The brain's cross-wired organization, in which each hemisphere controls the opposite side of the body, may be a more than 500-million-year-old inheritance from the visual systems of ancient fish, according to a hypothesis published in Frontiers in Neuroanatomy.
Dr. Martin Wessendorf, a neuroscientist and associate professor emeritus at the University of Minnesota, and Daniel Wang, who specializes in cognitive neuroscience and neurodegenerative diseases, propose that evolution built new brain circuits around an ancient visual system. Once early visual pathways established a crossed arrangement, they argue, later sensory and motor circuits may have inherited it.
The crossed, or contralateral, organization is one of the most intriguing features of the nervous system. When light passes through the eye's lens, the image projected on the retina is reversed, and at the optic chiasm nerve fibers are arranged so that each side of the brain receives information from the opposite visual field. Some of those signals reach the optic tectum, an ancient midbrain structure present in every vertebrate that helps produce fast reactions to visual events.
The researchers examined two sensory pathways that cross the midline: the dorsal column pathway, which carries gentle touch, vibration and body-position signals, and the spinothalamic tract, which transmits pain, itch and certain types of touch. Both appear widespread among tetrapods, with the spinothalamic arrangement also found in sharks and rays, suggesting deeper evolutionary roots.
They also looked at three motor pathways that connect one side of the brain to the opposite side of the spinal cord: the tectospinal, rubrospinal and corticospinal pathways. The corticospinal tract supports precise finger movements in humans, and the researchers suggest humans may have developed fine motor abilities by adapting an older circuit originally involved in controlling sensory input, giving an existing pathway an additional purpose rather than creating a new system.
Because every living vertebrate has an optic chiasm and optic tectum organized around the opposite visual field, the researchers suspect these structures were already present in primitive jawless fish during the Cambrian Period, roughly 538 to 486 million years ago. That would place the origins of the brain's crossed organization more than half a billion years before modern humans appeared.
The hypothesis may be testable, the researchers say. Anatomical evidence from fossilized skulls of ancient jawless fish could help establish whether those animals possessed an optic chiasm and optic tectum.
The broader idea challenges the assumption that every unusual biological feature must have evolved because it provided a direct survival benefit. The crossed connections may not have arisen because controlling the opposite side of the body was inherently more effective; instead, they may reflect an ancient arrangement that evolution repeatedly reused. The result could be one of the most enduring examples of how the nervous system preserves its evolutionary history.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The hypothesis tackles a fundamental feature shared by all vertebrates, potentially explaining why the nervous system is wired the way it is.
- It challenges the assumption that every biological trait evolved for a direct survival advantage, suggesting some features may simply be inherited from ancient structures.
- Because the study proposes a specific ancient origin, it offers a concrete target for fossil evidence to support or refute the explanation.
Background
The crossed organization of the nervous system has been recognized for well over a century, but its origins have remained unclear. The optic chiasm and optic tectum are among the most ancient structures of the vertebrate nervous system, present in some form in every vertebrate. The new study builds on that observation to propose that later neural circuits inherited their crossed pattern from these early visual pathways.
What to Watch
- Whether fossil examinations of ancient jawless fish skulls reveal evidence of an optic chiasm and optic tectum.
- Whether additional sensory and motor pathways, beyond those examined in the study, can also be traced to the ancient visual arrangement.
- Whether other unusual biological features may likewise be explained by evolutionary inheritance rather than direct advantage.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe brain’s cross-wired design may trace back more than 500 million years to the visual systems of ancient fish.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Scientists may have uncovered why our brains are cross-wired, tracing the mysterious arrangement back more than 500 million years to the visual systems of ancient fish.”
- SupportedResearchers propose that ancient visual circuits shaped the nervous system’s contralateral organization.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Their hypothesis suggests that these connections may have developed because evolution built new brain circuits around an ancient visual system.”
- SupportedEach side of the brain controls or connects with the opposite side of the body in the cross-wired organization.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “cross-wired (meaning one side of the brain connects with the opposite side of the body)”
- SupportedThe hypothesis was published in Frontiers in Neuroanatomy.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “In a study published in Frontiers in Neuroanatomy, the researchers explore several neural circuits in four-limbed animals that are cross-wired”
- SupportedDr. Martin Wessendorf is a neuroscientist and associate professor emeritus at the University of Minnesota.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Dr. Martin Wessendorf, a neuroscientist and associate professor emeritus at the University of Minnesota, studies how the brainstem regulates neurons in the spinal cord.”
- SupportedDaniel Wang specializes in cognitive neuroscience and neurodegenerative diseases.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Daniel Wang specializes in cognitive neuroscience and neurodegenerative diseases.”
- SupportedAt the optic chiasm, nerve fibers are arranged so each side of the brain receives information from the opposite visual field.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Here, nerve fibers are organized so that information from the right visual field reaches the left side of the brain, while information from the left visual field is directed to the right side.”
- SupportedThe optic tectum is an ancient midbrain structure that helps produce fast reactions to visual events.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “Located in the midbrain, this region helps produce fast reactions to visual events, such as suddenly noticing something moving nearby.”
- SupportedThe dorsal column pathway carries gentle touch, vibration and body-position information, while the spinothalamic tract carries pain, itching and certain types of touch.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “The first, called the dorsal column pathway, carries information about gentle touch, vibration, and the position of different body parts. […] The second pathway, known as the spinothalamic tract, transmits sensations involving pain, itching, and certain types of touch.”
- SupportedThe researchers identified the tectospinal, rubrospinal and corticospinal pathways as connecting one side of the brain with the opposite side of the spinal cord.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “The researchers identified three important pathways involved in controlling skeletal muscles that also connect one side of the brain with the opposite side of the spinal cord.”
- SupportedThe researchers suggest humans may have developed fine motor abilities by adapting an older circuit originally involved in controlling sensory input.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “The researchers suggest that humans may have developed advanced fine motor abilities by adapting an older neural circuit originally involved in controlling sensory input.”
- SupportedThe researchers suspect the optic chiasm and optic tectum were present in primitive jawless fish during the Cambrian Period, approximately 538 to 486 million years ago.Latest Science News -- ScienceDaily: “the researchers suspect that these structures were already present in primitive jawless fish during the Cambrian Period, approximately 538 to 486 million years ago.”