National Highways has discovered a new fault in speed cameras on English roads that may have let drivers escape fines; the Home Office has revoked approval for the footage to be used as evidence, and the agency says it will end its contract with operator Verra Mobility.
The fault affected all variable speed cameras on smart motorways, as well as cameras on a section of the A14 between Huntingdon and Cambridge and the A1 approach junction to the A14. Roads minister Justin Madders said: "We can't take chances with this. If we're going to prosecute people, we need to be confident the system is working as it should. That's why we've taken the action we have."
The latest problem comes after National Highways blamed a separate “anomaly” in December 2025 that led to 2,650 wrongful speed camera activations between 2021 and the end of last year. Those wrongly fined have been reimbursed. The agency said that while continuing to test the system it found a further issue “relating to how some of these cameras may activate in specific and rare circumstances.” It said that according to its calculations, “the circumstances in which the latest issue could occur are extremely rare, and there is no evidence to suggest it has impacted enforcement.” Nevertheless, it said it was taking immediate steps to ensure compliance and would deploy additional traffic officer patrols to monitor the sites.
National Highways said Verra Mobility’s camera system had been selected on the basis that it maintained Home Office approval. Since that is no longer the case, it said it was ending its contractual relationship to use the cameras for enforcement and was considering all further commercial and legal options that may be appropriate.
In a statement, Verra Mobility said it “remains fully committed to delivering reliable, innovative technology that helps make roads safer.” The BBC has contacted Verra Mobility for comment.
Rod Dennis, senior policy officer at the RAC motoring organisation, said: "Malfunctioning speed cameras on smart motorways do more than just let speeding drivers get away with breaking the law and endangering lives – they further undermine confidence in the very types of road we know drivers already have serious misgivings about."
Madders said enforcement of speed limits continues through a range of different tactics, including mobile cameras and marked and unmarked police patrols, but acknowledged the camera system will not be fully fixed until sometime next year.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Drivers who might have been wrongly fined or escaped fines could face uncertainty; the fault undermines trust in smart motorway enforcement.
- National Highways' decision to end its contract with Verra Mobility signals a potential shift in how speed camera technology is procured and vetted.
- The issue adds to public skepticism about smart motorways, which the RAC says drivers already have serious misgivings about.
Background
Speed cameras on England's motorways and major A roads are used to enforce variable speed limits. In December 2025, National Highways revealed an "anomaly" that caused 2,650 wrongful activations between 2021 and 2025, with affected drivers reimbursed. Home Office approval is required for camera footage to be admissible as evidence in court.
Key Perspectives
Roads minister Justin Madders: Said the government cannot take chances and must be confident the system works before prosecuting anyone, adding that action has been taken.
Verra Mobility: Said it remains fully committed to delivering reliable, innovative technology that helps make roads safer.
Rod Dennis (RAC): Said malfunctioning cameras not only let speeding drivers endanger lives but further erode confidence in smart motorways.
National Highways: Said it is ending its contract with Verra Mobility because the cameras no longer hold Home Office approval, and is considering all legal and commercial options.
What to Watch
- Whether Verra Mobility challenges the contract termination or takes legal action.
- How soon National Highways can fully fix the camera system, with the minister expecting completion next year.
- Whether additional wrongful fines from the latest fault come to light, and how they are handled.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedFaulty speed cameras may have allowed drivers to escape fines.BBC News: “Further problems with the accuracy of speed cameras on English roads have been uncovered which may have allowed drivers to slip through the cracks and escape fines.”
- SupportedThe Home Office revoked approval for footage from the cameras to be used as evidence.BBC News: “The Home Office has revoked approval that allows footage from the cameras to be used as evidence in legal proceedings.”
- SupportedNational Highways said it would end its contract with Verra Mobility to use the cameras for enforcement.BBC News: “US firm Verra Mobility operates the cameras but National Highways said it will now end the contract.”
- SupportedThe newly discovered fault affected all variable speed cameras on smart motorways, plus cameras on part of the A14 between Huntingdon and Cambridge and at the A1 approach junction to the A14.BBC News: “The fault affected all of the variable speed cameras on smart motorways, and a section of the A14 between Huntingdon and Cambridge as well as the A1 approach junction to the A14.”
- SupportedRoads minister Justin Madders said, “We can't take chances with this. If we're going to prosecute people, we need to be confident the system is working as it should. That's why we've taken the action we have.”BBC News: “Roads minister Justin Madders said: "We can't take chances with this. "If we're going to prosecute people, we need to be confident the system is working as it should. That's why we've taken the action we have."”
- SupportedIn December 2025, National Highways blamed a separate anomaly that led to 2,650 wrongful speed camera activations between 2021 and the end of 2025.BBC News: “In December 2025, National Highways, which runs England's motorways, blamed an "anomaly" in how variable speed cameras were interacting with speed limit signs on some A roads and motorways. [...] The fault led to 2,650 wrongful speed camera activations between 2021 and the end of last year.”
- SupportedDrivers who were wrongly fined have been reimbursed.BBC News: “Those who had been wrongfully fined have been reimbursed.”
- SupportedNational Highways said the latest issue could occur only in extremely rare circumstances and there was no evidence it had affected enforcement.BBC News: “It said that according to its calculations, "the circumstances in which the latest issue could occur are extremely rare, and there is no evidence to suggest it has impacted enforcement".”
- Partly supportedNational Highways said it was taking immediate steps to ensure compliance and would put additional traffic officer patrols at the sites.BBC News: “Nevertheless, it said it was "taking immediate steps to ensure compliance is maintained at relevant locations". It said it would put further traffic officer patrols in place to monitor the sites.”
- SupportedVerra Mobility said it “remains fully committed to delivering reliable, innovative technology that helps make roads safer.”BBC News: “In a statement, Verra Mobility said it "remains fully committed to delivering reliable, innovative technology that helps make roads safer".”
- SupportedRAC senior policy officer Rod Dennis said malfunctioning cameras undermine confidence in smart motorways and drivers already have serious misgivings about those roads.BBC News: “Rod Dennis, senior policy officer at the RAC motoring organisation, said: "Malfunctioning speed cameras on smart motorways do more than just let speeding drivers get away with breaking the law and endangering lives – they further undermine confidence in the very types of road we know drivers already have serious misgivings about."”
- SupportedMadders said speed-limit enforcement continues through tactics including mobile cameras and marked and unmarked police patrols.BBC News: “Madders said that the enforcement of speed limits continues to be conducted through a range of different tactics, including mobile cameras as well as marked and unmarked police patrols.”