Coinbase urges Bitcoin to begin quantum-proof preparations now

The cryptocurrency exchange proposes flexible addresses and backup quantum-resistant keys, and calls for a separate debate on lost coins

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Coinbase, the US-based cryptocurrency exchange, has called for Bitcoin to begin preparing for the threat posed by quantum computers, proposing the introduction of flexible addresses and backup quantum-proof keys, as well as a distinct discussion about how to handle coins that have been lost or rendered inaccessible.

In a proposal published on October 14, Coinbase outlined what it sees as necessary steps for the Bitcoin network to remain secure as quantum computing advances. The exchange, which according to the article holds an estimated 5% of all Bitcoin in circulation, is advocating for changes to the network's address system to allow for flexible addresses that can be updated, and for a separate backup key that would be resistant to quantum attacks.

Coinbase also suggests that the community should begin a separate debate about lost coins, a category that includes Bitcoin sitting in wallets whose private keys have been lost or destroyed. The proposal does not specify how such coins should be handled, but raises the issue as part of a broader conversation about quantum readiness.

The article notes that the timeline for when quantum computers could pose a practical threat to Bitcoin's cryptographic foundations remains uncertain, but Coinbase argues that preparation should begin now rather than later. The exchange's large holdings give it significant weight in any discussion about changes to the Bitcoin protocol.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Quantum computers, if sufficiently advanced, could break the elliptic curve cryptography that secures Bitcoin addresses, potentially enabling theft of funds.
  • Coinbase holds a substantial amount of Bitcoin, giving its proposal influence over the network's technical direction.
  • The call for a debate on lost coins introduces a contentious issue: whether those coins should be rendered unusable or somehow recovered, which could affect Bitcoin's supply assumptions.

Background

Bitcoin's security relies on cryptographic algorithms that are considered safe against classical computers but vulnerable to code-breaking algorithms that quantum computers could run in theory. While practical quantum computers capable of breaking Bitcoin's encryption are not yet available, the community has debated for years how and when to upgrade the network. Any change to Bitcoin's core cryptography would require broad consensus among developers, miners, and users, and could involve a network upgrade or even a hard fork.

Key Perspectives

Coinbase: The exchange argues that proactive preparation is essential to avoid a future crisis, and that the Bitcoin network should adopt flexible addresses and quantum-proof backup keys as a precaution. Bitcoin Developers and Community: There is likely to be debate over the technical merits and feasibility of Coinbase's proposals, as well as over the lost coins issue, which touches on the immutability of the blockchain. Critics and Skeptics: Some may argue that the quantum threat is still decades away and that rushing changes could introduce new vulnerabilities or disrupt the network unnecessarily.

What to Watch

  • Any formal Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) that emerge from Coinbase's suggestions.
  • Developments in quantum computing, particularly announcements of progress toward breaking 256-bit elliptic curve cryptography.
  • Community discussions and potential signaling from major mining pools and other exchanges regarding support for quantum-resistant upgrades.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe