On a summer afternoon at Pheasant Wood Military Cemetery in northern France, a headstone bearing Eric Bogle's 1976 ballad 'No Man's Land' marks the grave of Lance-Corporal William Andrew Craigie, killed at the Battle of Fromelles in 1916, a symbol of how the conflict's commemoration has shifted over a century.
Pheasant Wood is the newest Commonwealth War Graves Commission (CWGC) cemetery, opened in 2010, the first for five decades. The German Army buried 250 Commonwealth soldiers killed on its side of No Man’s Land in pits after the Battle of Fromelles on July 19-20, 1916, a diversionary assault that historian Ross McMullin has called 'the worst 24 hours in Australian history.' About 2000 Australians were killed, of whom more than 1330 could not be found. A total of 181 men have been identified by DNA, and all are buried at Pheasant Wood.
The headstone inscription for Craigie reads: 'The sun's shining down/On green fields of France Warm wind blows gently/The red poppies dance.' The use of Bogle's lyrics, written 60 years after Craigie's death, contrasts with the CWGC's long-standing policy that inscriptions reflect language from the time of death. A Department of Veterans' Affairs spokesperson says that when an inscription for a newly identified Australian soldier is 'unusual or contentious in some way,' the wording must be submitted for approval to the CWGC's Policy and Commemorations Group in the UK.
Responsibility for the inscription rests with the next of kin, the oldest surviving traceable family member, not necessarily the DNA donor. Ray Martin, nephew of recently identified Private Roy Leslie Martin, said the CWGC rejected his suggestions, including one referring to the 110 years since his uncle's death. The stone now reads: 'He that was lost is found', a suggestion initially offered by the CWGC.
Other stones carry poetry by Wilfred Owen, whose works were little known to the public until the 1960s. Lance Corporal Ralph Johnson's grave bears 'Dulce et Decorum est/Pro patria mori', a phrase from Horace that appears in Owen's poem, which denounces the maxim as 'an old lie.' Private Samuel Farlow's stone says: 'Red lips are not so red/As stained stones kissed/By the English dead' from Owen's 1918 poem 'Greater Love.'
Stuart Barr, a Canberra-based public servant, said a grave had been attributed to his great-uncle Percy Barr, though there was some doubt about the identification. Percy's remains were not correctly recognised until 2024. The original inscription, 'He fought, he died/Not for his own/But for England's unsullied name', was retained on the new stone after the CWGC recommended leaving it unchanged.
Geoffrey Benn, president of the Fromelles Association of Australia, described the hunt for next of kin: 'Sometimes it comes down to a family tree being put up on Ancestry as a public listing.' Some contacted relatives decline cooperation. 'We were trying to track down a vicar in the UK,' Benn said. 'The poor vicar's wife said, "We will not be involving ourselves in this. You can just f--- off!"'
In the immediate post-war years, families were charged 3½ pence per letter and word space for inscriptions, a charge the president of the Melbourne branch of the Returned Sailors and Soldiers Imperial League called 'the most paltry and contemptible thing I have heard of.' The Australian government eventually covered unpaid costs, but the decision was not made public, and many of the poorest families' children passed without even an epitaph.
Now, 110 years on, the men of Fromelles are reburied with full military honours in a bilingual ceremony. Lambis Englezos, the retired art teacher whose efforts and energy largely led to the discovery of the burial site, said: 'I'm not the hard bastard I look.' He noted the symbolism of his own son Anthony's service in Afghanistan while he stood among 410 unidentified Australians at V.C. Corner Cemetery.
Ray Martin's granddaughter Ariana unveiled Private Roy Leslie Martin's headstone at a ceremony attended by an Australian Army lieutenant colonel, the Mayor of Fromelles, and a coachload of battlefield tourists. The inscription echoes a theme repeated across the cemetery.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The use of Wilfred Owen's and Eric Bogle's poetry on headstones reflects a shift in how societies commemorate war, moving from state-controlled narratives to more personal and sometimes critical expressions of loss.
- The DNA-identification program at Pheasant Wood continues to resolve a century-old grief for families, with new names announced each year on the battle's anniversary.
