Five years before police arrested him, the state of California had received complaints that Braff sat students on his lap, rubbed their legs and touched them near their vaginas. But the teacher credentialing agency failed to thoroughly investigate after the Santa Paula Unified School District reported him in 2019. It was not until his 2024 arrest that his credentials were suspended.
After Braff’s arrest, a parent emailed the district superintendent, asking, “Who dropped the ball and allowed this monster to still be around kids?” Superintendent Jeffrey Weinstein, who was not at the district when the allegations arose, replied that the district had done its part and that he “vehemently disagreed” with the agency's decision. “We sent all the evidence we had gathered,” he said. “The district did everything in its legal capacity it could.”
Along with Braff, the Commission on Teacher Credentialing delayed revoking the credentials of two other teachers who were later convicted of sexually abusing students: Brashawn Washington, a middle school math teacher, and an elementary teacher. The district shared screenshots of messages Washington had sent to an 11-year-old student, including a TikTok video showing another boy’s penis; at his trial, Washington told jurors that he did not send the video. He continued messaging students over Fortnite. He was sentenced to eight years and eight months in prison for multiple sex offenses.
In all three cases, state investigators did not interview some of the students who had alleged abuse, according to students, parents and attorneys. One former agency investigator who reviewed the district's report on Braff said cases involving allegations of inappropriate touching should always be assigned to investigators trained to interview victims. “Any claim of sexual misconduct should go to somebody who's going to be making phone calls,” the investigator said. “This man is grooming these children. There's no other way to look at it to me. Their stories are credible.”
The district's 2019 report to the state included a 20-page summary of a principal's interviews with at least seven accusers and two witnesses. One fifth grader said Braff locked the door, grabbed her by her hips and forced her to sit on his lap. Two other girls alleged he touched them near their “privates.” One of them, now an 18-year-old identified only as J., said Braff told her whatever happened in his office was a secret. J. and her mother said no one from the state agency had called to ask them about her allegations or verify details. “If a little girl comes up to you and says something, maybe you should not say that they’re a liar,” J. said. “They should interview students themselves and not just rely on the school district. Do a legit investigation,” her mother added.
Braff has pleaded not guilty. According to the district's report, he said he did not touch students near their private parts or have them sit on his lap. He said he only gave students side hugs, high-fives, fist bumps and taps on the knee. The report said he described “keeping an office environment where kids can move around; and he would not be closer than arm’s length.”
Anita Fitzhugh, a spokesperson for the commission, said the state automatically revokes credentials when teachers are convicted of sexual criminal offenses, but “unless the applicant or educator is convicted of a mandatory criminal offense, there are no written criteria that set the level of adverse action for educator discipline matters.” She said the commission’s role was to balance “protecting students as well as the legal rights of educators who have been accused but not convicted.” She said the discipline system dates to the 1970s and that “a deep and comprehensive review of the educator discipline system, prioritizing student safety in the schools, is in order.”
The decision on whether to recommend discipline falls to a volunteer panel called the Committee of Credentials, which needs only a “probable cause” standard. The panel declined to recommend discipline for Braff; the district had documented multiple, similar student accounts. One former committee member said they were alarmed to hear some fellow members dismiss children as unreliable sources. “I was consistently shocked,” the former member said. “To have committee members discuss serious allegations as, ‘Well, you know how girls can be. They say all kinds of things they don’t mean,’ is an unacceptable, antiquated point of view. What if we get this wrong? Who are we allowing in the classroom?”