Connie Chan, Pelosi-backed candidate, calls for full arms embargo on Israel in California House race

San Francisco supervisor faces state senator Scott Wiener in race to succeed retiring Nancy Pelosi

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Connie Chan, the Democratic candidate endorsed by former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to succeed her in California's 11th congressional district, called for a full arms embargo on Israel during a televised debate on Thursday night, days before mail-in ballots are sent to voters. Chan said she would vote on day one to 'end a genocide in Gaza and to end an apartheid state' and oppose funding for Israel's Iron Dome missile defence system.

Chan, a San Francisco supervisor, is running against fellow Democrat and California state Senator Scott Wiener in the race to replace Pelosi, who is not seeking re-election at age 86. The winner of the primary, which takes place ahead of November's midterm elections, is expected to easily win the heavily Democratic district.

During the debate, Chan said she would push for a 'full arms embargo on the Israeli government' and that humanitarian aid must be prioritised. Wiener also described Israel's assault on Gaza as a genocide and said he would oppose funding for the Israeli military and the provision of bombs or offensive weapons. 'This government, and it's not just Netanyahu, is an absolute abomination, in my view, in terms of what it has inflicted on Gaza, in terms of Israel empowering settler violence and land grabs in the West Bank,' Wiener said.

Pelosi, who has long supported Israel in Congress and voted in favour of military aid, has endorsed Chan, underscoring the district's progressive lean even as her own record contrasts with Chan's stance. The race unfolds amid deep divisions in Congress over US policy toward Israel. Nearly all Senate Democrats recently backed an unsuccessful effort to require a State Department report on Israel's human rights practices, including the killings of nine Americans in the occupied West Bank. This week, several House members also introduced the Stop the Settlements Act, which would impose sanctions on individuals and entities involved in building or expanding illegal Israeli settlements.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The contest tests Democratic positions on Israel amid the Gaza war, with both candidates taking a hard line but Chan calling for a stricter full embargo.
  • The primary effectively decides the seat in this safe Democratic district, making the outcome a signal of progressive foreign policy priorities.
  • The November midterm elections, with all 435 House seats at stake, will shape control of Congress and US foreign policy direction.

Background

Nancy Pelosi has represented San Francisco for decades and served as House Speaker. Her endorsement of Chan, despite Pelosi's long record of supporting Israel and opposing boycott movements, reflects the district's progressive character. Both Chan and Wiener are seen as left-leaning Democrats, but Chan's call for an immediate full arms embargo is a more aggressive stance than Wiener's opposition to offensive weapons and military funding. The race takes place as the Gaza conflict continues and the United Nations and human rights groups have described Israel's actions as potentially genocidal.

Key Perspectives

Connie Chan: Advocated for a full arms embargo, ending US military aid to Israel, and prioritising humanitarian aid. Positions herself as ready to act immediately on day one in Congress. Scott Wiener: Also calls Israel's actions a genocide and opposes funding for the Israeli military and offensive weapons, but has not gone as far as calling for a total embargo. Emphasises opposition to settler violence and land grabs. Critics: Some Democrats and pro-Israel groups may argue that such positions risk alienating moderate voters and undermining bipartisan support for Israel, though the district's liberal makeup reduces electoral risk.

What to Watch

  • The primary election date and vote margin between Chan and Wiener, which could set the tone for other progressive challengers.
  • Whether other Democratic candidates in competitive districts adopt similar stances on Israel.
  • The progress of the Stop the Settlements Act and any Senate action on human rights reporting requirements.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.