District attorneys from 30 California counties filed a lawsuit Monday asking the state Supreme Court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom's blanket commutation of death sentences, arguing that he acted unlawfully by not affording victims of the crimes the chance to be heard.
The petition, filed at the California Supreme Court, asserts that Newsom violated state law when he proposed commuting the sentences of 548 prisoners without affording victims or their families the opportunity to be heard. 'Only this court can stop the governor's disregard of the law, his abuse of power,' the petitioners wrote.
Newsom, in an explanatory statement, argued that the statutory notification requirements do not apply because the commutations were not based on applications from death row prisoners but were initiated by him. He said that after submitting the proposed commutations to the court, his office would notify the district attorneys in the counties where the crimes occurred and seek their help with notifications.
The state Supreme Court is required to review nearly 400 of the commutations because those prisoners were convicted of multiple felonies. Representatives of the court have not said how or when those reviews would take place.
Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019 and later ordered the dismantling of the death chamber at San Quentin State Prison. His successor, Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, has committed to extending the moratorium when he takes office.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The case tests the limits of a governor's clemency power under California law.
- It directly affects victims' families, who say they were denied a legal voice in the process.
- The outcome could determine the fate of hundreds of death row inmates and shape future use of the death penalty in the state.
Background
Newsom issued a moratorium on executions in 2019 and later ordered the dismantling of the death chamber at San Quentin. Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra has pledged to continue the moratorium. The state Supreme Court must review almost 400 of the commutations because those prisoners had multiple felony convictions.
Key Perspectives
District attorneys of 30 counties: Argue Newsom's blanket action violated victims' statutory right to be heard and was an 'abuse of power.' They are asking the court to block the commutations.
Gov. Gavin Newsom: Contends the notification requirements do not apply because he acted on his own initiative, not in response to prisoner applications. He said his office would notify district attorneys after submitting the commutations.
What to Watch
- How the California Supreme Court will conduct the required reviews of the commutations involving multiple felonies.
- Whether the court will grant the prosecutors' request to halt the commutations and on what timeline.
- The incoming Becerra administration's approach to the death penalty, given his commitment to maintaining the moratorium.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedCalifornia prosecutors are asking the state Supreme Court to block Newsom’s death-penalty commutations.CalMatters: “California prosecutors and an advocacy group for crime victims are asking the state Supreme Court to block Gov. Newsom’s blanket commutation of death sentences.”
- SupportedThe lawsuit claims Newsom failed to give victims the opportunity to be heard.CalMatters: “The lawsuit, filed at the California Supreme Court, asserts that Newsom acted unlawfully when he proposed commuting the sentences of 548 prisoners by failing to afford the victims of their crimes the “opportunity to be heard.””
- SupportedDistrict attorneys from 30 California counties filed a lawsuit on Monday asking the state Supreme Court to block the commutations.CalMatters: “The district attorneys of 30 counties argued in a lawsuit filed Monday morning that the state’s high court should halt Gov. Gavin Newsom’s commutations of people on death row.”
- Partly supportedThe petition asserts that Newsom acted unlawfully by proposing to commute 548 prisoners’ sentences without giving victims or their families the opportunity to be heard.CalMatters: “The lawsuit, filed at the California Supreme Court, asserts that Newsom acted unlawfully when he proposed commuting the sentences of 548 prisoners by failing to afford the victims of their crimes the “opportunity to be heard.””
- SupportedThe petitioners wrote, “Only this court can stop the governor's disregard of the law, his abuse of power.”CalMatters: ““Only this court can stop the governor’s disregard of the law — his abuse of power,” the petitioners wrote to the California Supreme Court.”
- SupportedNewsom argued that statutory notification requirements did not apply because the proposed commutations were initiated by him, not requested by death-row prisoners.CalMatters: “A central factor was that none of these proposed commutations stemmed from an application from a prisoner on death row. By proposing a blanket commutation, Newsom asserted that none of the statutory requirements applied.”
- SupportedNewsom said his office would notify district attorneys after submitting the proposed commutations to the Supreme Court and seek their help with notifications.CalMatters: “He added that, after he submitted the proposed commutations to the Supreme Court, his office would notify the district attorneys in the counties in which the crimes were committed and seek their help with notifications.”
- SupportedThe state Supreme Court is required to review nearly 400 commutations because those prisoners were convicted of multiple felonies.CalMatters: “The California Supreme Court will get a say on almost 400 of Newsom’s commutations. State law requires the court to review those cases because the prisoners were convicted of multiple felonies.”
- SupportedCourt representatives have not said how or when the reviews would take place.CalMatters: “Representatives of the court have not said how or when those reviews would take place.”
- SupportedNewsom issued a moratorium on executions in 2019.CalMatters: “Newsom in 2019 issued a moratorium on executions”
- SupportedNewsom later ordered the death chamber at San Quentin State Prison dismantled.CalMatters: “and later ordered the dismantling of the death chamber at San Quentin State Prison.”
- SupportedNewsom’s successor, Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, has committed to extending the moratorium when he takes office.CalMatters: “His successor, Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, has committed to extending the moratorium when he takes office.”