Friday 16 October 2026
Morning Edition
ZOTPAPER

News without the noise

ZOTPAPER
Australia

Brethren Church leader recalled to election inquiry over neo-Nazi interference claims

Spiritual leader Bruce Hales warned he will be subpoenaed if he refuses to appear before parliamentary committee

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
The spiritual leader of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church is set to be hauled before a parliamentary inquiry today over allegations that church members paid known neo-Nazi associates to intimidate candidates during the 2025 federal election, with the committee warning he will be subpoenaed if he refuses to appear.

The Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters, chaired by Labor MP Jerome Laxale, has recalled senior figures from the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church (PBCC) after earlier testimony in August failed to address what the committee calls unanswered questions.

Recent media reports have alleged that PBCC members paid far-right influencers, including neo-Nazi associates, to track and heckle the prime minister, and that volunteers for the Liberal Party at pre-poll centres in key marginal seats intimidated rival volunteers and candidates.

"Recent media reports about PBCC members paying known agitators and Nazi-associates to disrupt our democracy are deeply disturbing," the committee said in a statement. "For the committee to accurately report on the 2025 election, they need to show up and fess up."

The church has denied any interaction with any political party or third-party group during the campaign and denied the existence of any formal arrangement with the Coalition. It is the second time church representatives have appeared before the committee.

Bruce Hales, the church's self-described "most senior elder", said in a statement: "I was not involved, nor did I have any participation directly or indirectly in the 2025 election. I did not participate in the campaign, nor did I ask anyone to do so."

The church accused the committee of "persecuting our Church and its members", calling the inquiry "a deeply disturbing moment for religious freedoms in Australia". It said the government wanted to "force" Mr Hales to answer for the actions of "individual church members", despite evidence it said demonstrated it "had no involvement in the election".

Committee member James McGrath said any recommendations from the inquiry would be "tainted" by "hyper-partisanship and unprofessional conduct", and described the inquiry as having "descended into a hyper-partisan witch-hunt".

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The allegations strike at the heart of democratic integrity, involving claims that a religious group coordinated with far-right extremists to influence a federal election.
  • The committee's decision to recall the church's most senior figure signals a significant escalation in the inquiry, potentially setting a precedent for religious organisations' involvement in political campaigning.
  • The outcome could affect public trust in electoral processes and the relationship between religious freedom and political accountability.

Background

The Plymouth Brethren Christian Church, often known as the Exclusive Brethren, has previously faced scrutiny over its political activities. In past elections, the church has been accused of directing members to support conservative candidates, a practice it has denied. The church operates as a closed, hierarchical community with strict internal governance, and its members are expected to follow the direction of its elders. The 2025 federal election saw tight contests in several marginal seats, and allegations of voter intimidation and improper third-party campaigning have led to this continued parliamentary investigation.

Key Perspectives

Committee (chaired by Labor MP Jerome Laxale): The committee views the new allegations as deeply disturbing and is determined to get answers from the church's leadership to ensure the integrity of the 2025 election report. They have warned Mr Hales that refusal to appear will result in a subpoena. Church leadership (Bruce Hales): Mr Hales denies any involvement or participation in the 2025 election, and the church denies any interaction with political parties or third-party groups. The church frames the recall as persecution and an attack on religious freedoms, rejecting the claim that it can be held responsible for individual members' actions. Coalition committee member James McGrath: Senator McGrath has lost confidence in the committee's process, describing the inquiry as a hyper-partisan witch-hunt. He argues that any recommendations will be tainted by partisan bias and unprofessional conduct.

What to Watch

  • Whether Bruce Hales appears voluntarily or requires a subpoena, and the substance of his testimony if he appears.
  • Any further media investigations that may surface new evidence of payments or coordination.
  • The committee's final report and whether it leads to recommendations for electoral law changes regarding third-party campaigning and religious organisations.
  • The reaction from the Liberal Party regarding its relationship with Brethren volunteers during the campaign.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe