Column 8: Readers share memories of Edward Loong, Paul Hogan and moth songs

Light-hearted reader contributions span school days, hair treatments and rugby league puns

By LineZotpaper
Published
Updated
Read Time2 min
Sources4 outlets
Sydney Morning Herald's Column 8 has brought together readers with shared memories of a former National Service member, a comedian's school days, and an entomological singalong, in a collection of anecdotes published on Tuesday.

A series of reader contributions to the Sydney Morning Herald's Column 8 have linked strangers through common experiences, ranging from National Service to primary school classmates.

Graham Lum of North Rocks recalled doing National Service with an Edmund Loong from Parramatta in 1959, whom he assumes is the Edward Loong of Herald fame. Maureen Lysaght of Terrey Hills wrote asking whether the same Edward Loong is the younger brother of Nancy Loong, who attended Parramatta Public Primary School with her in the early 1950s.

Further connections emerged from Ian Rewell of Longueville, who noted that four contributors to Column 8 were all in the same year at the University of Sydney Faculty of Medicine, final year 1977: Tim Ingall, James Wall, Malcolm Robilliard and himself.

In lighter fare, Jo Rainbow of Orange lamented misunderstanding an advertisement for "Brazilian blowout nanoplasty", which she had initially thought was about a bikini wax. Richard Hale of Paddington suggested that a reader's "Mothpocalypse Now" party should be followed by "MothBusters".

George Manojlovic of Mangerton contributed a poetic moth song referencing place names such as Gulgong, Wollongong and Dandenong. Paul Taylor of Winston Hills responded to a previous item about a rugby league player's alleged assault on a calf with a series of puns on udders and steak, concluding that "repeat offenders being banned for heifer and heifer" would be appropriate.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Column 8 continues to serve as a social connector, matching readers across decades through shared memories.
  • The submissions highlight the enduring appeal of local trivia and personal anecdotes in an age of algorithm-driven news.
  • Such columns foster a sense of community among readers who might otherwise never interact.

Background

Column 8 is a long-running feature of the Sydney Morning Herald where readers submit observations, questions and reminiscences on a wide range of topics. It often prompts further correspondence as readers identify with or respond to previous items. The column has been a staple of the paper's letters page for decades, covering everything from local history to wordplay and puns.

Key Perspectives

Readers: They enjoy sharing memories and making connections, as evidenced by the multiple references to the same person (Edward Loong) and the medical school cohort. Column editors: The editors curate submissions that are likely to generate further reader engagement, favouring humour, nostalgia and wordplay. Skeptics: Some may view such columns as trivial filler, but the sustained reader participation suggests it fulfils a niche appetite for light, human-interest content that is increasingly rare in digital news.

What to Watch

  • Whether further connections emerge from the Edward Loong references, potentially tracing a broader network of former schoolmates or National Service colleagues.
  • The response to Paul Taylor's rugby league puns, which may prompt additional wordplay from other readers.
  • The longevity of Column 8 as newspapers continue to shift towards digital formats and shorter content.

Sources

Checked

11 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 8 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedTaylor concluded that repeat offenders should be banned “for heifer and heifer.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: “I would have no beef with repeat offenders being banned for heifer and heifer.”
  2. SupportedThe headline says Column 8 readers shared memories of Edward Loong and Paul Hogan.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “I did my National Service with an Edmund Loong (C8) from Parramatta back in 1959. I assume he is the Edward Loong of Herald fame. Incidentally, Paul Hogan was in my class at the Harris Park Convent school.”
  3. Partly supportedThe story describes Paul Hogan as a comedian whose school days readers recalled.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Paul Hogan was in my class at the Harris Park Convent school. He was well-behaved at age seven.”
  4. Not in the sourcesThe collection was published on Tuesday.
  5. SupportedGraham Lum recalled doing National Service with Edmund Loong in 1959 and said he assumed Edmund was Edward Loong of Herald fame.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “I did my National Service with an Edmund Loong (C8) from Parramatta back in 1959. I assume he is the Edward Loong of Herald fame.”
  6. SupportedMaureen Lysaght asked whether Edward Loong was Nancy Loong’s younger brother, and said Nancy attended Parramatta Public Primary School with her in the early 1950s.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Is the prolific Edward Loong of Column 8 fame the younger brother of the lovely Nancy Loong who attended Parramatta Public Primary School with me in the early 1950s?”
  7. SupportedIan Rewell said four Column 8 contributors were in the Sydney Uni Faculty of Medicine, final year 1977.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “there are four of us who have been published in Column 8 (thank you!) who were all in the same year at university, the Sydney Uni Faculty of Medicine, final year 1977: Tim Ingall of Scottsdale Arizona, James Wall of Sutton Forest, Malcolm Robilliard of Darling Point and myself.”
  8. SupportedJo Rainbow said she initially mistook “Brazilian blowout nanoplasty” for something to do with bikini-line preparation.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Apparently, ‘Brazilian blowout nanoplasty’ is nothing to do with getting my bikini line in readiness for summer.”
  9. SupportedRichard Hale suggested ending the Mothpocalypse Now party with MothBusters.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Richard Hale of Paddington thinks “Janice Creenaune’s daughter should end her Mothpocalypse Now party (C8) with the show MothBusters”
  10. SupportedGeorge Manojlovic contributed a moth song that names Gulgong, Wollongong and Dandenong.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “‘I’ve been to Gulgong Cooranbong Ettalong Kurrajong Wollongong Bong Bong Binalong and Grong Grong Bedgerebong Matong Yarramalong and Dandenong so bogongs everywhere flap your wings and sing along!’”
  11. Partly supportedPaul Taylor responded to a previous item about a rugby league player's alleged assault on a calf.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “My first response in reading George Zivkovic’s revelation of Mitchell Moses’ cowardly assault upon a calf (C8) was udder disbelief.”

Zotpaper

Written by June Katz on the Australia & local desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source8 of 11 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe