Hindmarsh's report, written in August 2023, concluded that Joshua's symptoms of diabetes would have been clear and that medical help should have been sought earlier. The Thomases, who have always maintained their innocence, have applied to the Court of Appeal to challenge their convictions. Their eldest son Alessandro told The Guardian the family was unaware of Hindmarsh's GMC investigation or that his hospital had barred him from treating children with diabetes until shortly before the trial ended.
The GMC investigation into Hindmarsh began in November 2022. UCLH and Great Ormond Street Hospital both reported “multiple and wide-ranging concerns” about his practice to the General Medical Council, including cases where harm to patients was alleged. In March 2023, UCLH medical director Dr Tim Hodgson wrote to the GMC that Hindmarsh had breached a supervision order and independently advised two child patients to stop taking insulin at home. Hodgson told the GMC that one of the children had an episode of diabetic ketoacidosis, though he said it was not clear whether it coincided with the alleged advice. Hodgson said UCLH could not “accept the level of risk Professor Hindmarsh appears to pose to children and young people even with close clinical supervision”.
Hindmarsh had earlier provided an opinion in the Letby trial that two babies had been poisoned with insulin, a conclusion that seven experts have since argued was wrong. Letby, serving 15 whole-life sentences, has always maintained her innocence, and her lawyer has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission to refer her convictions back to the Court of Appeal.
When the CPS became aware of Hindmarsh’s situation in November 2025, it asked West Midlands police to raise the matter with him. Hindmarsh then disclosed that he had been barred from clinical practice and under GMC investigation. He later provided an expert witness self-certificate that mentioned two earlier tribunal rulings but omitted the April 2023 ruling, UCLH’s concerns, the fact that he had been barred from treating patients, and the termination of his honorary contract at Great Ormond Street. The CPS decided it could continue to rely on his evidence.
A CPS spokesperson said: "The CPS met all its disclosure obligations and no objections were raised by the defence at any stage in relation to expert evidence relied on by the prosecution." West Midlands police said they fulfilled their obligations around disclosure.
Hindmarsh applied for voluntary erasure from the medical register, which was granted in November 2024 and ended the GMC investigation without conclusion. He declined to answer questions from The Guardian about the investigation, his exclusion from practice or his disclosure.
Alessandro Thomas said: "Professor Hindmarsh's report of August 2023 was relied on throughout all the proceedings against my parents, but he said nothing in it about any of the proceedings against himself. ... This does not feel like justice."
The case has raised questions over whether Hindmarsh complied with the duty of expert witnesses to disclose material that might undermine their credibility, and over the use of expert witnesses in courts.