry was established to examine aspects of the deal, including its strategic implications and costs. The Lowy Institute is an independent Australian think tank that regularly publishes analysis on international affairs and defence policy.
Key Perspectives
Sam Roggeveen (Lowy Institute): Argues the inquiry's scepticism runs only one way, doubting Washington's motives at length while barely questioning Beijing's.
What to Watch
- Whether the inquiry's final report reflects a more balanced assessment of both US and Chinese positions.
- Political reaction in Australia to the criticism of the inquiry's approach.
- Whether the analysis influences public opinion on AUKUS ahead of any eventual parliamentary vote on the submarine acquisition.