Burns accuses new Greens leader Shoebridge of prejudice against Jewish Australians

Labor MP says senator divides Jews into 'good and bad' categories based on Gaza stance

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
Labor MP Josh Burns has accused newly elected Greens leader David Shoebridge of being prejudiced against Jewish Australians, saying the NSW senator divides Jews into 'good and bad' categories based on their position on Israel's war in Gaza.

The accusation came as Shoebridge's history of controversies was circulated by internal Greens critics and political opponents in Canberra, and as Prime Minister Anthony Albanese suggested Shoebridge's hardline approach would turn off Greens voters.

On Thursday, Shoebridge said the rare contested ballot of Greens MPs this week showed the party's hunger to respond to what he views as overlapping social, economic and environmental crises producing 'searing anger' among voters. 'I see that as a real sign of strength in the party and a sign of deep eagerness across the whole team to get in and make this fight real,' he told the ABC.

Shoebridge was asked on Wednesday about his relationship with the Jewish community. He said the party had 'really strong connections with much of the Australian Jewish community here, working alongside Jewish Australians who are fighting a genocide.' He added: 'And we will continue to champion their voices, to be solid allies with them.' He urged the media to 'listen to their cries for justice like we do.'

Burns, who represents parts of Melbourne's Jewish community, called the response 'pretty shocking.' 'Instead of saying something that was unifying and acknowledging that everyone deserves to feel safe and to be included in the Australian political landscape, Senator Shoebridge decided to give an answer that said that he has relationships with some [who] agree with him on his perspective of the Middle East,' Burns said.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The Greens' leadership change and its approach to the Israel-Gaza conflict could reshape federal politics in seats with significant Jewish or Muslim communities.
  • The accusation from a Labor MP representing Jewish constituents highlights how the war is straining cross-party and community relations in Australia.
  • Prime Minister Albanese's suggestion that Shoebridge's approach will turn off voters signals Labor sees an opportunity to peel away moderate Greens supporters.

Background

David Shoebridge, a New South Wales senator, was elected Greens leader in a contested ballot this week. His leadership campaign emphasised a hardline stance on the war in Gaza, which has become a defining issue for the party. The Greens have internal divisions over strategy, with some members concerned that the party's focus on the conflict risks alienating broader electorates. Shoebridge's history of controversies has been circulated by both internal critics and political opponents as the new leadership begins.

Key Perspectives

Josh Burns (Labor MP): Accuses Shoebridge of prejudice for only engaging with Jewish Australians who share his views on Gaza, rather than offering a unifying message that includes all Jewish Australians. David Shoebridge (Greens leader): Defends his party's connections with Australian Jews opposing what he calls a genocide, vowing to champion their voices and be solid allies. Anthony Albanese (Prime Minister): Suggests Shoebridge's hardline approach will turn off Greens voters, implying a strategic opening for Labor.

What to Watch

  • Response from major Jewish community organisations to Shoebridge's remarks and whether they engage with the new Greens leader.
  • Any further internal Greens dissent over Shoebridge's leadership style and policy focus.
  • Electoral polling in key inner-city seats where the Greens and Labor compete, testing Albanese's prediction.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.