AustraliaDeveloping

Doctors excluded from safety meetings before Elizabeth Struhs death, inquest hears

Paediatrician had warned girl was at 'extremely high risk' in her mother's care

By LineZotpaper
Published
Updated
Read Time2 min
Sources5 outlets
Doctors who warned that Elizabeth Struhs was at "extremely high risk" in her mother's care were excluded from inter-agency safety meetings before she died, a Brisbane inquest has heard. The exclusion came despite a paediatrician's warning that the girl could be close to death again if her insulin was withheld.

The inquest into the death of Elizabeth Struhs heard on Thursday that, as she recovered from a 2019 diabetic emergency, an inter-agency Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect (SCAN) team held meetings about her case. A Child Safety officer testified she had not spoken with the paediatrician who warned Elizabeth could fall seriously ill within hours if her mother interfered with her insulin, but was aware of a colleague's notes at the time of the August meeting.

The paediatrician had told Queensland's Child Safety Department: "Elizabeth is at extremely high risk of harm in a household where mum has any responsibility of care as she does not believe in medication and refuses to use it. She can be close to death again in the future."

After Elizabeth was transferred out of the care of that paediatrician and other Brisbane-based medical staff to her local hospital on 12 August, they could not attend SCAN meetings without an invitation from Child Safety, the inquest was told.

Elizabeth had been airlifted to a Brisbane hospital in July 2019 after diabetic ketoacidosis left her in a coma and nearly killed her. The inquest also heard that doctors were so concerned about the religious beliefs of her mother, Kerrie Struhs, that they recommended she be subjected to an involuntary mental health assessment, because she delusionally believed her daughter would be healed from type 1 diabetes. Child safety officers nonetheless decided to return Elizabeth home to her mother's care in 2019, over the objections of Brisbane-based doctors.

Elizabeth died on 7 January 2022 at her home in Rangeville, Toowoomba, after her insulin was stopped by her father, Jason Struhs, who had joined the family's religious sect, known as "the Saints", in 2021. Her parents, brother and 11 other members of the group prayed around her while she lay unconscious on the living room floor for days.

Coroner Ainslie Kirkegaard heard evidence from three child safety officers involved in Elizabeth's case on Thursday.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The inquest is examining how child safety systems failed to protect Elizabeth despite repeated medical warnings.
  • The exclusion of doctors from SCAN meetings raises questions about whether critical health expertise reached decision-makers.
  • The coroner's findings could lead to changes in how Queensland agencies share information on children at risk.

Background

Elizabeth Struhs was a child with type 1 diabetes whose parents belonged to a religious group that rejected medicine. She died in 2022 after her insulin was withheld. The coronial inquest is examining the actions of child safety authorities, hospitals and other agencies between her 2019 hospitalisation and her death.

Key Perspectives

Doctors: They warned Elizabeth was at extreme risk in her mother's care, recommended an involuntary mental health assessment of the mother, and objected to the girl being returned home. Child Safety officers: They decided Elizabeth should go home with her mother in 2019. One officer testified she relied on a colleague's notes rather than speaking directly to the paediatrician. Critics and campaigners: They are likely to argue that excluding medical staff from safety meetings deprived the system of expert advice, and that the department overrode clear clinical warnings.

What to Watch

  • Further evidence from child safety officers, hospital staff and other witnesses as the inquest continues.
  • Whether the coroner's findings recommend changes to how SCAN teams incorporate medical expertise.
  • Any examination of why Elizabeth was returned home in 2019 despite doctors' objections.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe