Justice Thomas certified the case after finding sufficient grounds to examine whether Google's payments to Apple discouraged Apple from developing its own search engine. The plaintiff was Spark Event Rentals Ltd., a British Columbia event rental company; Apple and Google first agreed in 2005 to make Google the default search engine on Safari in exchange for a share of advertising revenue.
Apple had argued that its agreement with Google was a legitimate distribution arrangement, not an unlawful conspiracy, and said it was an "innocent bystander" with Google the appropriate defendant. The plaintiff originally named both companies but later dropped Google following a dispute over an arbitration clause.
Justice Thomas, citing testimony from Apple executives Eddy Cue and John Giannandrea during the US Department of Justice's antitrust case against Google, wrote that "this provides some basis in fact, supporting the inference that Apple did not compete with Google in the search engine market because of its Agreement with Google." He acknowledged Apple's objections that the plaintiff had "cherry-picked evidence," but said "it is appropriate to do so at this stage in the proceedings."
The judge also allowed the question of punitive damages to proceed. No trial date has been announced.
