The court heard Kilgour was assigned in February 2024 to Strike Force Bonnefin, formed in response to a major Sydney Morning Herald investigation into accusations against Jones. Jones, 85, is on trial for 19 counts of indecent assault and two counts of sexual touching against five male complainants over 17 years to 2020. He denies the allegations.
During cross-examination, Jones' barrister, Gabrielle Bashir, SC, suggested Kilgour's statement-making regarding a man dubbed 'J' was not a serious attempt to investigate his allegations. 'That's completely incorrect,' Kilgour said. Asked if this was an endeavour to attempt to 'shore up' J's allegation against Jones, he replied: 'No'.
J was a teenage athlete when he met Jones in the early 2000s. He alleges Jones bought him a car, paid him hundreds of dollars weekly and indecently assaulted him on multiple occasions.
Bashir put to Kilgour that dates created problems for J's account, including the timing of a car registration. Kilgour had run checks suggesting the car was not registered in J's name until he was nearly 19, not 17 as earlier claimed. The detective said the aim of the additional statement was to clarify dates.
Kilgour accepted that his formal statement omitted some details from earlier phone calls and shifted timelines forward by one to two years, aligning with independent records. Bashir suggested the changes were made to accord with the records. Kilgour said, 'It added to his account.' 'There's no way whether it was good or bad. It is what it was,' he said.
The detective also acknowledged that before taking J's third statement in December 2025, he emailed J redacted bank records showing payments ran from 2003 to 2012, rather than 2002 to 2006 or 2007 as J had earlier said. Kilgour said he was fulfilling a routine requisition from the Director of Public Prosecutions to record the statement before a court-ordered deadline, and that he attempted to show complete transparency.
He rejected any suggestion of impropriety. 'There's nothing untoward in what I've tried to do,' he said.
The trial continues.