California attorney general Rob Bonta has served an investigative subpoena on Nvidia, probing whether the AI chip designer or former CEO Jensen Huang's actions resulted in China obtaining advanced chips or confidential information; Bonta said such actions could violate state law if Nvidia is found to have misled investors and the public.
“Nvidia is in a messy, transnational situation but the underlying principle of our corporate securities law is clear: Companies cannot mislead their investors,” Bonta said.
Nvidia, which has its global headquarters in Santa Clara, California, is at the centre of a scandal that emerged earlier this month when it was reported that Huang had an extramarital relationship with Alice Huang, a suspected Chinese spy and executive at Singapore-based data centre company Megaspeed. Some US lawmakers have urged the Department of Commerce to investigate whether Megaspeed, a major Nvidia customer, diverted Nvidia chips to China. Megaspeed has said it is aware of reports “containing assertions about our business, supply chain and global operations that are not supported by verifiable evidence”.
Huang left Nvidia last week after reports that he had relationships with subordinates. The company's board chair Harvey Jones said Nvidia had no intention of reinstating him, after Huang issued a statement saying he would be “honoured” to return, as some tech leaders including Elon Musk campaigned on his behalf.
Nvidia shares have fallen 22% since the New York Times reported on the affair in early November.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The investigation could test whether US state securities law can reach conduct involving foreign espionage and export control violations that federal authorities are also examining.
- Nvidia is a cornerstone of the US and California economies; the outcome of the probe could affect investor confidence in one of the most valuable companies globally.
- The case may set a precedent for how states police corporate disclosures in national security-related matters.
Background
Nvidia designs advanced AI chips that are subject to US export restrictions aimed at preventing China from acquiring cutting-edge technology. Jensen Huang co-founded the company and led it for more than three decades before resigning this month amid revelations of extramarital affairs, including one with a woman suspected of ties to Chinese intelligence. California securities law requires companies to make truthful statements to investors.
Key Perspectives
Rob Bonta (California attorney general): Argues the law is clear that companies cannot mislead their investors, and the probe will examine if Nvidia or Huang's actions breached that principle.
Megaspeed (the Singapore-based customer at the centre of the allegations): Says reports contain assertions about its business, supply chain and global operations that are not supported by verifiable evidence.
Nvidia board chair Harvey Jones: Says Nvidia has no intention of reinstating Jensen Huang, despite Huang's stated wish to return.
What to Watch
- Whether the US Department of Commerce opens a formal investigation into chip diversion allegations against Megaspeed.
- Nvidia's next quarterly earnings report, which will show the extent of share price decline and any change in China-linked revenue.
- Any further federal actions, including possible congressional hearings or export enforcement measures.