- The story highlights ongoing tensions between CWGC regulations designed to maintain historical integrity and families' desires to honour their ancestors in contemporary language.
Background
Pheasant Wood Military Cemetery in Fromelles, northern France, was opened in 2010 after Lambis Englezos and others used German records to locate mass graves behind former German lines. The site contains 250 Commonwealth soldiers killed in the Battle of Fromelles (July 19-20, 1916), a diversionary attack that failed. The CWGC, established after World War I, maintains about 1200 cemeteries in France and enforces strict rules on headstone inscriptions. As of 2026, 181 of the 250 men have been identified through DNA donated by living relatives.
Key Perspectives
- Lambis Englezos, battlefield tour guide: Said the search for the graves was driven by logic: 'They had to be buried somewhere.' He believes Australia has a national duty to recover and honour war dead.
- Geoffrey Benn, president of the Fromelles Association of Australia: Described tracking next of kin as 'like putting together the pieces of a jigsaw when you don't have any pieces, don't have the lid, and don't even know where to find the box.'
- Stuart Barr, great-nephew of Percy Barr: Received a 'cold call out of the blue' from the Fromelles Association and later provided DNA that confirmed his great-uncle's identity.
- A spokesperson for the Department of Veterans' Affairs: Said inscriptions must reflect language from the time of death to 'maintain historical integrity,' and that unusual wording is submitted to the CWGC's Policy and Commemorations Group.
What to Watch
- Whether additional CWGC rules are revised to accommodate more contemporary inscriptions as DNA identification continues.
- How many more soldiers at Pheasant Wood will be identified and named in future ceremonies.
- Whether the process of contacting next of kin becomes easier as genealogical records become more accessible online.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says song lyrics and poetry mark graves at Fromelles a century after the battle.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Their headstones pulse with the poetry of Wilfred Owen and Eric Bogle – whose graveside meditation is now a part of a graveside itself.”
- SupportedCWGC rules govern inscriptions on headstones.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “strict regulations have governed the wording on CWGC monuments since the end of the First World War”
- SupportedDNA has identified 181 men, all buried at Pheasant Wood.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “A total of 181 men have been identified by DNA, and all are buried at Pheasant Wood.”
- SupportedCraigie's headstone bears the quoted lines from Eric Bogle's song.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “whose inscription reads simply: The sun’s shining down/On green fields of France Warm wind blows gently/The red poppies dance.”
- SupportedPheasant Wood is the newest CWGC cemetery, opened in 2010 and the first in five decades.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “It’s the newest CWGC cemetery, the first for five decades.”
- SupportedThe German Army buried 250 Commonwealth soldiers killed on its side of No Man’s Land in pits.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “they finally discovered the pits used by the German Army to bury 250 Commonwealth soldiers who had been killed on the German side of No Man’s Land.”
- SupportedAbout 2,000 Australians were killed at Fromelles, and more than 1,330 could not be found.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “About 2000 Australians were killed, of whom more than 1330 could not be found.”
- Partly supportedCWGC policy requires inscriptions to reflect language from the time of death.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “inscriptions are expected to reflect language that could reasonably have been used at the time of the casualty’s death.”
- SupportedA DVA spokesperson said unusual or contentious inscriptions for newly identified Australian soldiers must be submitted to the CWGC’s Policy and Commemorations Group for approval.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “when an inscription proposed for the tombstone of a freshly identified Australian soldier is considered “unusual or contentious in some way”, the wording has to be submitted for approval to the CWGC’s Policy and Commemorations Group in the UK, says a spokesperson for the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (DVA).”
- SupportedRay Martin said the CWGC rejected his inscription suggestions, including one referring to the 110 years since his uncle’s death.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““I mentioned the 110 years [since Roy died] and you weren’t allowed to do that,” he says. “And then they agreed on this one.””
- SupportedBenn said that tracking down relatives can come down to finding a public family tree on Ancestry.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““Sometimes it comes down to a family tree being put up on Ancestry as a public listing,” says Benn.”
- SupportedThe men were reburied with full military honours at a bilingual ceremony 110 years after the battle.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Yet 110 years later, those same men are reburied with full military honours at a bilingual ceremony”