CCTV has revealed the final moments of food delivery rider Jianming Feng before he was fatally stabbed in Melbourne, as some Chinese social media users questioned the city's safety. The 47-year-old father of two was captured smiling and chatting with restaurant staff on Friday, minutes before returning to the eatery mortally wounded.
The restaurant owner, who asked not to be identified, told 7NEWS that Feng and another rider stepped outside after a man allegedly kicked over their bikes. 'The CCTV shows they were outside for just two minutes before coming back in,' the owner said.
Feng walked to a corner of the restaurant and sat on the floor. 'He must have begun feeling unwell,' the owner said. 'He literally found a corner in the restaurant and walked there himself, without anyone's help.' Police arrived at about 8.12pm, five minutes after the riders returned. Despite CPR, Feng could not be saved.
The other rider, a 34-year-old, was allegedly stabbed while confronting Urbano. An employee who struggled to enter the storeroom said, 'Every time we walk past that corner, we'll think of him being there.' The owner found small drops of blood marking Feng's movements from the entrance to the counter and then the corner where he collapsed. They planned to clean it themselves to spare staff who had witnessed the incident, but later enlisted another employee's help.
Feng moved to Australia about nine years ago to support his wife, two children and elderly parents in China's Shaanxi Province. His wife said he had hoped to return to China in another year or two, possibly after their son married.
Accused Roberto Urbano, 51, appeared in Melbourne Magistrates Court via video link on Monday, where he pulled down his pants and exposed himself before the link was cut. His lawyer told the court he experiences schizophrenia and requested a custody nurse assessment. He is due to return to court on 26 April 2027.
'The world's most liveable city could not protect a delivery rider,' read one WeChat post. State media reported that Consul General Fang Xinwen asked the Premier and Victoria Police to handle the case fairly and safeguard the rights of Chinese nationals.
Garrick Yang, who travels between Shanghai and Melbourne, said the attack was 'a tragedy' but unsurprising. 'When you look at everyday life in Melbourne and see these incidents, you realise how far reality is from [its liveability] reputation,' Mr Yang said. Sam Huang, a tourism research professor at Edith Cowan University, said the case could damage Melbourne's appeal to students and migrants over the next one to two years. 'Safety is one of the most basic requirements of a liveable city,' he said.
Blake Li, who lives in China's Sichuan province, questioned the 'Little Gotham' label, arguing that robberies, killings and arson can happen in any city. Sharon Kwok, a criminology lecturer at Western Sydney University, said 'signal crimes' could have a disproportionate impact on perceptions of safety, especially when the victim shares the observer's ethnic background.
Victoria's Crime Statistics Agency figures show the state's crime rate dropped 3.8 per cent in the 12 months to June 2026, but the City of Melbourne's latest annual report found only 34 per cent of women and 49 per cent of men surveyed felt safe at night.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The case is testing Melbourne's reputation as a safe, liveable city among Chinese migrants, students and investors, a key demographic for the city.
- It highlights the vulnerability of gig-economy workers, who often work late at night with little protection.
- The way the Chinese diaspora processes the crime through social media can create an 'echo chamber' that amplifies safety fears.
Background
Jianming Feng, 47, was a father of two who moved from China's Shaanxi Province to Australia nine years ago, working as a delivery rider for HungryPanda to support his family. On the evening of Friday 6 November, he was fatally stabbed on Frederick Way in Melbourne's CBD during a confrontation over a kicked-over bike. Roberto Urbano, 51, has been charged with murder and intentionally causing serious injury.
Key Perspectives
Garrick Yang (Melbourne property investor): Believes the liveability rankings are 'a joke' and questions the city's safety after a series of stabbings.
Sam Huang (Edith Cowan University tourism researcher): Warns the incident could deter prospective students, tourists and migrants for one to two years.
Blake Li (Sichuan resident): Cautions against the 'Little Gotham' label, noting crime occurs internationally.
Sharon Kwok (Western Sydney University criminologist): Explains that highly publicised 'signal crimes' can disproportionately affect the safety perceptions of specific ethnic groups.
What to Watch
- Court: Urbano's next hearing is set for 26 April 2027, with a psychiatric assessment expected to be a key factor.
- International perception: Watch for shifts in Chinese international student applications and tourism bookings in the coming months.
- Policy: Whether Victoria Police or the city council introduces measures to improve night-time safety in the CBD.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 2 sources: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedCCTV revealed the food delivery rider’s final moments before the fatal Melbourne stabbing.7NEWS: “CCTV reveals final moments of food delivery rider Jianming Feng before fatal Melbourne stabbing.”
- SupportedThe accused exposed himself in court.7NEWS: “He appeared in Melbourne Magistrates Court via video link on Monday, where he pulled down his pants and exposed himself before the link was cut.”
- SupportedSome Chinese social media users questioned Melbourne’s liveability.Just In: “Some dubbed Melbourne as "Little Gotham" — a reference to the fictional, crime-ridden city in Batman comics — while others questioned Melbourne's status as one of the world's most liveable city.”
- SupportedFeng was 47 and a father of two.7NEWS: “Less than three minutes after stepping outside to check on his bike, the 47-year-old father-of-two returned mortally wounded.”
- SupportedCCTV showed Feng smiling and chatting with restaurant staff minutes before he returned mortally wounded.7NEWS: “Food delivery rider Jianming Feng was smiling and chatting with restaurant staff moments before he was fatally stabbed in Melbourne”
- SupportedThe owner said the riders were outside for two minutes before coming back in.7NEWS: ““The CCTV shows they were outside for just two minutes before coming back in,” the owner said.”
- SupportedPolice arrived at about 8.12pm, five minutes after the riders returned.7NEWS: “According to the owner’s review of the CCTV, police arrived at about 8.12pm, five minutes after the riders returned.”
- SupportedThe 34-year-old rider was allegedly stabbed while confronting Urbano.7NEWS: “Feng and the 34-year-year-old man were allegedly stabbed while confronting Roberto Urbano.”
- SupportedUrbano is due back in court on 26 April 2027.7NEWS: “Urbano is due to return to court on April 26, 2027.”
- SupportedA WeChat post said, “The world's most liveable city could not protect a delivery rider.”Just In: “"The world's most liveable city could not protect a delivery rider," read one video post on WeChat.”
- SupportedState media reported that Consul General Fang Xinwen asked the Premier and Victoria Police to handle the case fairly and safeguard Chinese nationals’ rights.Just In: “[Consul General Fang Xinwen] asked the Premier, Victorian Government and Victoria Police to handle this case fairly in accordance with the law, severely punish the perpetrator, and earnestly safeguard the life and legitimate rights and interests of the Chinese nationals in Victoria”
- SupportedThe City of Melbourne’s annual report found that 34 per cent of women and 49 per cent of men surveyed felt safe at night.Just In: “the City of Melbourne's 2025–26 annual report found only 34 per cent of women and 49 per cent of men surveyed felt safe at night”