Column links Lambie's prolapse disclosure, Hanson cartoon and Haines attack to history of women's silence

Historian Julia Baird draws connections from Queen Victoria's undisclosed condition to modern stigma and gendered violence in politics

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources3 outlets
In a column published Friday, historian and journalist Julia Baird argues that Senator Jacqui Lambie's public disclosure of her pelvic prolapse, the subsequent mocking cartoon from Pauline Hanson, and the recent attack on independent MP Helen Haines are all part of a long pattern in which women in public life are expected to endure pain and hostility in silence. Baird links these modern events to Queen Victoria's undisclosed prolapsed uterus, which she says contributed to her later mobility and temperament.

Senator Jacqui Lambie recently spoke in parliament about her vaginal and bladder prolapse, which required surgery and five months off work. She argued that the Department of Veterans' Affairs does not adequately compensate for such conditions linked to military service. "You want us to have babies for the country," Lambie said, "but you're not interested in supporting our reproductive systems ... Australian women's vaginas are not made of Australian steel."

A cartoon on Pauline Hanson's "Please Explain" program later mocked Lambie's condition, depicting an animated Lambie clutching her crotch and saying she could not laugh because of her prolapse. Hanson initially dismissed criticism, telling Lambie to "get over it." After a backlash, Hanson apologised, saying the cartoon went up without her seeing it. "I respect people's views and opinions out there," she said, "and it wasn't as tastefully done as it could've been and I do apologise for that."

Baird, who has written a biography of Queen Victoria, notes that the queen's prolapsed uterus was discovered only on her deathbed. She argues it likely contributed to her reliance on a rolling chair and her use of a hand-operated lift at Osborne House. "No wonder she decried childbirth, how it made her feel like 'a cow or a dog'," Baird writes.

Connecting the Haines attack to a broader pattern, Baird cites NSW Greens MP Amanda Cohn, who said, "Rape and death threats shouldn't be dismissed as a normal part of my job." Baird concludes that violence against female MPs is more frequent and brutal than against male colleagues, and that answers lie in a long history of insisting women quietly endure.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The incident highlights the stigma surrounding common women's health conditions such as pelvic organ prolapse, which remains under-discussed despite affecting millions.
  • It raises questions about the boundaries of political satire and the acceptability of mocking members' medical conditions.
  • The connection to the Haines attack underscores the heightened level of gendered threats and violence facing female parliamentarians.

Background

Senator Jacqui Lambie is an independent Tasmanian senator who often speaks on veterans' issues. She disclosed her prolapse while arguing for better compensation from the Department of Veterans' Affairs. Pauline Hanson is the leader of One Nation and hosts the online show "Please Explain." Independent MP Helen Haines was attacked this week, though details of the attack are not given in the column. Baird is a historian and journalist who has written a biography of Queen Victoria.

Key Perspectives

Senator Jacqui Lambie: Spoke openly about her prolapse to advocate for veterans' reproductive health coverage, highlighting the physical toll of military service on women's bodies. Senator Pauline Hanson: Initially defended the cartoon as satire, then apologised after public backlash, saying it was posted without her knowledge. Historian Julia Baird: Argues that women's health issues like prolapse are under-examined and stigmatised, and that female politicians face more frequent and brutal violence than male counterparts, drawing a historical line from Queen Victoria to modern attacks.

What to Watch

  • Whether the attack on Helen Haines prompts new parliamentary security measures.
  • Continued public and media discussion on pelvic health stigma.
  • Potential further political fallout from the cartoon incident and any further response from Lambie on the apology.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 8 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedBaird links Lambie’s disclosure, Hanson’s cartoon and the Haines attack to a long history of women being expected to endure in silence.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “We like to blame modern times and modern platforms, but answers, too, can be found in our long history of insisting that women quietly endure.”
  2. SupportedBaird says Victoria’s prolapse contributed to her later mobility and temperament.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “A prolapse may not have been the sole cause of this behaviour – she also had a ventral hernia and rheumatism – but was surely a crucial contributing factor. I felt for her – no wonder she got so grumpy sometimes.”
  3. SupportedLambie’s prolapse required surgery and five months off work.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “spoke about the vaginal and bladder prolapse that had caused her to have surgery and take five months off work.”
  4. SupportedLambie said, “You want us to have babies for the country,” and that Australian women’s vaginas “are not made of Australian steel.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““You want us to have babies for the country,” she said, “but you’re not interested in supporting our reproductive systems … Australian women’s vaginas are not made of Australian steel.””
  5. Not in the sourcesThe cartoon appeared on Pauline Hanson’s “Please Explain” program.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “for the “Please Explain” cartoon that mocked Lambie’s condition.”
  6. SupportedHanson told Lambie to “get over it.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: “At first, Hanson said it was satirical and Lambie should “get over it”.”
  7. SupportedHanson apologised, saying, “I respect people’s views and opinions out there,” and “it wasn’t as tastefully done as it could’ve been and I do apologise for that.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““I respect people’s views and opinions out there,” she said “and it wasn’t as tastefully done as it could’ve been and I do apologise for that.””
  8. SupportedVictoria’s prolapsed uterus was discovered on her deathbed.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “it was not until she was examined on her deathbed that her doctor, Sir James Reid, found she had a prolapsed uterus”
  9. SupportedBaird writes that childbirth made Victoria feel like “a cow or a dog.”Brisbane Times - Latest News: “And no wonder she decried childbirth, how it made her feel like “a cow or a dog”.”
  10. Not in the sourcesHelen Haines is an independent MP.
  11. Reports differBaird attributes the quote “Rape and death threats shouldn’t be dismissed as a normal part of my job” to NSW Greens MP Amanda Cohn.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “As NSW Greens MP Amanda Cohen said in these pages , “Rape and death threats shouldn’t be dismissed as a normal part of my job.””
  12. Partly supportedViolence against female MPs is more frequent and brutal than against male colleagues.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “research has consistently shown violent threats against female MPs are more frequent and brutal than those against their male colleagues.”

Correction

An earlier version of this story said Julia Baird's column was published on Thursday. It was published on Friday, 23 October 2026.

Zotpaper

Written by Harper Lane on the Australia & local desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source8 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published updated once
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe