MelbourneDeveloping

Security overhaul for MPs under consideration after Helen Haines attack

Labor weighs bolstered police protection and home security upgrades as Parliament prepares Monday tributes

By LineZotpaper
Published
Updated
Read Time3 min
Sources13 outlets
The Albanese government is weighing options to give federal MPs bolstered police protection and funded security upgrades for their homes and offices, after the alleged attack on independent MP Helen Haines. Parliament will hold a dedicated session of tributes on Monday, with Haines remaining in critical condition after surgeons amputated both her legs.

Government sources said ministers wanted the Australian Federal Police's protective services to be more proactive, including providing threat assessments without MPs having to request them and opening better lines of communication. "Currently [MPs] feel in the dark," one source said, adding that the system is "a bit reactive now. The assumption should be that something could go wrong."

The options, which are still subject to change, include an overhaul of how safety at electorate offices is upgraded, a process that can currently take months, and making it easier for MPs to install cameras and fences at their homes, potentially through a government-funded round of upgrades or a tax deductibility scheme. MPs currently pay thousands for such installations themselves.

Well-placed sources said the attack had elevated a widely held sense among MPs of all parties that more must be done to counter rising threats, although authorities believe the attack on Haines was opportunistic rather than planned. Authorities have also expressed frustration with MPs who fail to follow protocol when flagging high-risk events or reporting incidents.

Haines was rammed by a LandCruiser while taking items from the boot of her car outside her electorate office in Wangaratta in north-east Victoria. Her husband Phil Haines revealed on Wednesday that both her legs had been amputated as surgeons at Melbourne's Alfred Hospital fought to save her life. Her chief of staff, Kaz Rourke, said the office may reopen next week and that the attack has been deeply traumatic for the team.

Kooyong MP Monique Ryan, a friend of Haines, called for bollards outside offices but dismissed the need for permanent guards. "There's a real balance to be found here on what we can do here that's reasonable and not excessive without freaking everyone out," she said. Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke has pointed to the UK's move to assign each MP a specific security officer.

At the state level, Victorian Premier Ben Carroll met the electoral commissioner and police chief commissioner Mike Bush on Wednesday to discuss stronger safety measures. Bush said police were working to establish a centralised process for monitoring threats against MPs, a "single-stop shop" for reporting. Victorian MPs were due for a police briefing on Friday.

Female Victorian MPs have described intensified threats. Upper house MP Georgie Purcell said a constituent commented on her statement supporting Haines that he wished it had happened to her, while another wrote "You should be scared." Nationals MP Annabelle Cleeland said she shares her live location with her husband and staff on the road. "I don't feel like I signed up for this job to put my children in harm's way and, right now, I'm frightened about that," she told ABC Radio Melbourne.

Opposition Leader Angus Taylor urged caution about limiting debate. "Our democracy was built on the Westminster system, which requires and needs vigorous and rigorous debate, but it should never cross the line," he said.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The attack on Helen Haines has pushed MP safety to the top of the national agenda, with all parties calling for a more proactive security regime.
  • State and federal MPs say threats, particularly against women, have escalated and are changing how they campaign, work and live.
  • With a Victorian election five weeks away and a federal election ahead, authorities are racing to put new protections in place.

Background

Helen Haines, the independent federal MP for Indi, was allegedly attacked on Monday outside her electorate office in Wangaratta by a constituent driving a four-wheel-drive. She remains in critical condition in Melbourne's Alfred Hospital after the amputation of both legs. The case has exposed long-running tensions between MPs and security agencies, with politicians claiming agencies are too reactive while authorities say some MPs fail to follow protocol. A wide-ranging independent review of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Support System, launched by Special Minister of State Don Farrell, has been underway since April.

Key Perspectives

Federal government and MPs: Ministers want the AFP to be more proactive, including automatic threat assessments and better communication, while MPs want faster security upgrades at electorate offices and support for cameras and fences at home. Security agencies and police: Authorities point to the importance of MPs following protocol and note the Haines attack appears to have been opportunistic, meaning some proposed measures may not prevent a similar incident. Victorian police are building a centralised threat monitoring process. Victorian MPs and critics: Female MPs describe sexualised, violent threats targeting their children and homes and say the current system leaves them on high alert. Some, like Monique Ryan, caution against excessive measures, while Opposition Leader Angus Taylor warns against constraining vigorous democratic debate.

What to Watch

  • Monday's dedicated parliamentary session of tributes for Helen Haines and any security announcement that accompanies it.
  • Friday's Victorian police briefing for MPs and the rollout of the proposed centralised threat reporting system.
  • The findings of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Support System review, which may feed into an immediate package of measures.
  • Whether the federal government funds home security upgrades directly or through tax deductions, and how quickly electorate office upgrades can be accelerated.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 2 sources: 11 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedA security overhaul for MPs is under consideration after the Haines attack.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The security upgrades are subject to change but likely to include an overhaul of the way in which safety at electorate offices is upgraded”
  2. SupportedLabor is weighing bolstered police protection for federal MPs.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Politicians would receive bolstered police protection and security for homes and offices under options being weighed by Labor”
  3. Partly supportedSecurity upgrades for both homes and offices are described as funded options.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The government also wants to make it easier for MPs to install cameras and fences at their homes, potentially through a government-funded round of upgrades or a tax deductibility scheme.”
  4. SupportedParliament will hold a dedicated session of tributes for Haines on Monday.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Parliament will hold a dedicated session of tributes for Helen Haines on Monday.”
  5. SupportedHaines is in critical condition after both her legs were amputated.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Haines remains in critical condition three days after she was rammed by a LandCruiser”
  6. SupportedA source said, “Currently [MPs] feel in the dark.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““Currently [MPs] feel in the dark,” one source said”
  7. SupportedA source said the system is “a bit reactive now” and that “The assumption should be that something could go wrong.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““The system is a bit reactive now. The assumption should be that something could go wrong.””
  8. SupportedAuthorities believe the attack was opportunistic rather than planned.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “what authorities believe was an opportunistic, rather than planned, attack on Haines”
  9. SupportedKaz Rourke said the Wangaratta office may reopen next week and the attack was deeply traumatic for the team.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Kaz Rourke, Haines’ chief of staff, released a statement on Thursday saying the MP’s team was devastated and the Wangaratta office may reopen next week. “Most of us were in the office when the incident occurred and some of us were involved in Helen’s immediate care, so this has been deeply traumatic for the team,” she said.”
  10. SupportedMonique Ryan called for bollards outside offices and said, “There's a real balance to be found here on what we can do here that's reasonable and not excessive without freaking everyone out.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““There’s a real balance to be found here on what we can do here that’s reasonable and not excessive without freaking everyone out,” said Monique Ryan, member for Kooyong and a friend of Haines, calling for bollards outside offices but dismissing the need for permanent guards.”
  11. SupportedA constituent told Georgie Purcell, “You should be scared.”World news | The Guardian: “Another, a little while later, said: “You should be scared.””
  12. SupportedAnnabelle Cleeland said, “I don't feel like I signed up for this job to put my children in harm's way and, right now, I'm frightened about that,” to ABC Radio Melbourne.World news | The Guardian: ““I don’t feel like I signed up for this job to put my children in harm’s way and, right now, I’m frightened about that,” she told ABC Radio Melbourne on Thursday.”

Zotpaper

Written by June Katz on the Australia & local desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

7 sources11 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published updated once
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe