A Dutch judge on Friday backed a request from Defender-maker Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) for an injunction against BYD barring sales of the Ti7 until the court decides whether JLR's intellectual property has been infringed.
JLR has brought intellectual property claims under EU design-right law in The Hague, as well as copyright and “slavish-imitation” claims in Rotterdam. The Hague District Court found that the differences between the two SUVs highlighted by Shenzhen-based BYD were insufficient to distinguish them from each other.
JLR labelled the Ti7 a "shameless copy" of the Defender in its court submissions. After the ruling, it said: "We protect our intellectual property and take legal action when necessary."
The Ti7, expected to launch in the UK and Australia next year, has been called a "Chinese Defender clone" by the BBC's Top Gear magazine and the "Land Rover Pretender" on social media. It will carry a UK price of £47,995, about £24,000 less than JLR's Defender, which starts at just under £72,000.
The injunction comes after JLR was ordered last week to destroy documents seized from BYD in raids on Dutch offices in August, which were part of a bid to establish whether the Chinese firm had taken apart a Defender to reverse-engineer its technology. BYD successfully argued the raids amounted to a "fishing expedition," with a judge finding the documents were not necessary for JLR's case.
BYD said it strongly disagreed with the Dutch judgment and intended to appeal. A spokesman said: "The BYD Ti7 is the result of BYD's own independent design work and infringes none of JLR's rights. We will pursue every legal avenue to demonstrate that this decision is incorrect."
JLR previously won a similar 2019 case against Jiangling Motor Corporation, arguing that the Landwind X7 was a Range Rover Evoque lookalike. The influx of lookalike vehicles has gathered pace over the past 18 months, with the Jaecoo 7, the "Temu Range Rover", leaping to the top of British sales charts earlier this year, racking up more than 10,000 purchases, and the Jaecoo 8 described by Autotrader as having "more than a hint of Range Rover Sport."
