Andy Burnham is expected to make resetting Britain’s relationship with Europe the pivotal theme of his white-tie speech at the lord mayor’s banquet in London tonight, ahead of a one-day UK-EU summit in Brussels on Friday where the two sides hope to sign deals on food and drink, emissions trading and a youth experience scheme.
The prospect of closer ties, and the possibility of the UK reversing Brexit, has generated jubilation and relief among supporters and vehement opposition from others, with a new campaign group, Stay Out, launched last week against rejoining the European Union. The pro-Brexit press has been on the offensive: recent headlines include the Express warning that Burnham’s plan would leave the average household £6,500 poorer, the Sunday Telegraph reporting that taxpayers are funding pro-EU university courses, and the Daily Mail quoting the ‘staggering cost’ of the prime minister’s EU reset. Even within Labour, MPs and unions have expressed unease. David Cameron, the prime minister who lost the 2016 referendum, has insisted the UK’s problems have nothing to do with leaving the EU.
The summit’s formal agenda does not include discussion of rejoining. Instead, the EU and UK hope to sign deals on food and drink, emissions trading and a youth experience scheme enabling work and study exchanges. The Guardian’s Brussels correspondent, Jennifer Rankin, reported that the first two deals are largely agreed. Two sticking points remain on the youth exchange: the Home Office wants to limit numbers to keep migration figures low, and there is disagreement over whether participants would pay UK domestic tuition fees or the international rate, four or five times higher for some courses. The UK has offered concessions on fees if it can join the EU’s Made in Europe legislation, designed to protect domestic manufacturing from Chinese competition, but the European Commission says it cannot make a deal on Made in Europe this week because the law is still at draft stage. The commission has proposed delaying an agreement on tuition fees for six months, a move that could allow time to bring the UK into Made in Europe, but member states are pushing to pin down the UK on fees this week.
“This is a real priority for the EU, in almost emotional terms,” Rankin said. “Lots of EU officials and diplomats studied in the UK, or their children did, and they felt this was one of the big losses of Brexit, that these person-to-person links were being eroded.”
In play at Friday’s summit will also be a future deal for the UK to rejoin the EU’s internal electricity market and a joint migration pact, with Britain seeking access to EU crime databases to tackle the small boats crisis. A similar row over UK contributions to EU funds scuppered last year’s negotiations on entry into a €150bn defence fund. It could also be a challenge for the UK to realign with the EU on farming, after changing to a payment model that puts more emphasis on delivering environmental benefits. Past UK governments have been lukewarm about EU AI regulation, devised post-Brexit. Some European diplomats have told Rankin that the technicalities of a full re-entry could be wrapped up within a year because the UK remains closely aligned with the bloc in many areas, but the EU and its member states are preoccupied with other priorities: the war in Ukraine, rising far-right support, street protests, hybrid threats from Russia, and a trade deficit with China that has reached €1bn a day.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen is by nature cautious, Rankin reported, so she does not expect a repeat of French President Emmanuel Macron’s ‘welcome back’ at Friday’s press conference. But behind closed doors, EU officials repeatedly say it is up to the UK to decide. There remains caution about the stability of British politics: now the Burnham government is exploring options, but a very different government could follow in a few years.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The Friday summit will produce the first concrete deals between the UK and EU since Brexit, testing whether the political will for closer ties can overcome technical and financial disagreements.
- A successful youth exchange scheme would restore the cross-border movement of young people that many EU officials describe as a major loss of Brexit.
- The UK’s potential return to EU electricity and defence markets would have direct implications for energy prices and security cooperation, affecting households and industry.
Background
The UK left the EU in January 2020 after the 2016 referendum. Andy Burnham, a Labour prime minister who campaigned to remain, has signalled openness to reversing Brexit. The EU has welcomed this shift but stresses that the decision rests with the UK. This week’s summit is the first high-level meeting since the Burnham government took office, and the mood music from both sides has been positive, though formal rejoining is not on the table.
Key Perspectives
Andy Burnham (UK Prime Minister): Expected to use his speech tonight to make the EU reset the central theme, and has predicted “some long nights” of negotiation this week.
Pro-Brexit press and Stay Out campaign: Oppose closer ties, warning of higher costs and increased migration. The Express, Sunday Telegraph and Daily Mail have led attacks on the reset plans.
David Cameron (former PM): Has insisted the UK’s problems are unrelated to leaving the EU.
European diplomats (via Guardian correspondent): Express genuine enthusiasm, saying technicalities of re-entry could be resolved within a year, and that it would be a vote of confidence in the European project.
European Commission (President von der Leyen): Cautious; not expected to offer a public “welcome back” but will likely signal openness at the press conference.
What to Watch
- Whether the youth experience scheme tuition-fee deadlock is resolved at Friday’s summit or kicked down the road for six months.
- The outcome of a potential row over UK contributions to EU cohesion funds if electricity market talks begin.
- The long-term political stability of the Burnham government: EU officials remain wary that a future government could reverse the reset.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 9 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedBurnham is expected to make resetting the UK’s relationship with Europe the pivotal theme of his banquet speech tonight, ahead of Friday’s summit.World news | The Guardian: “Andy Burnham is expected to make the reset of our relationship with Europe the pivotal theme of his white-tie speech at the lord mayor’s banquet in London tonight.”
- SupportedThe UK and EU hope to sign deals on food and drink, emissions trading and a youth experience scheme at Friday’s summit.World news | The Guardian: “the EU and UK hope to sign deals on food and drink, emissions trading and the youth experience scheme (a work and study exchange programme).”
- SupportedRejoining the EU is not on the summit’s formal agenda.World news | The Guardian: “the one-day summit in Brussels this Friday does not include any formal discussion of rejoining”
- SupportedThe mood around the summit is upbeat.World news | The Guardian: “Still, the mood music is upbeat.”
- SupportedThe food-and-drink and emissions-trading deals are largely agreed.World news | The Guardian: “the first two deals on food and drink and emissions trading were largely agreed.”
- SupportedThe youth exchange talks have sticking points over participant numbers and tuition fees.World news | The Guardian: “There are two sticking points with the youth exchange deal. First, the Home Office wants to limit numbers to the UK to keep migration figures low. Second, there’s disagreement over whether those students would pay UK domestic rates of tuition fees or the international rate”
- Partly supportedStay Out is a newly launched campaign group against rejoining the EU.World news | The Guardian: “Stay Out, a new campaign against rejoining the European Union, launched last week.”
- Partly supportedThe pro-Brexit press has been on the offensive.World news | The Guardian: “the pro-Brexit polity has been in broadcast mode: headlines from the past few days include:”
- SupportedDavid Cameron, the prime minister who lost the 2016 referendum, has insisted the UK’s problems have nothing to do with leaving the EU.World news | The Guardian: “David Cameron, the prime minister who lost the 2016 Brexit referendum – has insisted the UK’s problems have nothing to do with its exit from the EU.”
- Partly supportedThe European Commission says it cannot make a deal on Made in Europe this week because the law is still at draft stage.World news | The Guardian: “But the EU says it can’t make a deal on Made in Europe this week, because the law is still at a draft stage.”
- SupportedRankin said, “This is a real priority for the EU, in almost emotional terms.”World news | The Guardian: ““This is a real priority for the EU, in almost emotional terms,” Jennifer says.”
- SupportedRankin said EU officials and diplomats felt that eroding person-to-person links were one of Brexit’s big losses.World news | The Guardian: ““Lots of EU officials and diplomats studied in the UK, or their children did, and they felt this was one of the big losses of Brexit, that these person-to-person links were being eroded.””