Bangladesh says Saudi Arabia executed two citizens without notifying Dhaka

Government seeks details of Mecca case that has stirred public concern

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Bangladeshi authorities say they were not informed of the execution of two Bangladeshi nationals in Saudi Arabia until after it had taken place, and have asked Riyadh for details of the case. A man and woman were executed last Wednesday in Mecca after being convicted of committing an "indecent act" inside a mosque, according to the Saudi interior ministry.

Bangladesh says it was not notified beforehand of the execution, local media report. State minister for foreign affairs Shama Obaed Islam said the government had reached out to Saudi authorities about the offences involved and legal proceedings, and would consider next steps, including the repatriation of the bodies, once it receives information. She said the government was committed to safeguarding the welfare and interests of Bangladeshis abroad.

The Saudi interior ministry said the pair were convicted and sentenced to death under "tazir", the Islamic law category for punishments left to the discretion of a judge. The ministry cited the severity of the offence and the violation of the "sanctity" of the mosque, but did not specify the nature of the act.

The Daily Star reported that the two executed nationals appeared on a list of prisoners Saudi Arabia shared with Bangladesh at the request of the Bangladeshi Consulate General in Jeddah, but that the list did not indicate they had been sentenced to death.

The case has raised public concern in Bangladesh, where more than three million nationals work and live in Saudi Arabia, mostly in low-paying jobs. Amnesty International says Saudi Arabia has executed around 100 people this year, many of them foreigners convicted of drug offences. In 2011, eight Bangladeshi men were publicly executed in Riyadh after being found guilty of killing an Egyptian.

Earlier this month, Saudi Arabia overturned the death sentence of a Sri Lankan man convicted of blasphemy over a Facebook comment, after the case sparked public outcry in Sri Lanka and diplomatic appeals for clemency.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Dhaka's claim that it learned of the executions only afterwards raises questions about how Saudi Arabia handles foreign nationals facing capital punishment on its soil.
  • With more than three million Bangladeshi workers in the kingdom, the case has stirred public concern in Bangladesh and could test a relationship built on religious affinity and strong economic ties.
  • Coming weeks after Saudi Arabia commuted a Sri Lankan man's death sentence, the case shows diplomatic pressure can influence outcomes in the kingdom.

Background

Saudi Arabia's criminal justice system applies Islamic law, including tazir punishments left to a judge's discretion, and the death penalty is used for a range of offences. Executions of foreign nationals are not unprecedented, and rights groups have voiced concerns about the number of executions carried out this year, many involving foreigners. Bangladesh and Saudi Arabia maintain close political and economic ties, with large numbers of Bangladeshi migrants working in the kingdom.

Key Perspectives

Bangladesh: The government says it was not informed of the executions in advance, has asked Saudi authorities for details of the offences and legal proceedings, and will consider next steps such as repatriating the bodies once it has that information. It frames the case within a commitment to protect Bangladeshis abroad.

Saudi Arabia: The interior ministry defends the executions as punishment for an "indecent act" inside a mosque, imposed under tazir because of the severity of the offence and the violation of the mosque's sanctity. It has not specified the act.

Human rights observers: Amnesty International's count of around 100 executions in the kingdom this year, many of them foreigners, points to broader concerns about the use of the death penalty and the position of migrant workers in the Saudi justice system.

What to Watch

  • Saudi Arabia's response to Bangladesh's request for details of the offences and legal proceedings.
  • Whether Bangladesh secures the repatriation of the bodies and any official account of why it was not notified.
  • Whether public concern in Bangladesh escalates into official protest, and whether Riyadh shows similar clemency to that granted in the Sri Lankan case.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedBangladesh says Saudi Arabia executed two citizens without notifying DhakaBBC News: “Bangladeshi authorities say they were not informed of the recent execution of two Bangladeshi nationals in the holy city of Mecca until after it had taken place, local media reports.”
  2. SupportedGovernment seeks details of Mecca case that has stirred public concernBBC News: “Bangladesh says it has reached out to the Saudi Arabian government to ask for more details about the case. ... news of the double execution has raised public concern in Bangladesh.”
  3. SupportedA man and woman were executed last Wednesday in Mecca after being convicted of committing an 'indecent act' inside a mosque, according to the Saudi interior ministryBBC News: “A Bangladeshi man and woman were executed last Wednesday after being convicted of committing an 'indecent act' inside a mosque, according to the Saudi interior ministry.”
  4. SupportedBangladesh says it was not notified beforehand of the execution, local media reportBBC News: “Bangladeshi authorities say they were not informed of the recent execution of two Bangladeshi nationals in the holy city of Mecca until after it had taken place, local media reports.”
  5. SupportedState minister for foreign affairs Shama Obaed Islam said the government had reached out to Saudi authorities about the offences involved and legal proceedings, and would consider next steps, including the repatriation of the bodies, once it receives informationBBC News: “Bangladesh has reached out to the Saudi government about the offences involved and legal proceedings in the case, said state minister for foreign affairs Shama Obaed Islam. The government would consider next steps, such as the repatriation of the bodies, after getting information from Saudi authorities, Islam said.”
  6. SupportedShe said the government was committed to safeguarding the welfare and interests of Bangladeshis abroadBBC News: “She added that the government was committed to safeguarding the welfare and interests of Bangladeshis abroad.”
  7. SupportedThe Saudi interior ministry said the pair were convicted and sentenced to death under 'tazir', the Islamic law category for punishments left to the discretion of a judgeBBC News: “According to the Saudi interior ministry, the two Bangladeshi nationals were convicted and sentenced to death under 'tazir', which in Islamic law refers to punishments left to the discretion of the judge.”
  8. SupportedThe ministry cited the severity of the offence and the violation of the 'sanctity' of the mosque, but did not specify the nature of the actBBC News: “The ministry statement said they were handed the sentences because of the severity of the offence, and the fact that they violated the 'sanctity' of the mosque. The ministry did not specify the nature of the offending act.”
  9. SupportedThe Daily Star reported that the two executed nationals appeared on a list of prisoners Saudi Arabia shared with Bangladesh at the request of the Bangladeshi Consulate General in Jeddah, but that the list did not indicate they had been sentenced to deathBBC News: “The two executed Bangladeshis were included in a list of prisoners that Saudi Arabia had shared with Bangladesh, upon a request from the Bangladesh Consulate General in Jeddah - but that list did not indicate that the pair had been sentenced to death, the Daily Star reported.”
  10. SupportedThe case has raised public concern in Bangladesh, where more than three million nationals work and live in Saudi Arabia, mostly in low-paying jobsBBC News: “More than three million Bangladeshis work and live in Saudi Arabia, mostly in low-paying jobs, and news of the double execution has raised public concern in Bangladesh.”
  11. SupportedAmnesty International says Saudi Arabia has executed around 100 people this year, many of them foreigners convicted of drug offencesBBC News: “According to Amnesty International, the country has executed around 100 people this year, many of whom are foreigners convicted of drug offences.”
  12. SupportedIn 2011, eight Bangladeshi men were publicly executed in Riyadh after being found guilty of killing an EgyptianBBC News: “In 2011, eight Bangladeshi men were publicly executed in the Saudi Arabian capital of Riyadh after they were found guilty of killing an Egyptian.”

Zotpaper

Written by Rex Doyle on the World desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source12 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published 19 Oct, 7:46 pm
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe