The BBC has traced Liam Kavanagh, the businessman at the centre of one of the biggest financial scandals in British local government history, to a luxury apartment in Bucharest, after his whereabouts had remained largely unknown for years. Thurrock Council in Essex invested more than £600m in Kavanagh's solar energy businesses despite warnings the investments were too risky, leaving the authority effectively bankrupt and forcing central government to step in with hundreds of millions of pounds of taxpayers' money.
The council is now suing Kavanagh, accusing him of deceit and alleging that millions of pounds of its investments were diverted for his personal benefit. Kavanagh denies misleading Thurrock and any wrongdoing. His legal defence says he honestly believed he was entitled to use the money in the way he did and highlights wording which he claims allowed him to make deductions from the money Thurrock invested.
Leaked bank records show millions moving from Kavanagh's company into his personal accounts, alongside payments for luxury purchases. Among the items he bought with the money were a £12m private jet, a yacht, a fleet of supercars, a country house once admired by Jane Austen, a Damien Hirst pickled sheep artwork and a £250,000 revolving bed. Leaked financial records give a glimpse of the life inside: one wall covered in Swarovski crystals, another featuring 25 television screens, and the enormous revolving bed that had to be lifted in by crane.
Councils were struggling with government spending cuts. Thurrock's finance director, Sean Clark, borrowed huge sums from other local authorities around the UK to fund the investments, often through deals that could be arranged with a few emails. At one point Thurrock owed more than £1bn to other councils.
The council's own financial adviser, Arlingclose, sounded the alarm. Chief executive Mark Pickering described the council's investment activity as "pretty extreme" and said his firm felt "the likelihood of them blowing up was pretty high". "You try several times to help a friend - and after a while you have to leave them to their own devices, don't you?" he said. Arlingclose eventually cut ties with Thurrock, but Clark carried on borrowing and investing.
Clark has admitted professional misconduct relating to his time at Thurrock. The Financial Reporting Council said he had "recklessly provided misleading information to council members, and therefore to the public". He received a severe reprimand and was excluded from membership of his professional accountancy body for five years. The Serious Fraud Office is investigating suspected fraud involving Kavanagh's businesses and Thurrock Council. It has not announced whether Kavanagh will face criminal charges.
BBC reporters traced Kavanagh to an exclusive apartment complex in northern Bucharest. They attempted to deliver a letter containing their questions and asked him to come downstairs to sign for it. He did not appear. Soon afterwards, a security guard carrying a camera was stationed outside the building. Kavanagh's lawyers later confirmed the correct address and said he did not wish to communicate directly.
Reporters also approached Clark near his home in Kent while he was walking his dog. Asked whether it was OK to ask some questions about Thurrock, Clark replied: "No, it isn't." Asked if he felt any guilt or had anything to say to the people of Thurrock, he answered simply: "No." He declined to answer why he had invested so much public money with one businessman, or whether he was "a fool or a crook".
The bill has arrived for Thurrock residents through higher council tax and reduced services. Local social entrepreneur Neil Woodbridge became emotional when asked about the lack of accountability. "I can't get my head around the fact that no-one's held to account," he said.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Thurrock residents are paying for the scandal through higher council tax and reduced services, with debts that will burden the authority for years.
- The case exposes failures in local government financial oversight, where hundreds of millions of pounds were invested without proper records or challenge.
- The Serious Fraud Office investigation and the council's lawsuit may determine whether those responsible face legal consequences.
Background
Thurrock Council in Essex invested more than £600m in solar energy businesses run by Liam Kavanagh, despite warnings from its own financial adviser. The investments initially appeared successful but collapsed, leaving the council with a vast financial black hole. It effectively went bankrupt, and central government had to provide hundreds of millions of pounds to keep services running. The council is now suing Kavanagh for deceit, and the Serious Fraud Office is investigating.
Key Perspectives
- Thurrock Council: Alleges that millions of pounds of its investments were diverted for Kavanagh's personal benefit and is suing him for deceit.
- Liam Kavanagh (via legal defence): Denies misleading Thurrock and any wrongdoing, claiming he honestly believed he was entitled to use the money as he did, citing wording in the agreements.
- Residents of Thurrock (via Neil Woodbridge): Express frustration that no one has been held accountable for the losses, which are now being paid through higher taxes and reduced services.
What to Watch
- The outcome of the council's civil lawsuit against Kavanagh, which will test the legal basis of his defence.
- Whether the Serious Fraud Office brings criminal charges against Kavanagh or others.
- Any further reporting from the BBC's investigation that reveals more details about how the money was used or who else may have been involved.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe BBC traced Liam Kavanagh to a luxury apartment in Bucharest.BBC News: “The BBC has tracked down businessman Liam Kavanagh to a luxury apartment in Bucharest.”
- SupportedThurrock Council invested more than £600m in Kavanagh’s solar businesses despite warnings that the investments were too risky.BBC News: “Thurrock Council in Essex invested more than £600m in Kavanagh's solar energy businesses - despite stark warnings that the investments were too risky.”
- SupportedThurrock was effectively bankrupt, prompting central government to provide hundreds of millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money.BBC News: “Thurrock was left with a vast financial black hole and effectively went bankrupt, forcing central government to step in with hundreds of millions of pounds of taxpayers' money.”
- SupportedThurrock residents faced higher council tax and reduced services.BBC News: “For the people of Thurrock, however, the bill has already arrived - through higher council tax, reduced services and debts that will burden the authority for years.”
- SupportedKavanagh bought luxury goods with money he received, including a £12m private jet and a £250,000 revolving bed.BBC News: “With the money he received, Kavanagh bought a £12m private jet, a yacht, a fleet of supercars, a country house adored by Jane Austen, a Damien Hirst pickled sheep artwork and a £250,000 revolving bed.”
- SupportedThe council is suing Kavanagh, accusing him of deceit and alleging that millions of pounds of its investments were diverted for his personal benefit.BBC News: “The council is now suing Kavanagh, accusing him of deceit and alleging that millions of pounds of its investments were diverted for his personal benefit.”
- SupportedKavanagh denies wrongdoing; his defence says he believed he was entitled to use the money as he did.BBC News: “Kavanagh denies misleading Thurrock and any wrongdoing. His legal defence says he honestly believed he was entitled to use the money in the way he did”
- SupportedMark Pickering said the investment activity was “pretty extreme”, the likelihood of it “blowing up” was “pretty high”, and quoted: “You try several times to help a friend - and after a while you have to leave them to their own devices, don't you?”BBC News: “Arlingclose chief executive Mark Pickering described the council's investment activity as "pretty extreme" and said his firm felt "the likelihood of them blowing up was pretty high". "You try several times to help a friend - and after a while you have to leave them to their own devices, don't you?" he said.”
- SupportedWhen asked if it was OK to ask questions about Thurrock, Clark replied, “No, it isn't.”BBC News: “BBC reporters approached him near his home in Kent while he was walking his dog and asked whether it was OK if we asked some questions about Thurrock. "No, it isn't," he replied.”
- SupportedAsked whether he felt guilt or had anything to say to Thurrock residents, Clark answered, “No.”BBC News: “Asked whether he felt any guilt, or had anything to say to the people of Thurrock, Clark answered simply: "No."”
- SupportedThe Financial Reporting Council said Clark had “recklessly provided misleading information to council members, and therefore to the public”; he received a severe reprimand and a five-year exclusion from his professional accountancy body.BBC News: “The Financial Reporting Council said he had "recklessly provided misleading information to council members, and therefore to the public". He received a severe reprimand and was excluded from membership of his professional accountancy body for five years.”
- Reports differNeil Woodbridge is a local social entrepreneur.BBC News: “Local charity worker Neil Woodbridge became emotional when we asked him about the lack of accountability.”