Pesticides sold by European chemical companies were named in more than 1,600 poisoning reports in Brazil last year, with about a third involving substances banned from use on farms in the European Union, an investigation by Unearthed and Public Eye has found. The reports include deaths and severe injuries among farm workers.
Analysis of Brazilian health ministry data by Unearthed and Public Eye, published Tuesday, found that 1,605 of 2,857 poisoning reports that named an identifiable agricultural product named brands sold by European pesticide companies. Under Brazilian law, healthcare professionals must submit reports for all suspected pesticide poisoning cases, though laboratory confirmation is rare and diagnoses often rely on clinical judgment.
European companies are not prohibited from manufacturing chemicals banned on EU farms, as long as they export them to countries where they are legally allowed. Among the products cited is Reglone, a diquat-based weedkiller made by Syngenta in Huddersfield, UK. Diquat was banned in the UK in 2020 over risks to people living near sprayed fields.
Nelson Castoldi, who died on his family farm in Rio Grande do Sul last year after accidentally drinking Reglone from a bottle he mistook for a soft drink, was one of the cases described. “That poison, Reglone, should be banned in Brazil,” his son Ivan Castoldi said. “Not because of what happened to us, but because of its toxicity.” The investigation found Reglone was named in 44 reports, including four deaths.
In another case, Sidnei Souza de Oliveira suffered severe leg injuries after a jug of Dormex, a cyanamide-based pesticide made in Germany, spilled on him. “After 15 days, my leg was black. Chunks of flesh were falling off,” he said. Cyanamide was banned in the EU in 2008 because of health concerns for farm workers.
Syngenta products were cited 425 times in the poisoning reports, BASF 179 times, and Bayer's Roundup was frequently named, including in 12 deaths. A Syngenta spokesperson said almost half the cases attributed to the company were not classified as confirmed poisonings and said the evidence was being selectively interpreted to support a predetermined conclusion. “There are real people behind these statistics,” the spokesperson added.
Bayer said its products were safe when used according to label instructions and questioned the reliability of the data, noting that “Roundup” is widely used as a generic term that could refer to weedkillers made by other manufacturers or counterfeit products. BASF said it was deeply concerned by reports of poisoning that might be linked to its products and noted that some incidents might have involved intentional ingestion of crop protection products, which it described as deliberate misuse.
Nina Schrank, a senior campaigner at Greenpeace UK, called the findings a "deadly double standard". "If a pesticide is too dangerous to use in Britain, it should be too dangerous to export," she said.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 9 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says European-made pesticides were named in 1,605 poisoning reports in Brazil, according to the investigation.World news | The Guardian: “European-made pesticides named in 1,605 poisoning reports in Brazil last year.”
- Partly supportedThe summary says a third of the cases involved chemicals banned on EU farms.World news | The Guardian: “About a third of the cases involved chemicals banned from use on farms in the EU because of the risks they pose to people and the environment.”
- SupportedThe investigation found that 1,605 of 2,857 reports naming an identifiable agricultural product named brands sold by European pesticide companies.World news | The Guardian: “of 2,857 poisoning reports that named an identifiable agricultural product, 1,605 named brands sold by European pesticide companies.”
- Partly supportedThe reports included deaths and severe injuries among farm workers.World news | The Guardian: “Farm workers in Brazil have described their flesh rotting, skin burning, difficulty breathing and vomiting after using the chemicals at work, according to the report. A small number have died accidentally or killed themselves by drinking the pesticides.”
- SupportedBrazilian law requires healthcare professionals to report all suspected pesticide-poisoning cases, and laboratory confirmation is rare.World news | The Guardian: “Under Brazilian law, reports must be submitted by healthcare professionals to Brazil’s national disease notification system in all suspected pesticide poisoning cases.”
- SupportedIvan Castoldi said, “That poison, Reglone, should be banned in Brazil. Not because of what happened to us, but because of its toxicity.”World news | The Guardian: ““That poison, Reglone, should be banned in Brazil,” he added. “Not because of what happened to us, but because of its toxicity.””
- SupportedReglone was named in 44 reports, including four deaths.World news | The Guardian: “The investigation found Reglone was specifically named in 44 reports, including four deaths.”
- Partly supportedSidnei Souza de Oliveira suffered severe leg injuries after a jug of Dormex spilled on him, and said, “After 15 days, my leg was black. Chunks of flesh were falling off.”World news | The Guardian: “Sidnei Souza de Oliveira, 49, suffered a severe injury after a jug of Dormex spilled on his leg while he was filling a sprayer. ... “After 15 days, my leg was black. Chunks of flesh were falling off,” Oliveira said.”
- SupportedCyanamide was banned from use in the EU in 2008 because of health concerns, particularly for farm workers spraying it.World news | The Guardian: “Dormex contains cyanamide, which was banned from use in the EU in 2008 because of concerns about its effects on human health, particularly among farm workers spraying the chemical.”
- SupportedSyngenta products were cited 425 times and BASF products 179 times in the reports.World news | The Guardian: “Syngenta products were cited 425 times in the poisoning reports, and BASF 179 times.”
- SupportedA Syngenta spokesperson said almost half the cases attributed to the company were not classified as confirmed poisonings and said the evidence was selectively interpreted to support a predetermined conclusion.World news | The Guardian: “A Syngenta spokesperson said almost half the Brazilian cases attributed to the company were not classified as confirmed poisonings ... the evidence was “being selectively interpreted to support a predetermined conclusion”.”
- SupportedGreenpeace UK campaigner Nina Schrank called the findings a “deadly double standard” and said, “If a pesticide is too dangerous to use in Britain, it should be too dangerous to export.”World news | The Guardian: “Nina Schrank, a senior campaigner at Greenpeace UK, said the findings were a “deadly double standard”. “If a pesticide is too dangerous to use in Britain, it should be too dangerous to export.”