U.S. District Judge Mustafa Kasubhai ruled Monday that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers violated a court order by continuing to make warrantless arrests in Oregon. The judge further found that an agency deportation officer fabricated details in an arrest report to make it appear lawful, and ordered the federal government to provide all arrest documents to Innovation Law Lab and ICE to produce body-worn camera footage for arrests conducted on or after Sept. 1, 2026.
The ruling stems from a class action lawsuit filed by Innovation Law Lab challenging ICE’s ability to arrest people without a warrant. Kasubhai had issued a preliminary order earlier this year restricting warrantless arrests to cases where the person is likely to flee, and requiring documentation of those cases.
Attorneys for the federal government denied the claims of non-compliance. In his order Monday, Kasubhai found that ICE had continued making warrantless arrests and failed to properly document them. He wrote that the government’s figure of 13 arrests without a proper warrant was “highly unlikely” and found that ICE had conducted “significantly more” than 13 warrantless arrests in Oregon between February and August 2026.
The judge was particularly critical of an ICE deportation officer identified as J.G., who testified that he wrote false information in an arrest report, known as an I-213. In the report, the agent claimed he knew the detainee’s immigration status before making a stop in Medford, Oregon last July. On the witness stand, he admitted this was not true.
“It defies logic that such consequential errors in the I-213 form are merely a ‘mistake,’” Kasubhai wrote. “The Court finds that he did not make a mistake in the I-213. He lied in an official record to facilitate the impression he was conducting a lawful warrant-based arrest.”
Kasubhai also noted errors in ICE documentation, including one report that said an arrest took place in California when it actually occurred in Oregon. He wrote that many reports contained nearly identical boilerplate language.
“ICE agents’ boilerplate repetition of their ‘unawareness’ of community ties is a clear example of their failure to conduct simple law enforcement investigative duties. This is sloppy work,” Kasubhai wrote.
The order was issued as the judge considers a similar case in federal court in Eugene. During an evidentiary hearing Monday, a man identified as L.A.M.A testified he was arrested in a Walmart parking lot in Albany on June 18 without being shown a warrant. He said agents told him they would drive him to the Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma, but eventually left him on the streets of Portland. His son had to drive from Albany to pick him up.
“Anguish, quite a bit of it. Anguish, frustration — how your life can change in 24 hours,” L.A.M.A. told the court in Spanish.
Kasubhai also questioned the broader integrity of ICE’s records in the state, writing, “There is no telling how many other agents in Oregon engaged in similar misconduct, which calls into question the veracity of all I-213 forms completed by ICE officers in Oregon.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- A federal judge has found that a federal law enforcement officer deliberately lied in an official record to cover up an unlawful arrest, challenging the credibility of ICE’s internal documentation.
- The court’s finding that the number of warrantless arrests is far higher than the government disclosed suggests a systemic pattern of non-compliance with judicial oversight in Oregon.
- The case tests the limits of judicial authority to enforce procedural safeguards on federal immigration enforcement.
Background
The class action against ICE was filed by Innovation Law Lab in Oregon, challenging the agency’s use of warrantless arrests. Judge Kasubhai previously ordered that ICE could only make a warrantless arrest if the person posed a flight risk, and mandated documentation of those instances. The current ruling finds ICE systematically violated that order. Oregon has specific policies limiting state and local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement, which has historically made it a flashpoint in the national immigration debate.
Key Perspectives
- Innovation Law Lab: The legal group brought the class action arguing ICE could not arrest people without a warrant in Oregon and that the agency was violating Judge Kasubhai’s preliminary order.
- Judge Mustafa Kasubhai: Found that ICE conducted hundreds of warrantless arrests in violation of his order, that an officer fabricated details in an official report, and that the government’s submitted figures were unreliable.
- Federal Government: The government’s attorneys denied the claims that ICE was not complying with the court’s order, though the judge ultimately ruled against them on the key facts.
What to Watch
- The judge ordered ICE to produce all body-worn camera footage for arrests from September 2026 onward, a significant expansion of oversight.
- The ongoing evidentiary hearings in the related Eugene case could yield similar findings about ICE conduct.
- Whether the Department of Justice or ICE takes administrative action against the officer the judge found lied in his report.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedOn Monday, Kasubhai found ICE officers violated his order by continuing to make warrantless arrests in Oregon.OPB: “In his order Monday, Kasubhai found that ICE has continued to conduct warrantless arrests and failed to properly document those instances, both in violation of his February order.”
- SupportedKasubhai found that an ICE deportation officer lied in an arrest report to make it appear the arrest was lawful.OPB: ““The Court finds that he did not make a mistake in the I-213. He lied in an official record to facilitate the impression he was conducting a lawful warrant-based arrest.””
- SupportedKasubhai wrote, “The Court finds that he did not make a mistake in the I-213. He lied in an official record to facilitate the impression he was conducting a lawful warrant-based arrest.”OPB: ““The Court finds that he did not make a mistake in the I-213. He lied in an official record to facilitate the impression he was conducting a lawful warrant-based arrest.””
- SupportedThe judge ordered the federal government to provide all arrest documents to Innovation Law Lab.OPB: “In his new order, Kasubhai is now requiring the federal government to provide all arrest documents to Innovation Law Lab.”
- SupportedICE must produce body-worn camera footage for arrests conducted on or after Sept. 1, 2026.OPB: “ICE must also produce all body-worn camera footage for arrests conducted on or after Sept. 1, 2026.”
- SupportedKasubhai’s preliminary order allowed warrantless arrests only if the person was likely to flee and required documentation of those arrests.OPB: “U.S. District Judge Mustafa Kasubhai issued a preliminary order earlier this year that ICE could only make a warrantless arrest if the person is likely to flee, and the agency must send documentation of those arrests to Innovation Law Lab.”
- SupportedThe federal government said only 13 arrests were conducted without a proper warrant.OPB: “In documents provided to Innovation Law Lab, the government had said only 13 arrests were conducted without a proper warrant.”
- SupportedKasubhai found ICE conducted significantly more than 13 warrantless arrests in Oregon between February and August 2026.OPB: ““The Court finds that ICE officers conducted significantly more than 13 warrantless arrests in Oregon between February 2026 and August 2026,” he wrote.”
- SupportedAttorneys for the federal government denied the claims that ICE was not complying with the order.OPB: “Attorneys for the federal government have denied those claims.”
- SupportedJ.G. testified that he wrote false information in an I-213 report about knowing the detainee’s immigration status before the Medford stop, and admitted that was not true.OPB: “During the September hearing, J.G. testified that, while arresting a man in Medford last July, he had written false information in an arrest report, known as an I-213. In the report, the agent attested that he knew the detainee’s immigration status before making the stop. On the witness stand, he admitted that was not true.”
- SupportedL.A.M.A testified that he was arrested without being shown a warrant at a Walmart parking lot in Albany on June 18.OPB: “During an evidentiary hearing Monday, a man identified as L.A.M.A testified that he was arrested in a Walmart parking lot in Albany on June 18. ... He said he was never shown a warrant during his arrest.”
- SupportedL.A.M.A told the court in Spanish, “Anguish, quite a bit of it. Anguish, frustration — how your life can change in 24 hours.”OPB: “Clearly emotional, he told the court in Spanish the experience left him feeling, “Anguish, quite a bit of it. Anguish, frustration — how your life can change in 24 hours.””