Costa unveiled the latest set of budget numbers on Saturday, marking the first time since negotiations began last year that the EU's regional spending, known as cohesion policy, is a target for reductions. He proposed reducing cohesion by €8 billion compared with the previous proposal, which was put forward by Ireland last month in its role holding the rotating presidency of the Council of the EU.
The cuts were a setback for a coalition of 17 countries from Eastern and Southern Europe including Poland, Italy and Spain, who had rejected potential cuts to cohesion policy only days ago. But the plan was welcomed as "a first step" by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, who urged further cuts.
"This proposal is fit for tackling the challenges we are facing in our societies, and gives the European Union the necessary capacity to act," Costa said on Saturday morning.
Overall, the reductions amount to a cut of €204 billion, or 10.2%, from the European Commission's original proposal in July last year. Budget savings also came from foreign aid, cut by €7 billion, and competitiveness, cut by €20 billion. Another €10 billion in savings came from deferring repayments of the EU's post-Covid debt, which are due to start in 2028. One of the few items to receive additional funding was a rainy-day crisis fund, downsized by Ireland last month.
In a major development, Costa replaced an unpopular corporate tax proposal known as CORE with a levy on tech multinationals with a turnover exceeding €750 million annually globally and over €50 million in the EU. The proposed digital levy will cover online advertising, digital intermediation services and user-generated data for companies, and is expected to generate around €5 billion per year, according to an EU official. Most governments opposed CORE over fears it would undermine EU competitiveness.
To generate additional resources, Costa also suggested increasing taxes on non-collected plastic and electronic waste by levying an additional 25 cents per kilo, raising the share of a carbon imports' tax flowing to the bloc's budget to 100% from the current 75%, and exploring levies on crypto firms and national spectrum auctions. He also proposed phasing in taxes on tobacco products and polluting firms, known as the Emissions Trading System, for countries most affected.
Costa argued the new taxes will keep national contributions to Brussels under control. "With this proposal we have managed to come very close to the current level of national contributions," he said.
However, Merz criticised the cuts as insufficient. "The proposal now on the table is a first step, but its overall size remains too high," he said in a statement. On the other hand, the European People's Party's budget negotiator Siegfried Mureșan immediately criticised Costa's cuts, writing on X: "The plan is unacceptable to the European Parliament and cannot form the basis for our consent. The proposed cuts take the negotiations backwards."
EU governments are split between those wanting a smaller budget focused on defense and competitiveness, and those favouring a larger budget spent on traditional priorities such as farming and cohesion. Costa proposed modest cuts to cohesion to appease Germany and its allies, the so-called frugals.
The proposals set the scene for fraught discussions among the EU's 27 leaders at a summit next week, starting December 17. Costa expressed confidence governments would reach a deal among themselves during the summit. “I believe this proposal can bring us closer to a final agreement. And I will continue to work with all leaders to reach that objective,” he said. Even if agreed by governments, the budget must also be approved by the European Parliament.