Analysis: Why three-peat Hawks and another super side have Fagan's Heroes covered

Jake Niall examines the historical company the Brisbane Lions join after a third consecutive AFL premiership

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
The Brisbane Lions' third consecutive AFL premiership places coach Chris Fagan's team in rare company, but chief football writer Jake Niall argues that the three-peat Hawthorn team of the early 2010s and another super side have the Lions covered when it comes to sustained dominance.

The Brisbane Lions under coach Chris Fagan have completed a three-peat, winning the AFL grand final in 2024, 2025 and 2026, as depicted in an image showing the coach and co-captains Josh Dunkley, Harris Andrews and Hugh McCluggage with the three premiership cups.

In an opinion piece published by the Brisbane Times and Sydney Morning Herald, chief football writer Jake Niall notes that it is a strange quirk of the 21st century AFL that three teams have achieved what the equalised system is supposed to prevent and taken three premierships consecutively.

Niall observes that when the Brisbane Lions team coached by Leigh Matthews won the 2003 grand final, demolishing a much less talented Collingwood team, they were the first club since the 1950s Melbourne side to complete what became known as the three-peat. That Melbourne team played before colour television in a quasi-amateur sport in a Victorian-only competition.

Geelong of 2007-2011 had the capacity to equal that record, but stumbled in 2008 on grand final day and in 2010 when their game style was overtaken and hunger waned, and they did not make the grand final. Hawthorn, a beneficiary of the AFL's expansion, would be the next three-peater under Alastair Clarkson, their super team claiming the 2013, 2014 and 2015 flags against a treble of non-Victorian opponents.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The Lions' three-peat is a rare achievement in the modern AFL, where equalisation measures are designed to prevent sustained dominance.
  • Comparisons with previous great teams help contextualise the Lions' place in AFL history and spark debate about the toughest eras.
  • The achievement raises questions about the effectiveness of the AFL's equalisation policies when such dominance remains possible.

Background

A three-peat in the AFL refers to winning three consecutive premierships. Before the Lions, only two teams had achieved this in the modern era: the Brisbane Lions under Leigh Matthews (2001-2003) and Hawthorn under Alastair Clarkson (2013-2015). The Melbourne side of the 1950s also achieved three consecutive flags. Geelong, which won premierships in 2007, 2009 and 2011, could have three-peated but fell short in 2008 and 2010.

Key Perspectives

[Brisbane Lions (Chris Fagan's side)]: Their 2024-2026 three-peat places them among the greatest teams of the 21st century. [Niall's analysis]: The three-peat Hawks and another unnamed super side have the current Lions covered in terms of overall team strength and sustained dominance. [Critics/Skeptics]: Some may argue that the current Lions face different challenges and that direct comparisons across eras are inherently flawed due to rule changes, list management rules, and competition depth.

What to Watch

  • How the Lions follow up their three-peat; whether they can contend for a fourth flag or begin a natural decline.
  • Whether the AFL considers any rule or equalisation changes in response to the dominance.
  • Historical reassessments as the Lions' core players age and the team evolves.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.