The European Union is unlikely to accept a US-backed proposal to resume Russian gas deliveries to Europe through Ukraine, according to several EU officials, citing legal commitments to phase out Russian gas imports by 2027 and wariness of Moscow's past weaponisation of energy supplies.
The proposal, first reported by the Wall Street Journal and confirmed to the Kyiv Independent by people familiar with the matter, envisions selling Russian gas through a US intermediary to circumvent EU sanctions. It would allow gas to flow to Europe through the Druzhba pipeline, potentially generating transit revenue for Kyiv while offering European consumers access to Russian gas.
The idea is not entirely new; Ukrainian negotiators floated a similar arrangement during Istanbul talks with Russia in 2022 as a way to receive what they saw as reparations in the form of transport fees. US negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner also told their Ukrainian counterparts that several mechanisms could prevent the Kremlin from using the money to finance its war. Proceeds could be transferred to a US-proposed prosperity fund, which negotiating teams have discussed as part of a potential postwar arrangement; one option under consideration is an escrow account in a third-party jurisdiction. US negotiators told Ukrainian officials in September that the deal would be implemented only after Russia ends its war against Ukraine or agrees to a ceasefire.
Ukrainian officials have so far been reluctant to comment publicly on the initiative, but some privately remain cautious about rejecting it outright.
Several senior EU officials told the Kyiv Independent they are frustrated by Washington repeatedly putting forward initiatives without prior consultation. “The Americans can propose what they want. That doesn't mean we will agree to it,” one senior EU official said.
Beyond the diplomatic friction, the bloc has a legal barrier. EU legislation seeks to prevent Russian gas from entering the bloc indirectly through third countries. "Regardless of what happens, we are phasing out Russian gas and LNG. The last shipments will be finished by the end of next year," European Commission spokesperson Anna-Kaisa Itkonen said.
European Commission chief spokesperson Paula Pinho highlighted Moscow's history of using energy as a political tool. "We know far too well the hidden costs of being dependent on Russia for the purchase of fossil fuels. They have been weaponized, and we have been paying the price. We do not forget," she said, adding that Russia was the party that originally cut supplies.
The disagreement follows a similar clash in October, when the bloc dismissed a US proposal to place Russian immobilized assets in Europe under US custodianship. A senior EU official said the bloc's push for energy independence extends beyond the war in Ukraine, and that the Persian Gulf situation showed the importance of energy independence. The official added that the move away from fossil fuels and toward domestic energy sources would continue regardless of the outcome of the war.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The dispute exposes a significant transatlantic rift over post-war strategy, with the EU resisting a US-led plan that could undermine its energy sanctions and climate goals.
- A rejection of the plan would cement Europe's decoupling from Russian energy, accelerating the pivot to renewables and LNG imports from elsewhere, with direct consequences for global energy markets and European consumers.
- Ukraine is placed in a difficult diplomatic position, forced to balance short-term financial incentives against its long-term alignment with EU policy and the imperative to maintain Western unity against Russia.
Background
Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 prompted the EU to impose sweeping sanctions on Russian fossil fuels. In response, Moscow cut off most pipeline gas supplies to Europe, triggering a historic energy crisis and pushing the bloc to accelerate its transition to alternative energy sources. The Druzhba pipeline is one of the world's longest oil and gas export networks, stretching from Siberian fields through Ukraine to Central and Western Europe.
Key Perspectives
EU officials: Express frustration that Washington proposed the plan without consulting Brussels, and stress that the bloc is legally bound to phase out all Russian gas imports by 2027, a policy reinforced by Moscow's history of weaponising energy supplies.
US negotiators: View the plan as a pathway to a ceasefire that would provide Ukraine with transit revenue functioning as indirect Russian reparations, with safeguards such as a third-party escrow account to prevent the Kremlin from directing the funds toward its war effort.
Ukrainian officials: Have remained publicly cautious but privately recognise the potential financial benefits of the transit fees, which Kyiv could frame as compensation from Moscow, even as it navigates its relationship with its EU allies.
What to Watch
- Whether Kyiv ultimately takes a public stance on the proposal, as its position could test the balance of its relationships with Washington and Brussels.
- The EU's legislative deadline for the complete phase-out of Russian gas imports, set for the end of 2027, which leaves little practical room for the plan.
- The fate of the related US proposal on Russian assets, which the EU also dismissed in October, suggesting a broader pattern of friction over post-war financial arrangements.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe EU is unlikely to accept a US proposal to resume Russian gas deliveries to Europe through Ukraine.Kyiv Independent: “The European Union is unlikely to accept a U.S. proposal to resume Russian gas deliveries to Europe through Ukraine, EU officials told the Kyiv Independent”
- SupportedThe EU is legally committed to phasing out Russian gas imports by 2027.Kyiv Independent: “the EU has already legally committed to phasing out all Russian gas imports by 2027.”
- SupportedThe EU warns against renewed dependence on Russian energy because Moscow has used energy supplies as a political tool.Kyiv Independent: “Beyond its legal commitments, the bloc has little appetite for renewed dependence on Russian fossil fuels after Moscow repeatedly used energy supplies as a political tool.”
- Partly supportedEU officials say the bloc is unlikely to accept the proposal, citing legal commitments and wariness of Moscow’s past weaponisation of energy supplies.Kyiv Independent: “The European Union is unlikely to accept a U.S. proposal to resume Russian gas deliveries to Europe through Ukraine, EU officials told the Kyiv Independent”
- SupportedThe proposal envisions selling Russian gas through a US intermediary to circumvent EU sanctions.Kyiv Independent: “The idea, first reported by the Wall Street Journal and confirmed to the Kyiv Independent by people familiar with the matter, envisions selling Russian gas through a U.S. intermediary to circumvent EU sanctions .”
- SupportedUnder the proposal, Russian gas would flow through the Druzhba pipeline, potentially generating transit revenue for Ukraine.Kyiv Independent: “Under the proposed arrangement, Russian gas would flow to Europe through the Druzhba pipeline”
- SupportedSteve Witkoff and Jared Kushner told Ukrainian counterparts that mechanisms could prevent the Kremlin from using the money to finance its war.Kyiv Independent: “U.S. negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner also told their Ukrainian counterparts that several mechanisms could prevent the Kremlin from using the money to finance its war.”
- SupportedThe proceeds could be transferred to a US-proposed prosperity fund.Kyiv Independent: “The proceeds could be transferred to a U.S.-proposed prosperity fund, which negotiating teams have been discussing as part of a potential postwar arrangement.”
- SupportedUS negotiators told Ukrainian officials in September the deal would be implemented only after Russia ends its war or agrees to a ceasefire.Kyiv Independent: “U.S. negotiators told Ukrainian officials in September that the deal would be implemented only after Russia ends its war against Ukraine or agrees to a ceasefire .”
- SupportedA senior EU official said, “The Americans can propose what they want. That doesn't mean we will agree to it.”Kyiv Independent: “"The Americans can propose what they want. That doesn't mean we will agree to it," one senior EU official told the Kyiv Independent.”
- SupportedAnna-Kaisa Itkonen said, “Regardless of what happens, we are phasing out Russian gas and LNG. The last shipments will be finished by the end of next year.”Kyiv Independent: “"Regardless of what happens, we are phasing out Russian gas and LNG . The last shipments will be finished by the end of next year," European Commission spokesperson Anna-Kaisa Itkonen told the Kyiv Independent.”
- SupportedPaula Pinho said, “We know far too well the hidden costs of being dependent on Russia for the purchase of fossil fuels. They have been weaponized, and we have been paying the price. We do not forget.”Kyiv Independent: “"We know far too well the hidden costs of being dependent on Russia for the purchase of fossil fuels. They have been weaponized, and we have been paying the price. We do not forget," European Commission chief spokesperson Paula Pinho said.”