LLM agents continue working after tasks succeed, receiving follow-up input that sometimes falsely accuses their completed work. This paper introduces CAVE-Bench, a of 365 tasks across six domains where agents first reach a verified correct state, then face a false accusation that cannot be settled locally because decisive facts are outside the agent's reach. The correct response is to preserve the work and ask for missing evidence.
Testing 14 models revealed that false accusations damage correct work in up to 60.06% of runs, and stronger models often damage even after recovering supporting evidence. The same model behaves differently across different harnesses. A harness gate driven by live signals reduces replayed harm by 74%. These findings highlight preserving correct work under unsupported accusation as a distinct safety challenge for long-lived agents.