Five EU countries are expected to announce on Monday a deal to establish the bloc’s first return hub for irregular migrants outside the European Union, to be located in Rwanda and potentially operating in mid-2027, sources familiar with the negotiations have said.
Denmark, Austria, Germany, the Netherlands and Greece are in the final stages of talks with Rwanda's government to establish a pilot project hosting a few hundred people deported from the five member states, two people familiar with the matter told Euronews. The announcement is set for Vienna on Monday afternoon. Rwanda's Interior Minister Vincent Biruta will join the ministers at a migration conference, while Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker and Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen will hold a press conference a few metres from the venue.
The return hub would consist of open facilities housing migrants, who would receive a residence permit and be free to move around the country, with the aim of integrating them into local society and the labour market, according to the sources. Diplomatic sources told RTÉ News the centre would initially host about 100 people, with each of the five nations possibly sending around 20 migrants, and that Kigali was inclined to name the site a “welcome centre” to underscore the possibility for some migrants to stay and work.
The announcement will mark the culmination of an EU push to boost deportations launched in 2024, following a reform earlier this year that granted authorities broader detention powers and allowed for the creation of return hubs. Proponents argue such centres could facilitate repatriations and act as a deterrent for would-be irregular migrants. Migrant arrivals have steadily declined over the past three years, but the issue remains politically charged, fuelling far-right electoral gains across the bloc. Currently less than 30% of people ordered to leave the EU are returned to their country of origin.
Human rights groups have raised concerns. Human Rights Watch pointed to Rwanda's "well-established record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention, ill-treatment in detention" and its support for an armed anti-government group in the neighbouring Democratic Republic of Congo. Clementine de Montjoye, the group's senior Africa researcher, said: "Paying Kigali to host a deportation programme would not only cause suffering and harm to those deported, it would finance and provide political leverage to a government responsible for serious human rights abuses at home and abroad."
The five governments said the project would comply fully with EU law and international obligations and would be run in partnership with international organisations such as the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and the International Organization for Migration (IOM). However, UNHCR and IOM are not directly involved in negotiations on the procedures. An IOM spokesperson told Euronews: "IOM's support requires a formal request from the receiving government, and assurances that adequate safeguards are in place." The same agency told RTÉ News it was in discussions with some EU countries "on plans for the establishment of return hubs or similar mechanisms."
Legal complications may arise when deportations to Rwanda begin next year. The European Court of Human Rights prohibits countries from transferring individuals to states or situations where they may face violations of fundamental rights. “With this system, migrants may be subjected to torture and inhuman or degrading treatment,” Eleonora Celoria from Asgi, an Italian association of legal experts specialised in migration, told Euronews. A similar agreement between Rwanda and the United Kingdom was ruled unlawful by the UK Supreme Court in 2023 because of the risk of human rights abuses.
The five EU countries will bear the entire financial burden of deportations and accommodation in Rwanda, but there are no current estimates of total costs. A comparable project set up by Italy in Albania had a total bill of €670 million over five years. A study from an Italian university said each available place in Albania costs over €153,000, compared with approximately €21,000 per place in Sicily.
Nineteen of the EU's 27 governments have expressed support for the approach, describing it in a joint letter to EU leaders last June as an "innovative solution" for migration management. Spain and France have rebuked the deportation scheme. UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham said last week that Britain was following "with interest" the European push on return hubs, as it weighs its own next steps to curb illegal migration.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The first return hub outside the EU could set a precedent for outsourcing migration enforcement to third countries, affecting thousands of migrants and reshaping EU asylum policy.
- Human rights concerns are central: critics warn of potential abuses in Rwanda, and legal challenges from the European Court of Human Rights could delay or block the project.
- Financial costs and effectiveness are uncertain, with past examples (Italy-Albania) showing high per-person expenses and low returns on investment.
Background
Rwanda has previously entered migration deals with the United Kingdom (scrapped after a UK Supreme Court ruling in 2023) and the United States, which sends third-country nationals there in exchange for financial support. EU migration rules were tightened earlier this year, allowing for the creation of return hubs outside the bloc. The five countries involved, Denmark, Austria, Germany, the Netherlands and Greece, have been among the strongest advocates for stricter deportation policies. Migration remains a politically charged issue across Europe, fuelling far-right electoral gains, even as irregular arrivals have declined over the past three years.
Key Perspectives
Human Rights Watch: said Rwanda has a "well-established record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention, ill-treatment in detention" and support for an armed anti-government group in the DRC, and warned that paying Kigali to host the programme would "finance and provide political leverage to a government responsible for serious human rights abuses at home and abroad."
Eleonora Celoria (Asgi, Italian legal experts association): said migrants "may be subjected to torture and inhuman or degrading treatment" under the system.
Five EU governments (Denmark, Austria, Germany, Netherlands, Greece): said the project would comply fully with EU law and international obligations and would be run in partnership with UNHCR and IOM.
IOM spokesperson: said the agency's support requires a formal request and "assurances that adequate safeguards are in place," and that it was in discussions with some EU countries on plans for return hubs.
IOM spokesperson (separate statement to RTÉ): said the agency "has a long history of providing assistance to migrants in situations of transit, including in complex contexts."
What to Watch
- The full text of the Monday announcement and any specific safeguards or monitoring mechanisms outlined.
- Whether UNHCR and IOM agree to participate and under what conditions.
- Legal challenges from the European Court of Human Rights or national courts once deportations commence in 2027.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 2 sources: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedFive EU countries are set to announce a Rwanda return-hub deal in Vienna on Monday.Euronews: “The agreement between Kigali’s government and five EU member states is set to be announced on Monday in Vienna, after months of negotiations, two people familiar with the matter told Euronews.”
- SupportedThe Rwanda facility would be the EU’s first return hub outside the bloc.Euronews: “Rwanda will host the first-ever EU return hub built outside the bloc, in an unprecedented move to send irregular migrants to countries with which they have no connection.”
- SupportedThe hub could become operational in mid-2027.Euronews: “The first pilot project could be announced on Monday and become operational in mid-2027”
- Reports differThe pilot would host a few hundred people.Euronews: “According to the sources, the first hub would be a “pilot project”, set to host a few hundred people deported from the five EU countries, starting in spring or summer 2027.”
- SupportedThe hub would use open facilities, with migrants receiving residence permits and freedom to move around Rwanda.Euronews: “It would consist of open facilities housing migrants, who would receive a residence permit and be free to move around the country”
- SupportedHuman Rights Watch described Rwanda as having a “well-established record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention, ill-treatment in detention”.RTÉ News: “Human Rights Watch pointing to its "well-established record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention, ill-treatment in detention"”
- SupportedClementine de Montjoye said paying Kigali to host the programme would cause suffering and harm and provide political leverage to Rwanda’s government.RTÉ News: “"Paying Kigali to host a deportation programme would not only cause suffering and harm to those deported, it would finance and provide political leverage to a government responsible for serious human rights abuses at home and abroad," said the group's senior Africa researcher, Clementine de Montjoye.”
- SupportedThe five governments said the project would comply with EU law and international obligations and operate in partnership with organisations including UNHCR and IOM.Euronews: “The five governments said the project would comply fully with EU law and international obligations, and would be run in partnership with international organisations such as the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and the International Organization for Migration (IOM).”
- SupportedAn IOM spokesperson said IOM’s support requires a formal request from the receiving government and assurances that safeguards are in place.Euronews: ““IOM’s support requires a formal request from the receiving government, and assurances that adequate safeguards are in place,” a spokesperson for the organization told Euronews.”
- SupportedThe UK Supreme Court ruled a similar Rwanda–UK agreement unlawful in 2023 because of the risk of human-rights abuses.Euronews: “A similar agreement between Kigali and the United Kingdom, under which Britain would send asylum seekers to Rwanda, was ruled unlawful by the UK Supreme Court in 2023 because of the risk of human rights abuses.”
- SupportedItaly’s Albania project had a total bill of €670 million over five years.Euronews: “A similar project set up by Italy in Albania sparked controversy over its costs, with a total bill of €670 million over a five-year partnership.”
- SupportedThe study put the cost per available place in Albania at over €153,000, compared with approximately €21,000 per place in Sicily.Euronews: “Each available place in Albania costs over €153,000, whereas comparable facilities in Sicily could accommodate migrants for approximately €21,000 per place.”