The peak body for Australian visual artists has called on councils to regulate the use of generative AI in public installations, after a new AI-generated mural at Brisbane's Bulimba Library drew sharp criticism for errors including a three-winged cockatoo and a city skyline with landmarks on the wrong side of the river.
Brisbane City Council confirmed the mural in the library's children's section had been produced using AI, but said it would be replaced once a local artist could be commissioned.
Artist Sophie Beer labelled the work "AI slop". Penelope Benton, executive director of the National Association for the Visual Arts (NAVA), said on Wednesday that human artists must be at the forefront of public art. "If a council can't afford to pay an artist, don't install a mural," she told this masthead. Benton called for local governments to incorporate a NAVA framework still being drafted into their art-commissioning policies.
Simon Degroot, program director at Griffith University's Queensland College of Art and Design, described the mural as "bland" and said it was particularly problematic in a children's reading space meant to encourage creativity. "It's not a space where you want to be reminded all the time that AI is an increasingly ever-present part of our daily life," he said.
At a council meeting on 3 November, opposition leader Jared Cassidy criticised the sanctioning of AI use in council's Brisbane Portrait Prize. Councillor Sarah Hutton noted the library's history, including a mural by artist Ryan Barwick in the courtyard.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The controversy highlights growing tensions between cost-saving use of AI and support for human artists in public spaces.
- Council's response sets a precedent for how local governments in Australia handle AI-generated public art.
- NAVA's call for regulation could shape future commissioning policies across the country.
Background
The Bulimba Library stands on the site of the former Bulimba School of Arts, built in 1887 and demolished in 1982. The council has a history of commissioning public art, including a mural by artist Ryan Barwick in the library courtyard. The use of AI in the children's section has revived debate about the role of generative AI in cultural institutions.
What to Watch
- NAVA's forthcoming draft framework on AI in public art, which it wants local councils to adopt.
- Whether Brisbane City Council changes its commissioning policies for future installations.
- Any further backlash or legal disputes over AI use in public art, building on an earlier dispute over a mural at a yoghurt store in Brisbane.